[Sun Care] Once again - "chemical" sunscreens are NOT bad for melasma

Sun Care

Sharing this Instagram post that labmuffin shared on her story. It's focused on melasma in general and specifically addresses the misconception recently peddled by *certain* hyperpigmentation- skin-of-colour-focused doctors that not only do organic filters produce drastically more heat in comparison with mineral ones, but also said heat can impact melasma (both assertions are false).

EDIT: Previously the word "doctors" was in quotation marks, which - as is discussed below - was in poor taste and had ultimately racist connotations.

Posted Aug 24, 2020, 4:26 PM UTC · edited

3156
throwaway10023122•

The person you're referring to has a Medical Degree but cannot practice medicine in England and didn't undergo the 2-year Foundation Programme mandatory to practice, or the additional 3-5 years to become a GP or specialist.

Yes, she is a "Doctor" based on her degree. LabMuffin is also a "Doctor" based on her phD in Chemistry. Neither is a Doctor of Medicine.

18
Jazzy261•

So I'm hearing that this doctor isn't "board certified"... but is the info she gave true or not?

3
dimdim1997OP•
  1. She doesn't know (or at least didn't know until very recently) that mineral filters also work largely by absorption. I get a "regular" derm missing this, but when you specialise in hyperpigmentation, that knowledge is a must imo, especially when you shun organic sunscreens on the basis of your misunderstanding.
  2. In this video where she reviews Hyram's skincare routine, after the 12:30 mark she claims that your sunscreen loses so much of its protection as time goes by that at midday "you're completely exposed", which you then ought to fix by reapplying powder SPF. First, sunscreen and especially water-resistant sunscreen doesn't lose all its protection in the matter of some 2-3 hours, but more importantly - no professional specialising in hyperpigmentation has any place touting powder as a reliable way to get any sun protection, specifically when one believes there isn't any "residual" protection from the morning sunscreen application.
  3. In this video, around the 1:30 mark when talking about the organic filters we should be looking for, she lists Avobenzone, Oxybenzone, Octinoxate and Ecamsule because those are "the best ones"? A UK-based (i.e. having access to the new-generation organic filters) doctor mentioning sh*t like Oxybenzone as opposed to any of the Uvinuls and Tinosorbs is insane.
  4. On her own website she advertises her sunscreen as a "professional strength sunblock", which with its 50 ML is supposed to be a "10-week supply". What the hell is a "professional strength sunblock"? She is preying on people's ignorance - because *every* sunblock *everywhere* undergoes the exact same testing to determine its protection - while basically encouraging people to significantly underapply sunscreen.
  5. As already addressed, she discourages organic-sunscreen use because the heat they produce might influence melasma. The Instagram post proves that to be false. Furthermore, in this video, after the 2:16 mark while discussing Inkey List's Q10 serum, she uses the same logic to discourage the use of antioxidants during the day - because apparently *antioxidants* can lead to such strong chemical reactions on the skin that your hyperpigmentation may worsen??? Again - we're talking about basic af antioxidants here. That's insane.
14
All_Consuming_Void•

One thing is, maybe she means the "10 week supply" as, they send you enough packages to theoretically last you 10wks

2
dimdim1997OP•

I think the logic is:

  • 1 week has 5 workdays -> you wear sunscreen only when you go to work -> you wear sunscreen only on your face so 1 ML per application -> you don't reapply -> 10weeks * 5days * 1ml = 50 ML, which is the amount of the sunscreen.
3
All_Consuming_Void•

Yiiikes... Not to mention her sunscreen probably ACTUALLY only lasts 2hrs lmao

2
CoughCoolCoolCool•

What? Heat absolutely does impact melasma

3
dimdim1997OP•

Did you read the Instagram post? The issue is that organic sunscreens do not impart anywhere near enough (especially in comparison with mineral sunscreens) heat to impact melasma.

5
CoughCoolCoolCool•

You said it’s false that heat doesn’t impact melasma

3
dimdim1997OP•

said heat can impact melasma

"Said" referring to the heat from organic sunscreens.

2
All_Consuming_Void•

Furthermore, Vanita's UK audience is beiong led to believe that the readily available oragnic sunscreens with impeccable protection are somehow bad for them, and that they need to order overpriced American paint...

2
dimdim1997OP•

YES. I remember in the past trying to see if I could get some EltaMD here in Europe and it was basically luxury. And that's without taking into account the currency change.

2
AutoModeratorMOD•

Hi everyone! SkincareAddiction is a friendly community of skincare enthusiasts.

In search of your own skincare advice?

See something that breaks our rules? Please report it!

Everyone is welcome in this community; remember to be kind and assume good faith :)

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
skincarelover_•

I don’t see a problem with people sharing evidence-based counter information but I don’t think you “quoting” doctors was necessary. A lot of us know who you’re referring to, and while I don’t personally subscribe to her channel, she is a doctor. You can disagree with a woman of color without implicitly questioning their qualifications. I know several physicians who have different opinions on ingredients since research is either inconclusive and has not yielded a straight yes or no answer or the control groups are too small and there haven’t been as many studies as some doctors would like in order to dispel their suspicions. As a result, several doctors take the extra-cautionary route while others don’t. I can especially understand why a doctor who is especially focused on dark skinned women (particularly black women) would want to be extra cautious. Again, I don’t know if it was your intention, but I’m a little annoyed with redditors indirectly taking a jibe at doctors’ qualifications just because they don’t agree with LabMuffin or one of their other favorite YouTubers. You could have written this without the smug wording.

-12
dimdim1997OP•

That's the thing - she isn't a "board-certified medical doctor". It's been discussed here. She doesn't show up on the UK medical register.

20
xsnoopycakesx31F/Dry-Dehydrated/PIH/NC25•

FWIW, as a south-asian POC I didn't read the term "doctor" in quotation as racist at all but rather just questionning her qualification as what most people would assume to be a "medically practicing doctor" which she isn't, hence the quotation marks. This could apply to anyone of any colour, age, gender... probably an unpopular opinion so ready for the downvotes lol but people just seem to be trying to find problems out of anything.

15
dimdim1997OP•

That's how I intended it too, but better to omit the petty quotations than leave it open to interpretation and possibly (and frankly not without reason) offend people.

14
Scascaaccount•

Also South Asian. I am in agreement with you, 100%. Your opinion is not unpopular, I would say majority have this opinion. Unfortunately, the majority is often silent because, as you said, people try to find problems out of anything.

10
skincarelover_•

I understand what you’re saying but you being a fellow POC doesn’t mean it’s not implicitly poor taste. Not all POC have the same opinion.

0†
skincarelover_•

She is a medical doctor. Other people not understanding that not all MBBS/MDs practice is a whole other thing but that doesn’t change the fact that she is qualified to speak on medical issues. I never questioned OP for disagreeing with her (personally I also use chemical sunscreens!) but I disagreed with the quotations since it’s problematic in the current environment to question a WOC’s qualifications so casually. Medical doctors who help develop cancer fighting drugs often have little to no experience in a patient practice as many graduated and went down the research pathway immediately. I wouldn’t question their doctor qualifications either. There is a difference between a PHD doctor and a medical doctor who actually went to medical school regardless of whether they chose to see patients or not.

-5
xsnoopycakesx31F/Dry-Dehydrated/PIH/NC25•

Well I would guess that there is a big difference in having a qualification in medicine on paper (the MBBS) and actually practicing it, but i don't know the details so I'm not gonna dive into it. I'm not denying that she is a doctor, but that the first assumptions that people may be making is that she is a practicing doctor/dermatologist which she isn't, and that makes a difference, at least from how I see it.

To make a comparison, LabMuffin is also a doctor, but a PHD Doctor. She doesn't label herself as a doctor but as a "chemistry PHD", which makes it more clear to people on what her background/experience as a doctor is, because when people hear "doctor" the first thing they tend to think of is a practicing medical doctor (such as Dr Dray).

13
skincarelover_•

I meant board certified as in she has been certified as an MBBS (the equivalent to MD in the UK). If you went to medical school and graduated, you are a doctor full stop. I see a lot of Americans get this information wrong just because she doesn’t have an MD doesn’t mean she isn’t a doctor. That said, a LOT of doctors actually choose to do what she did and go directly into research after earning their MBBS/MD qualification. Many medical students actually intend to graduate and go into research (thus forgoing traditional residency or fellowship). Choosing to go into research isn’t some cop out. In fact, it’s the route that many doctors involved in finding the drug-cure for cancer take. I have a friend on the same path and several medical schools have 2 tracks you can choose (research or practice). In the UK and other countries where an MBBS is awarded, things may be structured a little differently but yes she is 100% a doctor and a WOC and your post questioning her doctor status is in poor taste.

“Dr Rattan qualified from University College London Medical School in 2008 with 2 degrees, her degree in Medicine (MBBS) and a degree in Physiology and Pharmacology (BSc). The title ‘Dr’ is used in reference to her medical degree.

After graduation from Medical School, she spent the next 3 years studying clinical trials for hyperpigmentation treatments and putting together ingredients to reduce melanocyte activity without causing damage to surrounding tissue.“

You can totally question her opinions! I personally find myself thinking Dr. Dray for example (I know this is not who you are referring to) is a little too over the top with the frequent application of SPF even if indoors all day but I would never question her qualifications as a doctor. So making a smug post about Dr. Rattan for being focused on women of color, is in poor taste. She spent years studying and then years researching. That doesn’t go down the drain because you said so.

3†
dimdim1997OP•

You explicitly said she is a "board certified medical doctor". She isn't.

9
skincarelover_•

And you explicitly questioning her education is fine?? In the UK board certified can mean certified MBBS. I’ve heard the term loosely thrown around for several qualifications (it’s not a term used often there), not just a residency. Maybe it’s different where you’re from. Anyways, you can skirt around the issue but you questioned whether she was a “doctor” immediately after saying she focuses on darker skinned women. If you don’t see the implicit racism in your own language then no one can help you. I hope you also question the education of doctors who choose to forgo residency for cancer clinical research. Again you are free to disagree with her without questioning her education!

-6
anticlericalist666•

Woah she really isn't one? What is she exactly then?

This post is a lifesaver, I've been hunting down good physical sunscreens for a while now after she said that.

2
dimdim1997OP•

I'm not perfectly familiar with the UK system, but apparently she graduated at some point but never got certified or actually practiced..

4
skincarelover_•

Wrong. You can not impose the American system onto the UK or rest fo the world. Regardless, even American doctors who graduate from medical school and get an MD often choose to go straight into research instead. Many hospitals have MD + research streams which are even meant to lead into that instead of practicing after graduation (my friend is on this track and wants to work in clinical trials instead of seeing patients). How do you think most cancer drugs are made?? Many of those doctors had chosen to go directly into research after graduating instead of practicing traditionally or did not practice for long. Please do your research on the medical field globally before indirectly questioning someone’s well-earned qualifications as a doctor!

-1†
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

5
[deleted]•

[removed]

3