r/livesound•
kelcema

No Stupid Questions Thread - Week of 2020-08-24 - 2020-08-30

The only stupid question is the one left unasked!

Do you have a basic question you want answered? Let us help! Remember that r/livesound is for PA/sound systems/streaming -- we may not be able to be as helpful with questions about, say, home theatre systems. Keep in mind that the more information about your setup (amps, speakers, mixer, microphones) you can provide, the quicker we'll be able to help you!

Posted Aug 24, 2020, 5:20 PM UTC

844
TheCaptainhat•

I heard rechargeable batteries are iffy in wireless mics and IEM transmitters, but I've been using Eneloop Pros for over a year now and have had 0 issues. ELI5?

4
Chris935•

They're fine, but the battery meters won't read accurately if they're expecting alkalines, as the voltage/time curve is different.

If you don't absolutely need the capacity of the Eneloop Pros you might be better off with the standard Eneloops. They have a much longer service life of charge/discharge cycles.

http://aacycler.com/battery/aa/

5
AshamedGorillaPro - Crabtown, USA•

Modern rechargeables are just fine. But in the past rechargeables would often have a steep drop-off in voltage as they drained, often meaning they could not lost as long as single-use. Then there's the "issue" that rechargables do require some maintenance which people often ignore.

3
IronFilm•

Eneloops (or LADDAs) are great! And are the normal to use in wireless bodypacks, unless you need to squeeze that extra bit of battery performance out of them (and are loaded with money, and don't care about the environment) in which case then you'll use AA Lithium batteries

Waaay back in the dark ages rechargeables had a part reputation but tech has moved on, perhaps you're just hearing something older timers are repeating to you? (without them getting with the times)

3
UnderwaterMessPro FOH - Miami, FL•

If you have the newer Shure RF units, their battery systems are expensive but they're very nice and we've recently gone fully rechargeable throughout our entire RF inventory. I've used the Shure rechargeable batteries for mission critical/broadcast events plenty of times without any issues both in transmitters and IEM packs. We've also been using Eneloop with the church for a little over two years, and we're currently replacing the batch of batteries there after about 18 months of two charge/use cycles per week.

2
iarebryan•

I am run a small film festival and am putting together an outdoor screening. My equipment has been fine in the rooms we normally screen in but I need to be able to project in open air for up to 200'.

I run two powered Carvin PM10a speakers out of a Soundcaft MXPI.

My stupid question is: What the fuck do I need to be loud? An amp or preamp? My background is in video, I try to read articles and my brain seizes up.

3
the-real-compucatEE student by day, engineer by night•

We need more information. Assuming you’re in open space (i.e. no buildings or walls nearby to worry about), what’s the area you need to cover, how many people are in that area, and what’s your budget?

A preamp takes a low-level signal and brings it up to line level. A power amp takes a line level signal and amplifies it to speaker level. Your active speakers have a power amp built in. What you need is dependent on the requirements of the space.

2
iarebryan•

Thanks. Had to get some facts together. The space is about 100'x250'. One of the 100' ends has a wall we are projecting images on. We anticipate about 200-300 people. My budget is under $500.

The reason I am concerned is because the last time we used the speakers we had a soft buzzing that would happen above 25% speaker volume (knob on the back of the speaker) We had never experienced before and were unable to turn it up any louder. I had a few sound engineers come and look at the set up and no one could figure it out. It was a new space and we haven't used them since.

2
FeralStreetwear•

I am looking to start doing live performances in an open outdoor environment and I need a beginner PA speaker system that can output enough sound to carry the music over 100ft landing at 60db minimum. Can you guys help me plan out a setup that would be able to fit my needs?

3
IshmaelUnleashed•

I work for a University doing tech. Most of my work is floating heads and PowerPoints. I'm not an expert by any means. But our events board wants to put on a virtual concert and I have a technology to do it so I'll be running it. I have a Yamaha tf1 and a focusrite 2i2 for the audio. I'll also be using cameras and an ATEM mini pro, but we're here for sound.

What problems will I forget about and what's the best way for me to avoid them?

2
mister_damageAudio Dropouts Because Microwave Nachos•
  1. Delay. You'll most likely need to delay your broadcast mix to align with the video.
  2. If you're running ATEM Mini Pro and are broadcasting live out from the ATEM Mini Pro (from what I understand you are able to), I may even consider investing in a decent quality 1/4" TS Pair to 3.5mm and align your audio to your video out from ATEM mini and let ATEM Mini Pro handle everything. (Match your level outs though.... Again, it's been a long while since)
  3. A separate mix for your broadcast and your FOH is a must. What sounds good on live via speakers will sound crummy on your livestream and vice versa (for the most part). You'll want at least another iPad or a computer solely controlling either a matrix off of your LR/Sub out or dedicate a stereo Aux for broadcasting mix. Ideally, having another mixer altogether is better overall since you can process each channel suitable for livestream rather than for FOH. Since you do have a small audience, I'm assuming the TF1 is mainly to handle the FOH and the IEM or stage monitoring.
  4. Ditch the 2i2 and instead route your whatever AUX you'll be handling the broadcast mix to said USB channels or use analog out and send it to ATEM Mini Pro. This also eliminates a potential point of failure you're unnecessarily introducing by adding another hardware into your signal flow more than anything else. Some will argue that it introduces a loss of quality due to AD/DA/AD/DA, but thats really trivial.
5
IshmaelUnleashed•

My plan was to use the tf to handle to foh and broadcast mix by having a post fader stereo aux send to be the broadcast so as to mirror my FOH mix. I am limited by not having a ton of resources for equipment or bodies. So being able to set my broadcast and them have it mirror my FOH is a possible reality. The client might hire a FOH engineer and might hire a monitor engineer.

I'm playing around with OBS and ASIO, but I'm having a lot of trouble with that. The tf doesn't have 1/4in outputs, I would need to convert from xlr to 3.5mm.

Thank you for your ideas! This is why I'm doing this now, plus have a practice band coming in, before the actual concert series.

1
Chris935•

The Atem Mini Pro can stream directly to the internet, you don't need OBS for this.

3
mister_damageAudio Dropouts Because Microwave Nachos•

Keep it simple unless you need it not be simple.

If you can't spare any additional busses or get a split mix, then you can assign your whatever your broadcast aux, be it a matrix off of FOH or otherwise, a multiband comp so it helps to tighten up your mix a bit more. Use a slightly more critical headphone monitors (SRH-840 is my pick) or nearfield monitors to tune to taste, and hope for the best.

The reason why we would prefer a split mix down the line is that the workflow will probably be significantly different than you mixing to the space/FOH.

2
soundwithdesignTheatre-Designer/Mixer•

What kind of concert?

1
IshmaelUnleashed•

That's a very good question. They are planning 3 lunch time concerts, one with a two person band, one with a 4 person band, and one possibly with just a DJ. They did not know the make up of the bands specifically. It's fun working at a University because I truly never know what my days will look like.

2
soundwithdesignTheatre-Designer/Mixer•

The USB port on the back provides 34x34 channels of audio to a computer. Are you going to live stream or record and upload?

1
IshmaelUnleashed•

Live stream. We're talking about different platforms to stream to. I don't want to use USB since that will record. I was going to route the audio through auxes to go to the stream and the mains to go to the house sound. We have a very small audience to help it feel live.

1
Abacadaba714•

Look into OBS. It's a free software you can use for streaming. I have been messing with it and an x32. You'll have to use ASIO and assign 2 inputs at the "mic" and then route the audio that you're recording to those two inputs.

1
IshmaelUnleashed•

I have a focusrite 2i2 which let's me route the audio from xlr outs to my computer.

1
Abacadaba714•

So long as it has ASIO connectivity, it should be fine. Most likely you'll need to still use ASIO, assign the two channels of your focusrite as the input, and route a stereo mix to the focurite, you should be ok.

​

OBS will allow for multiple camera, and transitioning from different views. It's fairly straight forward. The biggest issue I had was figuring out how to configure the ASIO inputs.

1
IshmaelUnleashed•

I don't need to worry about the cameras in OBS, I have the blackmagic software to run my switcher.

I'll make sure the asio is working correctly!

1
Danny11998833•

Question about monitors from FOH / soft patching. I understand the concept, for example duplicating the vocals and having one for FOH and one for MONS. This way you can treat the same vocal separately for both applications. In this video https://youtu.be/OsFwGZS1PZ4?t=387 Justin talks about using the digital trim to "change the input level" in order to make it more usable for the monitor system. I don't really get that, how could the gain set for FOH be a problem for Mons ?

2
VinceLennonPro | LA•

Non-optimized gain structure within either the house PA or monitor system. Could be caused by a million things. Using digital trim is just one fix that is at your disposal. If I had ample time, I would prefer to set my aux masters, or my monitor amps, or my main LR matrices to a level that will allow my fader positions to be in a reasonable spot across the board.

6
Danny11998833•

Mmmh so you mean for example, I gain my vocals for FOH, and they are way too loud when barely raising the aux send, so I use the trim to turn the vocal down (on the mons-dedicated vocal channel) and allow my fader to go up ? Would that be a plausible situation ?

2
VinceLennonPro | LA•

Yes, that is a common situation

2
timverhoeven•

What you also need to remember, if you soft-patch one input into 2 channels you still have only one (still analog) preamp controlling that input.

Any change of the gain of that preamp will then impact both your FoH and Mon channels. That is where the digital trim comes in. If you want to change the level in only one of the channels you can use the digital trim to do so, the trim will not impact the other channel with the same input.

For example. During the show, after the soundcheck where you set the gain of the input and dailed in both FoH and Mon channels, there is a need to have bit more gain on the FoH channel. Then you would use the digital trim on the FoH channel to give you that extra gain.

1
Danny11998833•

I see, thanks !

1
cooltone•

Can anyone point me to the dimensions of the soundcraft ui24r. I can't seem to find them anywhere. I've searched Google, the user manual the sell sheet. I can only find the size of the box it ships in.

2
D-townP-town•

Sweetwater says it's 4 rackmount units so that's 7 inches tall, 6.8 inches deep and 19 inches wide (as is all full-width rackmount equipment).

2
cooltone•

Fantastic, many thanks. It was the 6.8 inches I was looking for.

1
GoingVeganPodcast•

Total beginner to live sound set ups here. I play guitar and drums (an e-kit for now) and want to put a band rehearsal space in my basement. I have a bass and keys I’ll be setting up and would love to play the bass, keys, drums, and 3-4 mics through speakers. I’ll run the guitar through it’s own amp.

I really have no idea what equipment I should be buying for this. Any suggestions? Thank you!

2
greylokiI make things louder•

You'll need some speakers:

https://www.thomann.de/gb/ev_elx_115.htm

Possibly a subwoofer or two:

https://www.thomann.de/gb/ev_elx_118p.htm

Possibly some foldback monitors:

https://www.thomann.de/gb/ev_elx_112p.htm

A mixer. You can go simple with an analogue board such as:

https://www.thomann.de/gb/allenheath_zed22fx.htm

However you'll almost immediately find yourself wanting features which would require additional purchases (graphic EQs for taming feedback, more/better effects, more auxes and groups and routing options, the list goes on). The current 'really cheap but featureful' options are the Behringer XR18:

https://www.thomann.de/gb/behringer_x_air_xr18.htm

and the Behringer X32-Rack:

https://www.thomann.de/gb/behringer_x32_rack.htm

If this thing is going to stay in a rehearsal space and rarely if ever be used elsewhere, the XR18 is a good bet. The X32-Rack gives you a lot of extra features which are nice to have, and is also expandable with extra inputs and outputs, I/O cards, and so forth. Both mixers are designed to be controlled via a tablet computer, so factor in the cost of an iPad if you don't already own one. The apps are free. You can also use a PC editor if you have a spare/cheap laptop lying around. Not as ergonomic, but very cheap as well.

You'll also need some mics for your drums and vocals etc. I like Sennheiser 600 series drum mics as a budget pick (602, 604, I don't think you'll need 614s in the size of rooms you'll be working in most likely), and sE V7 or V7X for vocals. Don't forget mic stands and cables.

I've listed all of these as examples of equipment that you could buy. I'd be happy recommending it all for your use case, but I would invite you to look at what else is on the market. Looking at other items in the same categories on Thomann is a good start to let you see the state of play with the market.

Hope this helps :)

2
GoingVeganPodcast•

Thanks so much for this! I’m in the US so will have to find the equivalents here. This was incredibly helpful.

In short, I need a mixer plus powered speakers to get started and everything can really run through that?

1
greylokiI make things louder•

In short - yep! FYI, mixers won't have appropriate inputs for acoustic or bass guitars to connect directly in, mind: the jack connectors are the same, but electrically they are quite different, so we use what's called a DI (direct input) box.

1
GoingVeganPodcast•

Perfect, thank you! That answers my question. To be clear, I'll need a DI box for a bass, keyboard, electronic drums, basically anything that isn't a mic?

1
MatthewGalloway•

We have just a single person at a time giving speeches into the stock vocal mic which is hardwired running into one of these portable (and battery powered) 800W speakers:
https://surplustronics.co.nz/products/10543-portable-pa-speaker-abs-15-inch-bluetooth-rechargable

This has been working more than well enough for our needs! Simple and dirt cheap.

But lately we've been getting a few hundred people, and it seems the numbers are only growing. (we're in a large outdoor space, and there is no way we could limit how many people would show up. Neither would we want to)

We're a non-profit, running off the fumes from an oily rag, so what's the best realistic approach to modestly expand our capacity? I thought we could buy a second one of these speakers (although sadly they're out of stock, so I couldn't get an identical one, but I could get this which is similar: https://www.surplustronics.co.nz/products/10595-portable-pa-speaker-amplifier-abs-15-inch-bluetooth ) then position one each side of the person giving a speech (facing the audience), putting them a fair distance apart to give greater coverage for the audience listening? (also by not having the person next to the speak any longer, we could likely also gain up the mic a lot louder without risking feedback. I'd loan them my Wendt X3 mixer, so they can take the hardwired stock vocal mic to send out the L/R feed to the two portable speakers each side)

2
This_ManU67Other•

I just landed a gig doing Monitors for an in house show/music attraction. Basically when this opens in the beginning of September (yes with social distancing and sanitation measures in place) it will run once a day for six days a week until they switch over to the holiday show. Has anybody worked a show like this before and if so what is it like?

DM me if you have any specific advice or would like to know more/chat.

1
h2ogie•

why do people talk shit on behringer

1
huffalump1•

This horse has been beat to death on audio forums for years already but..... They historically made a lot of low-quality, copycat products. The story changed with the X32 but their history of low-quality, unreliable speakers, pedals, mixers, etc is what people dislike. And they're still copying circuits with all their synthesizer releases.

2
h2ogie•

I mean hey maybe it's a dead horse but I only just recently got a baseball bat so I'm curious.

I've heard great things about the X32, their UMC1820, and the Wing from people around here so I was confused as to why there would be a blanket dislike for them as a company or why people would say that they're only good for a year of use.

2