r/scuba•
jaspmf

Equipment Q: Surface Supplied Setup using Tanks

Greets,

Pondering a fresh setup for diving Sea Cucumbers in the PNW. The specific fishery is designed such that we have a 7hr day & a 4hr day the next day. Maximizing bottom time (our crew always stay no-deco) is high priority. Thus far its all been done hookah style - something akin to a brownie or any of the other low pressure compressors.

Nitrox has been on my mind for obvious reasons, but the complexity of a low pressure compressor with active Nitrox mixing coupled with a tender operating a small skiff and all the other duties at any moment... it's just a bit much. So retrofitting our current setup with Nitrox is out of the question as far as I'm concerned.

Lately I've been pondering the notion of running Surface Supplied but switching from a low pressure compressor to high pressure tanks. Although it'd be annoying to have to go to the diveshop for fills - I think the tradeoff is worth it. Can be diving a known EAN mix that's been tested & confirmed, thereby reducing the load on the tender as compared to a compressor & active mixing. Much preferable, much less complex.

So anyways, I've been having a hard time finding materials & examples of this sort of rig. Maybe my Google query skills are rusty?

I see interspiro makes a manifold & hose setup - the high pressure hose all the way down is VERY appealing in this arrangement because I presume that allows the diver(s) to use a proper dive computer, whereas low pressure there's no path for active monitoring down below. Again, the less active responsibility on the tender the better far as I'm concerned. Not crazy about a topside person trying to pilot a skiff while watching a pneumo & tracking a dive profile.. Really prefer it to be right there on MY wrist.

Are there other examples of high-pressure setups like that?

Anybody know what the interspiro unit runs price wise?

Any resources you could point me to regarding equipment choices along my stated path?

Posted Aug 27, 2020, 3:30 AM UTC

19
runsongasOpen Water•

is the intent to use the nitrox to improve safety and also relieve any possible subclinical dcs fatigue? if so, just running a continuous blend with a CMF needle valve and inline o2 sensor on top of your existing hookah system should be sufficient.

if you are still staying within NDL limits for air, no real need to change the dive profile tracking. wrist dive computers do not need a high pressure hose to function.

if you are going to use the nitrox to increase NDL time, then you need an accurate mix readout which would either require an o2 monitor akin to a ccr head unit or running a set mix. but hauling enough tanks is going to be annoying for a set mix.

3
jaspmfOP•

Increased NDL time is the goal. Oftentimes we're passing up good harvesting because the extra 10-15' of depth isn't worth the tradeoff in terms of reduced bottom time. We're allowed a set amount of time to harvest 2 days a week and that's it.

Likely we'd use tanks far larger than 80's, but I understand your meaning re: annoying to haul.

2
runsongasOpen Water•

how big is your boat? a possibility is to stick hp banks on the boat and then refill back at the dock.

3
jaspmfOP•

18' skiff tenders the two swimmers during the dive days (infinitely more maneuverable as we sometimes cover alot of ground), but our 48' Seiner is always anchored nearby.

Definitely, if we go the tank route that's exactly what we'd do - high pressure bank on the big boat

1
runsongasOpen Water•

installing a membrane system on the 48' seiner may be an option instead.

2
jms700•

I have used high pressure banks and surface supplied equipment for commercial work and its fairly straight forward. We would regulate the pressure at surface and send lp down to the diver. Doesnt change the ability of the diver to use a computer . You would need a portable panel though which can be quite pricy or you can set one up your self. The only other gear you would need is the umbilicals and any electrical gear you want. We used multiple 15 litre cylinders with 2 plumbed in at all times then crossed over to the fresh cylinder to change out the old and back and forth that way. Your problem would lilely arrise trying to blend the same mix into all cylinders but that could be over come.

As you are diving within ndls is there a reason you arent just using twin sets ? I run a clam boat and we use lots of o2 and blend our own twinsets between dives with an onnoard hydraulic powered compressor with out issue. You can always wire up a comms line to a rope for hardwired comms and as a life line.

Feel free to pm me as i have used all sorts of systems like your talking about.

3
jaspmfOP•

If we went LP down to the diver we've already got the umbilicals, so that's a plus. I've seen those panels, they're pricey but not out of question. Right, that seems like a pretty straight forward setup. I see on the divator unit the tender manually turns on the 2nd tank/bank & the unit will automatically switch to the higher pressure input on the fly, that's pretty handy. Good point re: blending cylinders, shouldn't be a problem though like you said - just something to be aware of.

We certainly could use twins - it just winds up being bulky with two sizable tanks strapped to your back. That and having to come back up to swap out several times throughout the course of the day are a bit of a disincentive. We surface several times throughout the day but I quite like the 15 minutes of actual downtime as opposed to rigging new cans. Not out of the question by any means. Also using less tanks - running the SSA route - is a perceived benefit.. Just a few large ones as opposed to a bunch of 80's littering the skiff.

If we went twins certainly we'd want to keep the comms & tether - quite like that lifeline & it's got its utility at times.

Mostly twins just feels bulky on top of dragging around 80#'s of cukes in a bag, being so used to just a bail out bottle it'd be a hard adjustment.

Cheers, really appreciate your insights

1
jms700•

Sent you a private message.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
jaspmfOP•

Sounds rather straightforward to me. The less active responsibilities for the tender the better far as I'm concerned. I actually like the needing to switch to bailout each time topside swaps banks as that reinforces muscle memory for backup air. Nothin wrong with that.

Even something as simple as topping off the fuel tank on our compressor can get obnoxious when they're orienteering the skiff in chop against current trying to keep track of 2 divers & not get lines crossed. The less moving parts the better 👍🏽

2