r/askphilosophy•
zenmap12

Bad intention invalidates a good question?

Let's say a person proposes a good question with a bad intention like:

"What's the point of having mathematics if they are not real" with the clear intention of "debunk" maths and encourage the ignorance of it.

Does the intention invalidates the "good" of question?

Shall we always separate the sentences in parts so that we can extract the good parts of not just the sentences but rather everything?

I wonder if this is just a logic problem in the real, an ad hominem attack will invalidate any proper argument even if the argument is not bad.

Sorry for my bad explanation, this is a tricky concept to me.

Posted Aug 28, 2020, 6:25 PM UTC

35
Loading comments…