Is the Dialga Mirror Match Truly Random

Discussion

So I'll start this post by saying its currently only my very limited set of data.

BACKGROUND:

In master league I run a 15/15/13 best buddy dialga in the lead. In the mirror match (if you haven't played it before) one of the quirks of Niantics coding is that you don't get simultaneous fainting on one (or half depending on your definition) turn fast moves. So essentially it picks a dialga to win - this player gets 100 energy and switch advantage which generally spells game over for the loser!

I play this match out by going straight DB all the way and roll the dice. If they throw I should be ahead by a DB and win the match at the cost of a sheild (although 3 times this season I have somehow lost when they threw, presumably to lag).

DATA/QUESTION:

I write down all my matches in master league to try and make sure my team is optimal and see if I make consistent mistakes.

I have played out 11 mirror matches when nobody throws. And have LOST all 11. That's right I haven't won a mirror match this season.

The chance (assuming a true 50/50) of this happening is 0.0488% (or 1 in just over 2000).

So my question is - is this truly random? If I add the three matches when I dropped a DB and lost when they threw that's 14 loses in a row.

Does anyone have any similar data? I play on a Galaxy S10 5G using the most up to date version of the game and operating system.

I'm curious if anyone else has recorded their data, I know 1/2000 is super unlucky, but not completely out the question (although with the 3 other data points it becomes even less likely). There must be more than 2000 players that run dialga so maybe I'm just the really unfortunate one!

A final note - this issue of the mirror match being a coin flip has been with us since preseason. They really should fix it so that you both can faint at the same time, yes its still luck what you bring in at the back but you're on a 2 vs 2 with even sheilds rather than down a sheild (or 2) and have lost switch as well...

Posted Aug 30, 2020, 10:07 AM UTC

2710
PokeGo617•

I will try to find it, but I remember a thread a few months back on Silph Arena where a player said they lose the mirror in this fashion every single time. In that thread, others said they also lose it every time, but curiously, there were also commenters saying that they win it every time.

Despite all this, I’d still wager it’s the nature of DB and lag/skipping etc., but I wouldn’t rule there’s something else at play. I’d be curious to hear if other players still always win or lose 100% of the time.

5
Zenodore🕯️•

https://www.reddit.com/r/TheSilphRoad/comments/ghkmh5/issue_with_how_oneturn_fast_move_damage_is_applied/

I've always questioned the idea that this is limited to one-turn moves though. My mirror matches with e.g. Togekiss don't play out any better than my Dialga ones. I've even lost when they threw an AP but I didn't (and no, they didn't get the boost), just like what you report with Dialga and attribute to lag - I'd say that's all just one big issue with how fast moves are handled

edit: https://www.reddit.com/r/TheSilphArena/comments/ijm7wb/togekiss_slower_charm_in_mirror_matchup/

4
jostler57👑 Bossy Bossman 👑•

Wow, that’s terrible! I do know that there are reports of farming down gone wrong, where the opponent throws, you don’t, yet they still somehow win. It’s crazy! Happened to me once.

As for the majority issue, do you see their life total down to the bare minimum of appx 3-4 health, or is it sometimes above that? That leads to the next question:

I also know that DB often drops an attack during mirrors. Is it possible you’re often dropping an attack?

If there’s no dropped attack, and there’s no other lag, and the health is always equal, then it really would be just bad luck.

2
StormHHOP•

Generally it looks like they are one DB from dying on the last one, each time it looks like we have the same hp before I die. I could definitely drop a DB sometimes (definitely happened in the three when they threw) but its not obvious - we both go to yellow hp and red hp at the same time (unless its a 100 because I think it ends up on 51% hp when I'm on 50%, but still within one DB).

Its also happened to me on lower IV (but 15 attack) dialgas.

Its just a little bit frustrating when trying to climb but having to write 5-10% of games off straight away! Hoping its just bad luck and it will turn!!

3
jostler57👑 Bossy Bossman 👑•

It's certainly curious... on paper, you would both simultaneously faint. But in practice, you're always losing.

That just points to DB dropping an attack as the culprit. Other than that, maybe it's lag, or maybe some kind of desync issue, but you'd be able to see if you have the spinning circle/notification for lag, and you'd definitely be able to see if your DBs aren't simultaneous.

Might help to record a few sets to find those mirror matches. That way you can go back over it with a fine-toothed comb and possibly find where the problem lies.

1
StormHHOP•

Its well known that the simultaneous faint can't happen on the DB match up. Its a weird quirk of Niantics coding. When it comes to the final DB only yours or the opponents goes through.

Its a mad system. The winner has 100 energy and can generally either land one Draco meteor/Thunder or two IHs (depends how much damage the fast move of the opponent does). Realistically unless the loser has super hard counters to the opponent in the back its a gg at that stage.

3
jostler57👑 Bossy Bossman 👑•

That's a good point -- I honestly never lead with Dialga, so I never get into that situation.

I wonder if it's a hardware issue... you're either dropping a DB, there's a hardware problem, or you're incredibly unlucky.

2
Harfatum🕯️•

Could be some artifact like the classic Wi Flag from Asheron's Call.

2
hotstriker9•

With my perfect Dialga I usually won these but I do lose sometimes. Maybe 2/10. But most people have been throwing a charge move. Although I’ve lost 1 of these anyway, and twice had them throw two charge moves which was ridiculous and shouldn’t have been possible but there you have it.

1