A friend sent me this and asked for help, but I’m not quite sure that I know how to do it either.

Math
A friend sent me this and asked for help, but I’m not quite sure that I know how to do it either.

Posted Sep 1, 2020, 3:44 PM UTC

24026
UltimateMarino•

You multiply by C then just substract the Y and you get X. Im mostly sure that this isnt "possible" as you get x=cd-y

71
DatOneGuy00OP•

That’s what I was thinking

36
reddit12172003•

That’s the answer then, it doesn’t work you proved that x =/= dc/y

7
PositiveRegister•

Instead of subtracting the Y, divide by Y on both sides.

-27
RoyalBlood999•

Then you get x/y+1=dc/y

29
PublicTrash•

Then multiply by y on both sides, smh. /s

2
vasylnes•

Wouldn't x be equal to dc-y?

22
unoriginalqwerty•

yeah to prove it it would have to be xy not x+y

1
SeagullNoodles•

This is wack because the only ways I can think of end up with X+1=cd/y or X=cd-y

22
Konexian•

It's impossible. You can prove this by back substitution. The left side simplifies to cd = x + y. Now you plug in x + y for cd in the right side, and you get x = (x + y) / y

So xy = x + y

Which is clearly not true for all reals.

11
agree-with-you•

I agree, this does not seem possible.

5
Konexian•
8
MCreeper12731•

Type that the proof doesn't exist since it's impossible to solve

9
jelle2316•

what grade are you in

8
[deleted]•

[deleted]

13
RoyalBlood999•

This doesn’t work OP. You can even check by substituting values for the variables. Math doesn’t check out

7
PositiveRegister•

Multiply both sides by c to get rid of the denominator, then divide both sides by Y to get rid of the y on the left.

3
RixuYTGrade 12•

Then you get (X+y)/y = DC/y

I'm pretty sure this question is just wrong

8
SeagullNoodles•

but then you end up with x+1= cd/y,

because dividing y by y leaves 1.

2
balthazar_nor•

I mean if its asking for proof just swap the letters out with numbers and compare results lol

Or is there something I'm not getting

2
DatOneGuy00OP•

The problem is you cant, the two equations aren’t equivalent.

1
balthazar_nor•

So you show that the equations give different results therefore it is not equal lol

Say x is 5, y is 2, c is 7, d is 1, the first equation is valid, however the second equation would become invalid because 5 is not equal to 7/2

2
SpaceBoi65•

Rearrangement, I guess?

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
DatOneGuy00OP•

That’s not at all what you’re looking at. You have to prove that the first equation is equal to the second, which it is not because math doesn’t work like that

1
Ringer106•

•multiply C on both sides, leaves with x+y=dc •divide Y on both sides, leaves with x=dc/y

My classes haven’t resumed yet so I’m a bit out of practice but this is the answer I get every time I do it

-3
RixuYTGrade 12•

Why are you dividing by y... You could only divide it if it was xy not X+y

7
Ringer106•

Holy shit I’m an actually dumbass. Thanks man

7