A friend sent me this and asked for help, but I’m not quite sure that I know how to do it either.

Posted Sep 1, 2020, 3:44 PM UTC

Posted Sep 1, 2020, 3:44 PM UTC
Wouldn't x be equal to dc-y?
yeah to prove it it would have to be xy not x+y
This is wack because the only ways I can think of end up with X+1=cd/y or X=cd-y
It's impossible. You can prove this by back substitution. The left side simplifies to cd = x + y. Now you plug in x + y for cd in the right side, and you get x = (x + y) / y
So xy = x + y
Which is clearly not true for all reals.
Type that the proof doesn't exist since it's impossible to solve
what grade are you in
[deleted]
This doesn’t work OP. You can even check by substituting values for the variables. Math doesn’t check out
Multiply both sides by c to get rid of the denominator, then divide both sides by Y to get rid of the y on the left.
Then you get (X+y)/y = DC/y
I'm pretty sure this question is just wrong
but then you end up with x+1= cd/y,
because dividing y by y leaves 1.
I mean if its asking for proof just swap the letters out with numbers and compare results lol
Or is there something I'm not getting
The problem is you cant, the two equations aren’t equivalent.
So you show that the equations give different results therefore it is not equal lol
Say x is 5, y is 2, c is 7, d is 1, the first equation is valid, however the second equation would become invalid because 5 is not equal to 7/2
Rearrangement, I guess?
[deleted]
That’s not at all what you’re looking at. You have to prove that the first equation is equal to the second, which it is not because math doesn’t work like that
•multiply C on both sides, leaves with x+y=dc •divide Y on both sides, leaves with x=dc/y
My classes haven’t resumed yet so I’m a bit out of practice but this is the answer I get every time I do it
Why are you dividing by y... You could only divide it if it was xy not X+y
Holy shit I’m an actually dumbass. Thanks man
You multiply by C then just substract the Y and you get X. Im mostly sure that this isnt "possible" as you get x=cd-y
That’s what I was thinking
That’s the answer then, it doesn’t work you proved that x =/= dc/y
Instead of subtracting the Y, divide by Y on both sides.
Then you get x/y+1=dc/y
Then multiply by y on both sides, smh. /s