Thoughts on energy bars

Hi, I was wondering what other ultrarunners thought about energy bars, nutrition bars, etc.

Do you use pre-packaged bars (Clif bars, Ivan bars, etc), or did you make you own? Or use a different product for ultras.

Posted Sep 3, 2020, 2:15 AM UTC

847
Prag_matt1sm•

I find Clif bars and such get pretty dry to eat after quite a few hours. As far as pre-packaged foods, you cannot go past baby food. Fruit mixes, veggies and plenty of choices to avoid flavour fatigue.

11
mathBrianOP•

I don't think I heard the baby food one before.

I've found that most fruit don't carry well.

1
Freeasabird01•

Single serve, as much as I hate plastic packaging, is a common way here. Apple sauce squeeze pouches, fruit cups with the peel off top, etc. Now for some of this you could prep a large can of something like canned fruit and split it between small reusable plastic containers like Rubbermaid.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

7
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4
Freeasabird01•

Am I the only one that notices the off putting flavor in the caffeine ones?

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
PaulCunningham•

They give me a little stomach burn if I eat a whole one in one go.

1
[deleted]•

It really comes down to personal preference. You gotta try out different things on training runs and see what you like to eat.

3
CluelessWanderer15•

I don't use energy bars at all before or during my runs. I find that my gastrointestinal system is sensitive to fat, protein, and dietary fiber.

Instead I go with carbohydrates like sugary candy such as Skittles, Airheads, or Sour Patch Kids, or simple starchy stuff like plain bagels, pretzel chips, and rice crackers.

3
mathBrianOP•

Well, now I have an excuse to buy more Skittles, 2.5lbs bags shouldn't be too expensive. So you'd eat bagels and rice crackers during a run? Or only before?

1
CluelessWanderer15•

Before or during works for me. My local grocery store carries rice crackers without the wasabi peas, and they are a nice break from sugary stuff.

1

High five, fellow candy fan. My husband thinks I am crazy for buying candy corn in bulk every Fall, but that is by far the easiest snack for a long run. They just melt in your mouth even when you are too zonked to chew.

1
CluelessWanderer15•

The major challenge between candy and sport oriented candy is that I’m never tempted to eat gels or chews as a snack, but I have to keep Skittles out of sight or else.

2
mathBrianOP•

Yeah, I once bought 3 jumbo (2.5lbs) bags of Skittles in one summer. Though I probably ate slightly less than one bag, since I shared so much.

1
mathBrianOP•

Thanks for the tip, I'll be getting some candy corn in a month I guess. How long should they last though, do they get dry after a couple months?

Also, how do you carry and dispense them during your runs?

1

I have individual baggies that I carry on my person during a run. To be honest I’ve never had candy corn last long enough to get stale!

1
zta6pitt•

I eat candy. If you look at the ingredients of most gels they're just expensive candy. Might as well just buy cheap candy instead!

Or alternatively spend even more and get gels that are actually healthy.

3
mathBrianOP•

Yeah, the price of gels puts me off. But I saw Skittles in another post, and all I needed was another excuse to eat Skittles.

I also find that most chocolates don't eat well while running, if they have any wax at all, my dry cool mouth can tell instantly, and even real chocolate seems to melt awfully slowly while running.

But, related to that point, I'm guessing more fruity flavoured candies will probably work best while runnning.

1
havealooksee•

I supplement with energy waffles and blocks but try to eat “real” food as much as possible

2
HousmansHighway•

Clif bars work fine for me up to 30 miles. Once I'm 30-35 miles, they're pretty tough to eat. It feels like you're force-feeding yourself. Gels and gel chews work fine for me for the most part. I really like tailwind since you just drink it down. Past 50 miles, I just eat whatever I can swallow without feeling like I want to throw up...almond joy candy bars, beef jerky, apple sauce, etc.

You really just have to experiment. A lot of food that you think you'd like, you'd end up hating when you get palate fatigue.

2
mathBrianOP•

I've wondered whether beef jerky would also be fairly hard to eat. I haven't eaten it many times before either though.

1
HousmansHighway•

honestly, I think it really depends on the person. I've never had issues with just slowly chewing on some country archer beef jerky...it just doesn't seem to trigger my palate fatigue.

1

My problem is the junk they have in them.

2
mathBrianOP•

I am thinking of making bars myself to mainly save money, with the added benefit of knowing what goes in. Have experimented making any?

1

No I haven't but I think I will because I think they are good ways to carry fuel for long runs and races. Energy balls also seem like good fuel too but I always get concerned about them melting lol

1
Supamike36•

I have a Cliff builder bar in the morning.

I'll crumble up those Cliff bar coffee ones and put in a ziploc for a long run.

1
PaulCunningham•

I buy Clif bars cheap in bulk (I think they are close to expiry date so they are warehouse clearance stock or something) and use them as emergency snacks on the go and generally carry one on long runs or eat one immediately after for a quick hit. I probably consume 1-2 per week at most. I find them a bit rough on my guts though if I eat more than a couple of bites every 30 mins or so during a run.

I've looked at a few other bars and found them either too expensive for my liking, or they steer too far to the "natural" side and go bad very quickly (had some grow some kind of gross mold on them almost overnight).

For nutrition on long runs and for race day itself, I prefer to just pack some simple sandwiches with Vegemite or honey (or both so I have the option for sweet or savoury). Super cheap to make and very lightweight to carry. Also cheap to train with, compared to spending a ton on pre-made products and training your gut to be ready for race day.

For sugar hits I just buy cheap party mix lollies like these. I do keep some shot bloks on hand though as sometimes I need something I know will be super easy on my gut and has something extra in it like the sodium in the margarita ones.

1
mathBrianOP•

What is yegemite?

1
PaulCunningham•

I don't know. I only eat Vegemite.

1
dec92010•

Where do you buy bulk clif bars

1
mathBrianOP•

Costco is one place I've seen them frequently.

1
dec92010•

How many in those boxes? I dont have Costco or Sam's by me but at walmart I can get an 18 pack for about ~15

1
mathBrianOP•

At Costco I've seen 18 for 19$, but that would be Canadian dollars, which has depreciated significantly since 2015.

2
PaulCunningham•

Catch of the Day - one of those deals/clearance websites here in Australia.

1

I don't eat bars during my run. As noted elsewhere in this thread, I eat candy when I need a quick sugar hit (especially late in the run), donuts when I need sugar + fat, and for real food my go-to is peanut butter and jelly sandwiches. PB&J on an English muffin packs up really cleanly and fits perfect in my front vest pocket so I've just about always got one on me.

I do sometimes eat bars after the run when I need to worry less about how I'll digest. I had a salted caramel Clif Bar after my last ultra and the mix of salt + sweet was *chefs kiss*

1
NavyBlueZebra•

During long runs and races, I generally snack on roasted unsalted nuts. My stomach won't digest Clif bars and such.

1
mathBrianOP•

Can I ask how you carry your nuts? I guess for peanuts I'd have to shell them prior to a run as well.

1
NavyBlueZebra•

To reduce waste, I buy them in bulk, in recyclable jars. I carry them in a Ziploc with a slider, which lasts several months.

2
SkaterKate•

I've tried a lot of different bars and have moved almost exclusively to fruit source bars. Basically just fruity candy, but i find them very easy to eat while running. For longer days ill also throw together a small bag of peanuts/pumpkin seeds/raisins

1
mjern•

Clif bars all the way. Chocolate M&Ms. Gels. PB&J.

1
ultraaltru•

Flapjacks, fruit, dried sausage, elektrolytes, soup, mashed potatos, rice balls, chocolat.

Buying or cooking whatever works for you. Pre-packaged stuff won’t go bad as quick. If you make it yourself you know what you eat and prob better nutrition. I say go customize! 😉

Also train with the same food as race day

1
mathBrianOP•

Do you think using mashed potato powder would work in a meal-like energy bar?

1
speedbouc•

I replaced Clif Bars with Coconut Date Rolls for solid calories.

1
dec92010•

I use GUs gels but I also make my own pinole energy bars.

Also have some tailwind

1
mathBrianOP•

Can I ask you how you make your gels? I'm really intrigued, and would like to experiments with gels as well as bars.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
allfollowalice•

I always have Clif branded gels in my pack, but almost never use them while I'm out unless I'm feeling really low energy and/or on races when I need the emotional release of a warm raspberry flavoured slug :)

I *do carry electrolyte pills and take those religiously at least every 5 miles. I find I can knock out most runs with water and salt/potassium and prefer to go at it fasted.

I've done ok with Larabars (or my homemade knock off), fruit, pretzels, peanut butter/almond butter packets, jellybeans, homemade ginger cookies ...

Probably worth clarifying I'm not out there winning any of these races.

0
mathBrianOP•

What do you do to carry your fruit? Do you eat nut butters just like that? For cookies I'm guessing you try to have moist quick to chew ones? (not bricks that take forever to eat)

1
allfollowalice•

Oranges and bananas for fruit. I have been known to use the nut butter packets (single serve types) just like a gel. I made little cookies that were a bit crunchy but they were small so it wasn't a huge effort.

But again, I mostly run fasted. I try foods out mostly to know what sits well and what doesn't, and then on race day I have that info in my back pocket when approaching an aid station.

1