I feel "othered" by both the trans and cis communities
TL;DR Choosing not to transition and to live with misaligned sex/gender feels like I'm on a very lonely journey--one that doesn't fit with the typical trans or cis experience. Perspective, thoughts, and feedback welcome.
I'm 45 y/o, and physically male. I've had gender dysphoria since early childhood. My gender identity is unquestionably female. I wrestled with it for decades, but I've long since accepted that this is a core, unchanging part of who I am.
I've really gone to task on this over the last decade, in and out of therapy and investing a lot of effort into self-understanding and self-acceptance. I've given serious thought to transitioning, I'd never say never, but I really don't think transitioning is for me.
I feel like I've made a breakthrough in the last few years, where I'm finding a greater degree of peace with this contradiction. It feels like I'm able to allow both my physical sex and my gender without having to fight against, or hate on either one. A big part of it is accepting that my identity is 100% real and valid, even though it's entirely internal, and mostly inconsequential in day-to-day life. If I was asked the classic question of "if you could wake up tomorrow as ...," I would unquestionably be all in, but that's not reality for any of us, even for those who do transition.
Before I say this next part, a big disclaimer: this is all about my perception of myself and my struggles with my own identity. Whatever others have to do to love and accept yourself, I fully support you in that.
So, I get that, technically speaking, mismatched sex/gender makes me trans. Maybe stealth trans? I don't feel at all comfortable calling myself trans, though. It feels inaccurate and even offensive. Maybe it's that I'm older and grew up before a lot of this was common. Maybe I have a little bit more of a transmed leaning. Either way, I don't feel like just having a female gender identity is enough to be trans. I don't think my experience matches that of TW, and I don't want to minimize your experience or fake my own experience. That said, in some way there is a common thread, which is what brings me to communities like this.
It also feels silly to call myself "a woman" (even though very deep inside, this is an undeniable core part of who I am). I look in a mirror and I'm clearly not a woman. I'm not even making any attempt to change my appearance, and I probably never will. I don't ask for she/her pronouns, or well he/him pronouns either. Self-selecting any set of pronouns feels inauthentic to me--they all contradict with something that I know to be true about myself.
So, this is why I don't have flair in this sub. I don't know what to choose. I guess I could choose MtF, but my identity was never any less female and my body will never be any less male. I also find it hard to find my place in the mainstream trans subs. I feel othered both from cis and trans communities. I don't share the gender identity of my cis counterparts, but don't share the physical transitioning (or the "transitioning is the only answer" philosophy) of a lot of the trans community.
This path of acceptance feels like it's helping me live my life and love myself, but it also feels like I'm very much on a lonely journey of my own.
What do you think of this? Anybody share this experience? Any related thoughts? Anybody flat out think my perspective is wrong? I'd love to hear any of it.
Posted Sep 7, 2020, 1:16 AM UTC