Skeptical about surface disinfectant spray

COVID-19

We're in week 2 of school down in Southwest Florida. For the first week, we had a disinfectant spray called ALPHA PH that we were instructed to use to clean desks at the end of every class period.

This week, suddenly there is this new amazing disinfectant that is apparently so powerful, we don't need to clean at all! They are so confident about this that over the weekend they took back every bottle of ALPHA spray that was in each teacher's classroom. It is being alleged that this powerful OMNIShield spray can kill Coronavirus and other baddies on contact for 90 days.

Their website has this to say:

When applied to a surface or incorporated into a material, OMNI Shield forms a covalent bond with the substrate and creates a microbiostatic antimicrobial coating. The coating forms a self-assembling monolayer, which carries a positive charge that attracts the negatively charged bacteria. Once attracted, the monolayer ruptures the bacteria cell membranes, causing those bacterial microorganisms to die.

I am but a humble English teacher, and this level of chemistry is lost on me. It seems plausible that this solution is pretty strong, but the 90 claim has me feeling skeptical. To me it seems likely that my district realized how much it was going to have to spend on the cleaning solution for every teacher and wanted/needed to save money...

Do these claims seem legit to you?

Posted Sep 8, 2020, 8:35 PM UTC

57
RubberCatTurds•

I teach biochemistry. To translate the description into English teacher terms, please read "Jabberwocky" by Lewis Carroll.

11
Geodude07•

I have to say it sounds a bit strange that this supposedly works for so long. I don't really have the expertise to know, though other sources for the same cleaner said it could be worn down on certain surfaces that are touched often and require reapplication sooner.

It has not been tested specifically on COVID either. Though it says other similar things have been tested and it works.

How reliable that is is questionable but I only did a quick google search.

3
MoonlightReaper•

I found a few things about it, and I'm skeptical, but with proper application it looks promising for high-touch areas. The "antibacterial" language concerns me since COVID is not a bacteria - it is a virus - but the couple sources I found said the spray is "antimicrobial" and EPA approved to fight against COVID. The spray is composed of millions of nanocapsules filled with disinfectant and apparently continues to work even after the spray has dried. Body heat is supposed to help release the disinfectant.

I need to look more, but it does look interesting, though I'm not sure I'd trust it as a replacement just yet. If you can't disinfect with anything else, focus on the hand washing, sanitizing, and leaving faces alone!

My biggest concern would be if the school is having it applied correctly by people who know how to do it. If they spray this material in the same shoddy half assed way I see them spray surfaces after school, I'd definitely be concerned.

3
Chatfouz•

These claims do sound legit in a sense. This is actually how n95 mask work. They are electrically charged and work like a magnet to attract dust particles to stick to the fibers. Have you ever rubbed a balloon on your hair and it picks up bits of paper or sticks to wall? Same thing. This is why you can’t wash an n95 mask as the washing process de-electrifies the fibers and it loses most of its filtering ability.

So what this claims to do is put down a layer of attractive chemical that is similarly charged and will attract bacteria to it. Because at that size electric fields are crazy strong it will basically force the bacteria to crush under the force.

But viruses are different. They don’t have a membrane but a protein shell. I am not a microbiologist but I would suspect it doesn’t do squat against a virus. Not to mention that this

3
Chatfouz•

Also their COVID statement says it is the ozone and uV systems that are effective. This chemical spray is not included.

This sounds like a terrible idea based on a poor reading of the product descriptions

3
smartmouth314•

Physics teacher here. I call bs. A) covid is a virus, not a bacterium. From your quote, it ruptures bacteria cell membranes, so it doesn’t do shit to the virus. B) different bacterium have different cell membranes. I kinda understand what self-assembly is and I skimmed the Wikipedia article for self assembly monolayers. I do not believe something like this would work for 90 days against bacteria. BUT EVEN IF IT DID, COVID IS NOT A BACTERIA.

3
AutoModeratorMOD•

Welcome to r/teaching. Please remember the rules when posting and commenting. Thank you.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1