(VA) My HOA had to cancel our annual meeting in April due to COVID-19. The other board member is refusing to schedule an annual meeting. I can petition the court to order the meeting. Would a judge order it?
To elaborate, I'm on the board of my HOA in Virginia. One board position is vacant, so there is only one other board member at the moment. We had to cancel our annual meeting in April due to the state of emergency due to COVID-19.
We're only a 45-unit community, so our annual meeting would be well under the 250-person limit for gatherings. We could have the event outside, socially distanced, with masks and sanitizer, and we could limit the length of the event to allow for the officer election and a limited amount of public comment.
Our bylaws make no provision for remote annual meetings, and so far the legislature has not decided to override bylaws for annual meetings. The legislature did override bylaws to allow board meetings to be held virtually, regardless of bylaws.
Virginia allows me to petition the circuit court if an annual meeting has not been held in the past 15 months. I'm seriously considering it.
The other board member is arguing that the state of emergency absolves us from legal consequences for not holding the annual meeting. She also says that she and neighbors are worried about contracting COVID-19.
So, would a judge look at this and order us to hold an annual meeting? Or would the judge agree that we are still in a state of emergency and that he or she can't compel an annual meeting until the emergency is lifted?
In case you are wondering, yes, the other board member's term of office will expire at the annual meeting, so she probably thinks she can extend her term of office by putting off the annual meeting.
Posted Sep 9, 2020, 2:15 PM UTC
If you have the meeting, do you have any chance of getting the quorum required by your bylaws to conduct an election? Is anyone prepared to go door to door to get proxies signed? Are you prepared to do it all again to have an adjourned meeting? Do you have other candidates for the two board seats who have come forward?
Do your bylaws allow the board to appoint a third member on a temporary basis?
Do you have professional property management? What do they recommend?
Good points.
Quorum is 10%, so 5 members/proxies. I think that should be doable.
Our bylaws do permit us to appoint the third board member position to serve out the balance of the three-year term. Nobody has officially come forward to claim it. I have at least one person who has shown interest in being on the board. I should try to find another candidate as well.
The other board member is difficult to work with, so a lot of people don't want to serve on the board with her.
We do have a professional management company. Our manager said most of their other communities are having the annual meeting virtually, but also said that there would not be legal implications for postponing the annual meeting.
The way I read the law I don't believe it's legal for us to hold a virtual annual meeting. Our bylaws say that the notice of meeting has to specify a "place, day and hour of the meeting", and Virginia law only permits virtual meetings if bylaws don't require a place.
We do have an attorney, and I asked the other board member several times for a written opinion from the attorney about this. She has promised to provide this, but has not so far.
Like I said, she's difficult to work with, and quick to accuse people of having ulterior motives. I'll ask her again soon, and probably ask for the attorney's contact info so I can ask myself, but I need to prepare myself for her to accuse me of something.
If you have another person willing to serve, then convince the other current board member to appoint this person. Then the two of you can outvote her on the annual meeting.
I think you're reading the VA law overly literally and that nothing will happen -- except increased attendance -- if the meeting is held virtually. Legal opinions are expensive.
If you have professional management, that's who should be communicating with your attorney. Not any individual board member.
You may be right about me reading the VA law overly literally. In this case, how do I make sure we legally in the clear to have a virtual annual meeting?
I didn't realize that our management company should be communicating with the attorney, rather than any individual board member. I'm not really sure how to fix this, though.
You rely on the advice you receive from professionals like your management company. Given the apparent level of apathy in your HOA, it also seems unlikely that anyone is going to sue the HOA over it.
You ask your manager to handle it, and to call the attorney and get a quick opinion about the meeting. A memo will take hours and cost hundreds of dollars.