Playing "meta" knowledge straight with relatively poor writing skills can lead to a boring novel
I'm looking at you, Omniscient Reader's Viewpoint ðŸ˜
Tbh, I could tolerate it for close to 370 chapters but it gets boring and repetitive, not to mention the convoluted plot that's revealed in an extremely juvenile, fanfic-y "I know exactly what everyone is doing" fashion.
I mean don't get me wrong, the premise is kinda interesting and so is the world and mechanics if I think about it, even though it's terribly derivative. I don't mind that being played up as a joke or as a meta reference to the novel being influenced by the protag either, but the way that the author seems to intentionally use piss poor storytelling in the name of servicing his "meta" narrative gets to me in a way I can't quite pin down.
I honestly don't mind overpowered MCs or MCs driven by a "chosen one"/ "fated one" narrative either. I wouldn't be enjoying Cultivation Chat Group if I didn't have a stomach for that kind of writing, but overusing the worst kinds of plot devices and tropes in the service of making an overpowered, omniscient MC means that the writing at least needs to be good enough to make us care about the stakes being set up. So far, in over 350 chapters, the author has entirely failed to set up compelling emotional conflicts and scenarios even though I think that was the intention in some cases. One reason is because the MC almost literally never fails or loses anything significant, which is one problem (thus the author can't use loss as a character building theme). Another is that trying to write about a mechanically flawless MC with a straight face means you need to set up their character a lot better and I think it entirely fails to do it.
Does this mean that I think ORV is a terrible novel? No. It's well written enough to get me >60% of the way through what's honestly a somewhat verbose novel so there's some good in it. If you're in it just for the crazy twisted meta story, you might still enjoy it, but for me it barely cracks a 6-7/10 (generous) due to how little payoff there has been in over 350 chapters of development.
To be honest, I think one of the issues with the novel's narrative is that we can't enjoy it in an episodic manner, even if it's written explicitly using "Episodes" in its title. It reads like the longest, blandest serialized story in the world and that's off-putting to an extent when you expect similar episode wise payoffs that you would in an otherwise episodic grand narrative story, yknow?
Posted Sep 10, 2020, 8:07 AM UTC
I dropped it back then around Ch 280. Only reason I put was "lost interest" and it's probably because of the same reasons as you