Can you recommend a better choice than a Mazda3 (2009-13)?

Advice

I'm in the market for a reliable hatchback that I can use for the next 12 months in the UK. The aim here is to get around without issue and to minimise losses from owning this car. Therefore I'm after something that's robust, won't lose much value and will be easy to sell on.

Typically I'll be using it to commute (30 mins), occasional weekends away (0-3h) and sharing with the partner. I've been browsing listicles and adverts on Autotrader but I'm overwhelmed by the number of models in contention. I'm hoping to narrow it down to just a couple to view.

My current thinking is a Mazda3 (2009-13) or Hyundai i30 (2012-17), but then I'm an idiot. What are better suggestions?

Must have:

  • Around the £4,000 mark
  • Good all-round visibility and easy to park. No big C-pillars. Adjustable or higher driving position
  • Reliable. Low-risk maintenance and servicing. Abundance of parts
  • Easy resale and good residual value
  • Nice exterior. This is my pride talking. I'd like something at least a little bit like the V40, A-class, Mazda3, 1 series etc that'll look alright in the car park at work. The round Focus/Corsa/Clio/Bravo/Leon shapes look bloated and horrible to me.

Nice to have:

  • Interior style. I find the cloth interiors of old Polo/Golf models depressing. I think darker interiors have a bit more life in them. The fewer dash buttons the better.

Indifferent:

  • Engine size (unless there's a particular issue or benefit)
  • Petrol/diesel (as long as it's compatible with usage)
  • Manual/automatic gearbox
  • Number of doors
  • Infotainment screens
  • Being a fun car to drive

Posted Sep 10, 2020, 12:05 PM UTC · edited

119
ChristofferooSuperb Mk3 Estate•

About 5 years ago I test drove a new i30. I hated it. Everything about it felt cheap. The engine was underpowered, the interior was tat, the seats were coarse. I test drove a Mazda3 that day too and it was in a whole different class.

3
FinancialYearOP•

This is what I came here for. Do you have any other recommendations? !thanks

1
ChristofferooSuperb Mk3 Estate•

I don’t have loads of different car experience, sadly. But from what I know the stereotypes are true: medium sized Fords and Vauxhalls are mediocre - my dad has these and they’re alright. I had a Nissan and it was practical and soulless. My Peugeot was stereotypically comfy and unreliable. I’ve just got a 2017 Skoda Superb and I think it’s great. People are Skoda mad everywhere it seems. My neighbours love their Octavia.

In terms of retaining values, I think Volvos probably fair very well.

2
FinancialYearOP•

I drove a V40 and enjoyed it but man the buttons on that dash.. it’s like a scientific calculator strapped to the console.

3
ChristofferooSuperb Mk3 Estate•
2
ChristofferooSuperb Mk3 Estate•

Oh yeah, my partner’s 2004 Civic is such a lovely car. Not lovely for its age, just lovely. I can see why people rave about them.

2
KEEPCARLM•

Whatever you do don't buy a diesel mazda. Petrol is amazing, no issue with that. Stay away from diesel mazda

3
FinancialYearOP•

Appreciate it. !thanks

1

Following

2
BigRigs6305 Corolla - Honda Shadow•

Not really better, can offer different options but the Mazda3 is already rather good in its class.

Octavia's are really nice, the higher trim models (laurin & Klement for example) will be significantly nicer than anything in a Mazda3. Sort of an issue, while visibility is great the rear of the car is shaped more like a saloon with the boot being outreached so maybe that's not what you're looking for. Also sort of has that "bloated"/bubbly look.

You already mentioned a Volvo, have you looked at the s40s? The styling of it might be to your liking and it's within budget. The higher trims especially have nice interiors that you expect from a Volvo.

1
FinancialYearOP•

I appreciate the considered suggestions. I’ll look into these. !thanks

1

2012 Honda Civic. I drove both when I bought my current car and found the Mazda to have a weird driving position, vague gearchange and bitey clutch. The interior was also more plasticky and it was noisier on the motorway.

YMMV though, try out both thoroughly and see what you like. They're both practical and will never, ever break down so you can't really go wrong.

1
FinancialYearOP•

!thanks. I’d been put off by my perception of its size (quite large?) and Parkers’ review that rear visibility was bad. The rear does sit quite high up from what I can tell. What did you think?

2
YoungMansBlues•

I tried out a 2013 Civic recently and I found it really nice to drive. The only downside (and a big one imo) is that there's a pseudo spoiler thing that cuts across the rear window about 1/3 of the way up, so rear visibility isn't as good as it could be. I'm a tall guy so I was able to just use the top part of the back window but it could be an issue for average/smaller drivers.

I wouldn't call the Civic large but it's a decent size on the inside and has a big boot.

2
FinancialYearOP•

There’s probably an age above which a spoiler on your car is a crime. 25?

1
YoungMansBlues•

Spoiler is maybe the wrong word? It's this.. Not exactly Asda car park Subaru Impreza.

2

Yeah the rear visibility isn't great. You get used to it but sometimes I miss my Matiz for being able to park it in my sleep. It's certainly not a small car and when you're hunkered down in the cabin you feel its size up to a point, but it's not a big car either.

The rear is high to accommodate the magic seats, so it has a dumpy looking (and hideous) rear end but the boot is absolutely enormous.

2