The Religion and Sex Slavery problem: My Christian family member believes pornography is responsible for human trafficking and that criminalizing sex work / banning adult content is the solution.

The issue of justice for victims of sex slavery is something I’m very concerned about and I’m completely disgusted and appalled that it flourishes in my own country.

I think it’s obvious that treating victims of these crimes as criminals themselves is patently absurd and I still have a hard time believing this is how our legal system is currently written.

However, my Christian family member tells me that the majority of women in the adult film industry are victims of sex slavery and that pornography is also responsible for encouraging violence, broken families, child molestation and much, much more - it’s essentially the greatest non-virus related crisis our society is facing.

I tried googling phrases related to “porn statistics” and was treated to dozens of sites and foundations with varying degrees of overtness about God, stuffed with dubious studies, statistics and credit card forms. After scrolling through several pages of results, it was clear there’s little objective information about this subject that can easily rise above the religious noise.

If this is a popular opinion among Christians in the US, could we actually be in danger of having more Sharia like morality written into our laws?

It’s a chilling prospect and I’m terrified of the implications this could have for sex crime victims.

Posted Sep 12, 2020, 3:48 AM UTC

2758
feihCtneliSehT•

This is the same lack of nuance that fuelled the war on drugs. Sex work is a job like any other, the notion that it inherently demeans women itself demeans women by stigmatizing them for it.

It's not even comparable to sexual slavery, a prostitute or porn star does not belong to anyone. She isn't 'selling her body' anymore than a professional boxer is.

Seems like they're just scapegoating, rather than actually adressing the specific things that could make prostitution and pornography dangerous, they just use it to blame all our societal ills.

14
CarlBitbyterOP•

Yeah you're right about the war on drugs connection. The conversation I recently had with this family member first involved ridiculing my position on legalizing drugs and then accusing me of supporting sex trafficking for wanting to legalize prostitution.

The most frustrating thing is they're convinced I'm an immoral sex-crazed monster.

4
feihCtneliSehT•

They gravitate so easily to ad hominem and straw-manning, often because they care more about validating their religious values than actually making a change for the better. The moment you add any complexity to the discussion, you're automatically lumped together with everything they oppose.

It's a shame really, cause if we can't honestly discuss these things, we can't move forward as a group.

4
elduche212•

In those type of conversations just remind them of prohibition and the massive rise in organise crime the new black market facilitated.

3
NikolasTrodius•

If prostitution was legalized and regulated I think we could help lower trafficking. Once there is a legal option those who aren't looking for underage girls would have a legitimate place to go. I'd like to see trafficking statistics from Australia or the Netherlands to see if they are lower or higher than the US. Prostitution will exist either way, much like drug use.

The porn industry is super problematic and needs more regulation. The internet does make it difficult as they will move to another country if we regulate it more. We shouldn't let that stop us.

6
Ikwuin•

If prostitution was legalized and regulated I think we could help lower trafficking.

Totally agree. We need legalization and regulation to bring down trafficking

3
[deleted]•

[removed]

5
morepowerplease•

Slave owners in the new world sexually abused their black slaves including children.

You think that didn't happen in the old world?

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

3
morepowerplease•

None of my ancestors were slave owners and they didn't live in the US, but this singling out the US as somehow uniquely guilty of practicing slavery is the domain of brainless sheep. You'd be better off on focusing on Africa or the Middle East, the real hotbeds of slavery throughout history, where it's still practiced in some parts.

3
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
JerkItToJesus•

Breaking the dicks of all the statues didn't solves sex crimes and i'm pretty sure other forms of censorship won't do the trick either.

4
Honodle•

The wide availability of pornographic material actually has been shown to reduce the incidence of sex crimes. There will always be predators, of course. But the average incel eyeing the little girl or boy down the street can just relieve himself to porn and that's the end of it. No abduction, no shallow grave, no prison term.

I'm pretty sure just about everyone has impure or inappropriate thoughts now and again. Seems to me pornography keeps the vulnerable safer by allowing an easy release of those thoughts rather than plotting and acting on them.

There will always be exceptions to be sure. There are seriously bad people out there in the world.

3
CarlBitbyterOP•

Yeah, I keep running into this Psychology Today article which claims that according to the National Crime Victimization Survey, sexual assault has decreased by 44% since 1995.

It also has a brief summary of 7 other referenced papers related to the issue (statistics from Czech Republic, Denmark, Japan, China and Hong Kong as well as analyzing the porn habits of rapists and the interpersonal connectedness of of porn users.

https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/all-about-sex/201601/evidence-mounts-more-porn-less-sexual-assault

2
Th3_Eleventy3•

Maybe someone should ask the priests how banning sex works out. They all have pretty bad track records if ya ask me.

2
dostiersStrong Atheist•

Yeah, because it worked so well in the past.

Just like not allowing sex ed in schools and preventing access to contraception prevents teen pregnancy.

2
KittenKoderAnti-Theist•

Banning adult content would only increase the rate of sexual abuse.

2
Ikwuin•

However, my Christian family member tells me that the majority of women in the adult film industry are victims of sex slavery

That is actually correct. It's a very real issue and many have spoken against it. Your usual stars won't do the extreme acts. Solution? Trafficking.

I think it’s obvious that treating victims of these crimes as criminals themselves is patently absurd

Of course it's absurd! It is wrong to treat the victims as criminals. It was not their fault that they were forced into it.

I still have a hard time believing this is how our legal system is currently written.

I'm not from US so I don't know much, but is that how it is? Sex-slavery victims are trailed as criminals!? That's nonsense!

And as for banning explicit material, the verdict is split. There's serious danger of getting addicted, but that applies to everything I guess.

0
CarlBitbyterOP•

...the majority of women in the adult film industry are victims of sex slavery

That is actually correct.

Do you have any data to support this claim?

1
Ikwuin•

My bad. Should have linked the articles. Here's one:

https://fightthenewdrug.org/by-the-numbers-porn-sex-trafficking-connected/

A first person narrative :

https://exoduscry.com/blog/shiftingculture/a-survivor-of-teen-porn-trafficking-speaks-out-on-pornhub/

Also, I said that because my good friend is actually involved with saving girls forced to film. If you still honest believe that pornography industry isn't driven my sex-slavery, then I suggest you look into it yourself. Typing "porn statistics" isn't probably the best search term though

0
CarlBitbyterOP•

Typing "porn statistics" isn't probably the best search term though

It's funny you say that because the websites you liked (fightthenewdrug and exoduscry.com) are examples of what's returned from those types of Google searches and the precise ones I was referring to in my OP.

Further, those sites don't even claim that the majority of adult film performers are exploited and they're figuratively dripping with religious bias.

It seems you're taking the claim from these dubious sites that most sex trafficking involves pornography and making the faulty conclusion (which even they don't make) that therefore most pornography involves sex trafficking.

I suggest you look into it yourself.

I have looked into it myself; my point was about how someone such as yourself might be misled by the most easily available information as you demonstrated.

I'm informed by sources like sociologist Ronald Weitzer and the book Sex at the Margins: Migration, Labour Markets and the Rescue Industry by Laura Agustín.

So again, I ask - do you have any data to back up your claim that the majority of women in the adult industry are victims of sex slavery?

2
Ikwuin•

Here's a paper on the topic I hope you don't find it "dripping with religious bias".

Some more articles :

https://www.nytimes.com/2019/10/11/us/porn-sex-trafficking.html

https://www1.cbn.com/cbnnews/cwn/2019/april/the-porn-industry-is-modern-day-slavery-how-pornography-and-sex-trafficking-are-linked

​

I have nothing against women who work in in the industry. And okay, maybe "most women" was an overstatement . But even if the percentage is below 20%, I find it unacceptable. What we need isn't a ban on pornography, but stricter regulations and cross border patrolling. I hate people being exploited . I've seen first hard how hard it can be for the family of a girl who's trafficked.

Do you really think there's no trafficking involved? There clearly is. I've seen it happen over and over and it's heart breaking. To the women who want to work in that field, more power to them. Stigmatization is akin to demeaning. But for those who don't want to, they should be left alone.

0
FrenchKisstheDevilNihilist•

This is a very unpopular opinion on Reddit, but I think sex work reinforces a patriarchal societal order in which women are viewed as exploitable sex objects that can be used and abused by men. Sex work has a negative net impact on society.

Victims should be treated as victims, not as criminals, but I am opposed to pornography

-1†
CarlBitbyterOP•

The uninformed aspect of your opinion might have something to do with it's unpopularity.

3
FrenchKisstheDevilNihilist•

Sure

1
JerkItToJesus•

You know there are male sex workers too, are they also exploited victims?

Exploitation is the issue, it doesn't matter if it's a sex worker or a cleaner that is being exploited.

2
FrenchKisstheDevilNihilist•

Yes, they are being exploited. You’re correct

-4
JerkItToJesus•

How? If i right now choose to go suck someones cock for money how exactly am i being exploited? I am just of my own volition providing a service to another person in exchange for money.

5
krba201076•

no sane person wants to do that for a living. people who go into these "businesses" are desperate for cash and in deep shit.

-1†
FrenchKisstheDevilNihilist•

Whatever man. I’m not on the mood to argue. Suck all the dick you want

-2
RogueNarc•

It may be an unpopular opinion and one I don't agree absolutely with but it is one that should be heard and competently argued

1
FrenchKisstheDevilNihilist•

Thank you. That is literally the most mature response I've ever gotten. Sometimes this sub really disappoints me

1
dragonfly_snow•

I am strongly aginst pornography and i do belive that it should be either baned or heavily restricted. I see nothing good coming out of it, only bad. Main reasons for me are:

  1. Porn addiction, a lot of people especially men can get addicted to porn, it will damage the relationship and can even lead to infidelity if they decide to act on their fantasies.
  2. Young men learn to treat women with disrespect because of porn. When you are young you often don't understand how to treat your partner right yet and will thake porn as a real thing. Have you even seen the hardcore porn that is out there?
  3. Porn fuels the demand for sex trafficking
  4. People being exploited and forced to perfom for the camera.
  5. Its very hard to distinguish the difference in porn between consented individuals and those who were forced

There are a lot more. I do not see any benefit of it to society. What we truly need is sex education in schools. Maybe also education about healthy relationships.

-2†
CarlBitbyterOP•

Its very hard to distinguish the difference in porn between consented individuals and those who were forced

This is a good point, and the reason everyone should be encouraged to support their performers directly and not through platforms that could feature exploitative videos.

Porn addiction, a lot of people especially men can get addicted to porn, it will damage the relationship and can even lead to infidelity if they decide to act on their fantasies.

False.

Online Porn Addiction: What We Know and What We Don't - A Systematic Review

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6352245/

Young men learn to treat women with disrespect because of porn.

Also False.

Contemporary societies with restrictions on pornography have much higher instances of rape and violence against women.

Porn fuels the demand for sex trafficking

Again, false.

Countries with restrictions on porn have higher instances of sex trafficking.

People being exploited and forced to perform for the camera

That's a crime, not pornography.

Edit:

Accidentally posted before finishing

6
Ikwuin•

That's a crime, not pornography.

Crime is being committed in the pornography industry. That's the issue.

1
elduche212•

Crime is being committed in any industry that can produce in low labour cost/high abuse parts of the world. It's an utterly asinine argument to make.

2
Ikwuin•

How does the fact that crime is present in other industries undermine the necessity to stop crime? Also, I am not against pornography in any way. As long as it is produced legally. I don't agree with the u/dragonfly_snow at all.

That's a crime, not pornography.

I found this statement to be ridiculous and hence called it out. That's all there is to it. I am not making an argument for anything. Peace.

Edit : And by "legally made", I'm not referring to any particular country's laws on pornography. What I mean to say is as long the people involved aren't forced, it's fine to produce pornography.

Also, just an afterthought. I think legalizing the sex industry would make things much easier for victims to approach law. In my country, it isn't legalized, so it's much harder for the victim to come forth.

2
FlyingSquid•

Re #2- that is only the case if the porn itself is made disrespectfully. If the people having sex are not hurting or demeaning each other (and I admit that does happen in some porn, which I find revolting), I don't see how it teaches anyone to disrespect.

2