I've been working on some tile sets - here are a few mock-up screenshots made using Tiled (and a little editing to add characters)! They are far from finished, but I'd love to hear suggestions for things I can do to make each scene feel more complete without being cluttered.

I've been working on some tile sets - here are a few mock-up screenshots made using Tiled (and a little editing to add characters)! They are far from finished, but I'd love to hear suggestions for things I can do to make each scene feel more complete without being cluttered.

Posted Sep 14, 2020, 5:38 PM UTC

54
K4G3N4R4•

The big thing is that it feels empty, and almost blank. It looks like the backgrounds are using the auto tile feature to duplicate and extend. If that's the case, I would look into making a large pattern that doesn't repeat uniformly to allow texture in the open spaces. I also recommend detail variance along your bitmasked tilemap edges, make those paths feel a little more organic.

The coastline looks the best out of the three, but it also has less open space, and most variance in textures. I do recommend some filler objects for "clutter" just to keep the spaces from feeling sterile. Even if it is small rubble piles, or stacks of crates.

2
SlickSpecOP•

Indeed, the tiles have practically no variations at the moment and don't make use of things such as dirt/vegetation patches. I'll try to import some flavor tiles I used for another set, and work on making the edges less obvious. (Ideally each area should have a landmark and some unique flavor, plus an invisible web of paths you naturally feel like following, but that's for version 2.)

I agree with the open space being a problem right now. I think part of the 'blank' feeling stems from having enclosing walls on the bottom map but none on the two wastelands, so I'm thinking of introducing a badlands type of feel to direct the action more into rock valleys and such, or at least mark a border of sorts.

Clutter is a go. :)

Thank you for your feedback!

2
cs_ptroid•

It looks nice at first glance. But looking at it with a more critical eye, I can't help but notice that "Desert region" and "Jungle border" look very similar. The only difference is the colors. :/

Also the characters appear more detailed than the architecture. Perhaps you could add some sort of a texture (bricks, moss, cracks etc) to the buildings and walls. Some other props like pipes and such might help.

I suggest you check out the 2D game called "Chaos Engine". It also has the same top-down perpsective that you're going for and I am sure it will inspire you. It's got a variety of environments -- deserts, jungles, castles etc. and overall, there's a nice balance between natural formations and industrial elements. Each area stands out visually.

Here are some screens:

Mossy ruins

Rocky ruins

1
SlickSpecOP•

The first two images of mine are straight palette swaps, that's true. Not only that, but they don't have any edge variations on the tiles, so it's all square blocks. The border area is intended to transition in color and features into the next region. I'm hoping to spruce up each location with more obvious differences later - such as vegetation and more rocks. The only issue is that each new prop takes time to draw, and I'm running solo at the moment. :P

Chaos Engine looks really good! I like the way the artist adds texture to the ground by using craters and other minor details on an otherwise flat surface. (I have some reusable pebbles and plants already, I'll try adding them for a version 2.)

Large solid objects such as walls and stairs are hard for me to get right at my current skill level, but I love the inspiration I get from seeing what you posted. I have a folder full of screenshots from the 16-bit era and other pixel art games, and these go right in there.

Thanks a lot for the feedback, it gets the creativity flowing.

1