r/CrusaderKings•
golforce

Men-at-arms strategy?

Discussion

I'm by no means new to CK2, but still new-ish to CK3 and trying to wrap my head around Men-at-arms. From the way the battles work they seem like potentially the biggest factor to the strength of an army, but which should you build and why?

So far my choice has mostly been heavy infantry and pikemen as they both profit from barracks, which can be built in so many different terrains. I also built one siege regiment to make them a bit quicker.

Is this kind of composition good? Or are there better strategies to go about building them. Also does it make any difference if I first max out the size of my regiments before I create new ones?

Posted Sep 15, 2020, 10:23 AM UTC

610
arrasas•

You need to consider counters, not just raw stats and building benefits. Heavy infantry is countered by light infantry, which is far cheaper and used in abundance by the AI. As a result more likely then not, you are paying for very expensive and useless unit.

To decide what regiment of men at arms to rise, look at what men at arms your potential enemies have and in what terrain are you likely to fight them.

As I said before AI tends to field lot of light infantry, therefore I find heavy infantry to be useless. Light infantry is countered by archers, which is usually the first regiment I rise. I like then to combine them with pikemen. Pikemen have almost as good punch as heavy infantry but are countered by the heavy infantry. And AI fields heavy infantry only rarely in my experience. And then I usually add light cavalry which is good at pursuing enemy and protecting my men during pursuit.

But you should look at what AI is using in your region and decide accordingly.

Also, counters work on man to man basis. 200 archers will counter 200 light infantry twice as effectively as 100 archers. That said, counter debuff is huge, if I remember right 90% of the enemy combat stats. So you don't necessarily need to match enemy exactly to counter him "good enough".

Also don't underestimate siege engines, they are probably the most useful men at arms regiment, even if they don't take part in battles.

4
golforceOP•

Very interesting insight. Thank you.

I figured siege engines would be useful, but without the strength of regular men-at-arms I felt like my army would be too weak overall so I only built one regiment of siege engines.

I was thinking about the compositions, but stupidly didn't think to check what the AI uses. I also did not know how severe the counter penalties are.

3
arrasas•

One regiment of siege engines should be enough. You should be fine.

1
Ulthir•

I've had the complete opposite experience. Heavy infantry is very versatile since they have no terrain weakness, the stats aren't half bad either, makes for a good 'center". The real loser for me is cavalry, they don't pack as much of a punch as they should, and are under constant terrain debuffs.

1
arrasas•

Heavy infantry is countered by every petty count with his LI spam.

2
konflict88•

pursuit is OP.light cavalry is great

1
MgDark•

actually light cavalry is great, if i have a few maxed stacks of light cavalry, and i build around them, they will have so much pursuit that you will literally delete armies in retreat (is quite easy for light cavalry to pursuit levies, and they really destroy them).

1
nbaprojectJust•

Fully stacked siege weapons

3
jdogg17873•

I think the AI usually builds skirmishers and Calvary so I have been doing 2 bow men, 2 pike men, and load up on siege weapons. Once you max build the siege weapons you can seize holdings pretty quickly. In one of my dynasties - I was seizing holdings in 10 days.

I will also say the commander you use has a big factor as well - I have seen armies with many more men get wiped out by a strong commander.

2
Tyrant597•

Stack archers, hide tents, and never fight in open terrain. 😛

1