r/livesound•
kelcema

No Stupid Questions Thread - Week of 2020-09-14 - 2020-09-20

The only stupid question is the one left unasked!

Do you have a basic question you want answered? Let us help! Remember that r/livesound is for PA/sound systems/streaming -- we may not be able to be as helpful with questions about, say, home theatre systems. Keep in mind that the more information about your setup (amps, speakers, mixer, microphones) you can provide, the quicker we'll be able to help you!

Posted Sep 15, 2020, 6:57 PM UTC

741
AudioThrowAway9999•

How much is u/IHateTypingInBoxes paying these people for these specific and technical SPL monitoring questions?

6
IHateTypingInBoxesTaco Enthusiast•

Not enough it seems. They always seem to crop up just as I'm about to sit down for a meal or drive somewhere lol.

Seriously though, despite the "covid pause" , and maybe to some extent because of it, SPL stuff, particularly the health and safety aspects of it, has been steadily trickling down through the industry in terms of a growing consciousness and it's not just the huge festivals worrying about it anymore. It's becoming more and more common at FOH position, and now that we have thousands of people in the audience with Apple watches alerting them to Exposure hazard, there's really no going back. We still have quite a ways to go in terms of our understanding of these concepts, but we will get there. Not unlike the "digital revolution" or the proliferation of audio analyzers.

Bob McCarthy writes about starting his work with dual channel analyzers in the 80s and how people looked at him crazy for having it, and now you're more likely to get a crazy look if you don't have some sort of measurement system when you're doing this work.

We're now at a point as an industry where we actually acknowledge the fact that our systems can be, and are, loud enough to do damage, and for the most part we've moved past "let's all see how loud we can be, if it's too loud you're too old," etc. The next step after realizing we can hurt people is figuring out how to do what we do safely, without hurting people, just like pretty much any other job out there. And I welcome that. Because I like being able to hear. 😁

8
kelcemaOP•

I think George Soros pays him 2¢ per word typed and a buck per karma point. Sounds petty, maybe, but that's not a petty BMW he's driving these days. ;)

3
IHateTypingInBoxesTaco Enthusiast•

I drive a Ford EcoSport, would you believe that

3
AshamedGorillaPro - Crabtown, USA•

I do believe that. Because any self respecting* freelancer will drive a reliable car.

*(He says, with two BMWs in the driveway, one of which may or may not have been on fire earlier today 🤦🏻‍♂️)

4
scienceguy4•

Might be the wrong place to ask, I'm totally new to anything sound related. I have to collect Leq, L10, and Lmax data (A-weighted, slow response) for a science project. I . I was looking for iPhone apps to do this, but they only seem to collect Leq and Lmax data. Whats the best and cheapest way to go about this? Can I record the sounds with the voice memos app on my iPhone and upload that sound file onto my computer and into a downloadable or online sound analyzing app or would that ruin the measurement quality? And if I could do that without compromising the sound quality, what sound analyzing app should I use?

4
IHateTypingInBoxesTaco Enthusiast•

Oh, good, I love SPL stuff. Can you share more about your project and what exactly you're looking to do? A couple elements to the answer.

  • Calibration: this is the main reason it's not going to be helpful to record the audio file and then try to run it through SPL metering afterwards. The software can only see the digital values coming in. Since SPL is a measure of acoustic pressure fluctuations, the software needs a way to know what acoustic pressure at the microphone caused those digital values. Without that, the data isn't meaningful. This is usually done with an acoustic calibrator - a device that's placed over the microphone and produces a known SPL, say 110 dB SPL. Then the software can look at the digital level coming in, and we can tell it "this is the level that you'll see when the acoustic pressure is 110 dB SPL." Then the software has a reference for what it's seeing. If you just record a file to analyze later, you won't have that acoustic reference level and you won't be able to extract meaningful SPL data from it.
  • Phones in particular are generally not an appropriate way to gather SPL data if you need the data to be accurate / meaningful, for a number of reasons which I'm happy to elaborate on if you're curious or very bored. Actual SPL software can generate the specific metrics you're supposed to be collecting, but you'll also want an audio interface and a measurement mic and stuff that I wouldn't expect you to have access to if you don't work in pro audio. There are always ways to get a "good enough" measurement, so some more info on exactly what you're trying to do will help us with a specific recommendation, though, and I can help you try to hack something together.
  • Leq is just an average level over some amount of time. You specified A weighted, so that's LAeq. You also need to specify the amount of time - LAeq 10 is a ten minute average, for example. Do you know how long of an average you are supposed to collect? Longer averaging times tend to give very different answers than shorter averaging times, so it's important.
  • LAmax is just the maximum A-weighted level recorded, and since you're specifying slow integration here, that's technically LASmax.
  • L10 is a statistical measure - it's the value that is exceeded by 10% of the data points. Take a look at this screenshot - in the lower left of the window you'll see Max and L10 along with L50 and L90. Those stats are all describing the A Slow data that was collected.
  • Purpose-built tools for this include Smaart SPL (which I helped design, and which has a free demo that will probably be perfect for this), or Room EQ Wizard, which can do some of these metrics, but I don't think it can do all of them.

I've also sent you a DM with my contact info, I love stuff like this and I don't have a lot going on right now so happy to help you with the project any way I can :)

EDIT: fixed formatting

14
soundwithdesignTheatre-Designer/Mixer•
5
IHateTypingInBoxesTaco Enthusiast•

I just saw this, lol. Thanks.

EDIT: i was literally on my way out the door to buy tacos

11

So what kind of tacos were they? I had some carnitas tacos and some steak tacos 🌮 🤤

2
IHateTypingInBoxesTaco Enthusiast•

Dinner combo #2. Two tacos and two enchiladas. With no lettuce because ew lettuce. Met up with u/Fjordn before rehearsal.

5
kelcemaOP•

ping also to update stickied NSQ threads :)

2
theotheredbaronSemi-Pro UK•

Bound to be a stupid one here, but can I plug a reference mic into my x32 and somehow use it as an SPL meter? I assume I'd have to reference the gain to set against an actual SPL meter.

OK, I think I just talked myself into buying the meter instead :) Just trying to reduce the amount of stuff I have in my gig box.

3
IHateTypingInBoxesTaco Enthusiast•

There's no SPL monitoring capability on the X32. You could patch the mic to a direct out and feed it into SPL software but all that's doing is skipping a a dedicated interface and opening up the potential for a gig-ending routing issue. Not speaking from experience or anything. 😁

8
theotheredbaronSemi-Pro UK•

Yeah, I thought that was the case - thank you for your reply! I'll get a meter and a bigger gig box :)

One of those daft questions that had been swirling around my brain!

1
IHateTypingInBoxesTaco Enthusiast•

Why do you want to measure SPL? Be aware that unless you're spending several hundred dollars on an SLM with NIST traceability the numbers it spits out are probably not meaningful. If you're just measuring for consistency (same level every night) then this is completely fine, but if you're measuring for compliance with a regulation or for exposure, you will want an accurate tool.

3
theotheredbaronSemi-Pro UK•

I think you and the other person above have answered my question, thank you both! I just know all the pro people on here have that capability and I currently don't so was looking for a shortcut.

I'll carry on using my ears at the volume level I usually work at, which is folk. Thanks again.

1
This_ManU67Other•

Just got a gig running monitors for a house show. For some reason a singer today just complained about distortion in her ears for the first time. For reference the IEM tx/rx is Sennhieser G4. The whole week has been fine but today she told me she was hearing distortion but I wasn't driving my outputs hard nor could I hear it in my cue pack. Very curious. I'm thinking its either the In ear drivers going bad (shure 315). Or the receiver pack is acting fucky. Has anyone experienced this problem?

1
thebreadstoosmall•

If you plug your IEMs into her pack, briefly (!) crank up the level to as loud as you can tolerate and cannot hear any distortion then it's likely her IEMs.

The easiest (and by far the cheapest) way to ascertain whether the problem is with her IEMs is one of these:

https://www.westone.com/store/hearing_health_care/westone-listening-stethoscope-2267

Run a source of pink noise into her IEMs, listen with the stethoscope. You can typically hear obvious distortions, and differences between L & R sides. 315's are single driver IEMs, but with multi-driver units it's also possible to check the individual output tubes for each driver.

Bear in mind that what you hear through the stethoscope will not sound the same as what you would hear by putting the IEMs in your ears (you can listen to the difference by checking with your IEMs) due to the inherent resonances involved in listening through a foot and a half of narrow plastic tube. There are 'artificial ear' systems from the like of Brüel & Kjær that allow you to run an FFT analysis (same as SMAART) on IEMs via a tube connected to a mic which is then phase and frequency corrected to allow accurate measurements. These systems are about $5,000 so I'd stick with the stethoscope for now!

5
This_ManU67Other•

I appreciate the response. I might have a new item to put in my work bag/pelican. I'm hoping I can figure out the problem today so I can just focus on the show.

1
willyarm•

I've had singers describe RF dropouts/interference as distortion before. Can kinda see their point - the guy was not that interested in the technical side of things and just had nasty noises in his ears. The joys of getting into people's heads on monitors.

I also had a guitarist that told me that his actual ears (not earpieces) distorted if he turned his pack up past a certain level. He looked annoyed when my suggestion was to maybe not turn it up that loud.

4
This_ManU67Other•

So I actually solved the problem. It turns out that the sqelch settings I had were high enough that during certain songs it would be on the verge and cut in and out. Sounding like distortion.

2
thebreadstoosmall•

Glad it was an easy fix. I make a habit of doing a hardware reset of every pack in a new IEM rig, then either manually editing or defining in sync settings the baseline settings for my packs.

You should also walk test your packs whilst covering the antenna entirely with your hand - this simulates the worst case scenario of the antenna being pressed against a sweaty person's body/bare skin - if you still have solid signal like this then you can be pretty sure any issues you might have won't be RF transmission related.

2
willyarm•

Glad it was a simple fix! Always good when you don't need to replace things

1
TheCaptainhat•

Where do you measure your show's overall decibel level from? Just from mix position? I had a recent event where levels were comfortable in mix position and listening positions. Crowd thought it was good, but the actual staff (who were right in front of the PA, within ~10 feet) were convinced I was running everything way too loud.

1
AshamedGorillaPro - Crabtown, USA•

I usually measure from FOH but that doesn't mean I'm necessarily monitoring levels AT FOH.

Some SPL limits are enforced for all attendees. That means those in the front row too. You can keep track of this by taking a level at FOH and at the first row before doors open. You can take the difference and put in an offset on your mic at FOH. This will give you a better (though not 100% accurate) idea of what the level is at the front of the room.

However you should be setting levels for the audience, not staff. I often carry a bad of foam ear plugs for the security crew who are often placed in front of the front fills. First, see if they can stand somewhere else, and second, make sure they have the appropriate PPE.

2
IHateTypingInBoxesTaco Enthusiast•

Many of the European H&S SPL regulations require measuring from the loudest audience-accessible area. Since that's not usually accessible to a measurement mic position during the show, an offset measurement is used at FOH in most cases.

1
jholowtaekjho•

What does taking all four of my parametric EQ points and pulling them down do? I find when OTHER engineers do it, it can destroy the sound

1
greylokiI make things louder•

Depends a little on the context of this, but the simple answer will be 'it makes that channel quieter'.

3
freakytoneSF/Bay Area•

If I've got two different free speak 1.9 systems relatively close to one another, do i need to worry about them stepping on eachother?

1
kipkessmenPro - USA•

Not so much as in frequency space as in DECT time slots, which would be a function of the number of active belt packs in an area.

1
freakytoneSF/Bay Area•

How bout with a 1.9 system and a separate 2.4 system? Would active beltpacks show up in eachothers systems?

1
Generalpiggle•

I recently acquired some old PA Speakers, their audio is coming through but the tweeter on one is a bit weak at times and the other sounds really compressed and distorted. I checked the resistors on the crossovers and one reads around 1ohm and the other reads 3ohms. They are 20ohm/15W resistors. Should I replace them since they are cheap? Also do I use wirewound resistors or a different type.

1
SoundPon3Learning to ride faders•

Unsolder one leg of the resistor and double check. That's really far off. Replace them with the same type, typically wirewounds

1
Generalpiggle•

They are cement resistors and for whatever reason finding a 15W20ohmJ cement resistor is quite difficult, any chance I could replace it with a wirewound?

1
SoundPon3Learning to ride faders•

Cement resistors are wirewounds, it's just ceramic potting holding the wire in place. As long as it's the same wattage and impedance, it'll be completely fine :)

1
Mice_And_Gods•

Have a brand new QSC GXD 8 that started strongly smelling of burning electronics on its first run. It was used to run 2 subs (one per side) at 8ohms and the full 800w output per side for ~3 hours on bass heavy music.

Input sensitivity set at -0db (range is -100db to +30db). Crossover set at 80hz. The burning smell started about 1 hour in and stopped when I brought the sensitivity down to -20db.

Clipping lights never flashed and the status indicator shows that everything is good to go, but it REALLY smells strongly. I don't feel like I was asking the amp to do something it wasn't designed for.

What would you do? Request a refund? RMA? I don't feel like I can reliably trust the amp at this point.

1
alwaysearlyy•

Hello! So I got the Soundcraft Notepad 5 and I’ve been trying to download the control panel driver for the last few days. On Mac, I was able to download the driver and use the mixer but on Windows, whenever i try to open the .exe file, it says “Windows cannot access the specified device, path, or file. You may not have the appropriate permissions to access the item.” Any solutions please?

Hoping to use the mixer on Windows bc my sister owns the Mac I tested it on and my laptop is a Windows. Thanks!

1
The_Chees3•

Hey, /livesound, I'm running the sound for my church's live stream. We have a synth that plays with us, and I'm having a very specific and strange problem with it. We use it as a quieter, transitional instrument that isn't playing much lead, so I keep it lower in the mix than most things. If it gets too loud in the mix, it quickly overpowers every sound on the stage and all the other instruments sound like mud. That's not really the problem, I keep that from happening well enough when I'm running the sound.

We use microphones to mic our speakers for the stream. Not ideal, I know, but it's the simple solution we have. When I listen back to the stream on my television, and we get to a quiet part of the music, the synth is giving me this really prominent, pulsing warble that I assume has something to do with the frequency at which it's signaling the mic. The weirdest part is it doesn't happen while the louder piano is playing at the same time. I also think it could be being boosted by the compressor when things are quiet, but I don't think I'm experienced enough to know for sure that's what's happening, or how to keep it from happening. The thing is it's fine on phone speakers or laptop speakers. I have, thus far, only heard this happen on my flatscreen TV. When listening to it on smaller speakers, a trained ear can hear what would be a warble if it were louder and had better bass speakers. I tried dialing back the bass EQ with a big HPF on the in-house board, but that didn't seem to do the trick.

Is there anybody out there who knows what I'm dealing with here? It's bugging me a whole bunch, and I'd like to know how I can fix it. Thanks for any help or insight you can provide!

0