I know that the Wii U cant run 3DS games, but what exactly is preventing it?

In theory you would think that the Wii U would be more than capable of running the games, but since that isn't the case does anyone here know why not?

Posted Sep 15, 2020, 8:09 PM UTC

4030
[deleted]•

[deleted]

62
ModernPixelsOP•

as someone who knows little about how emulation works it seems hard to believe, but yeah im sure people have put hours into trying it before. thx for taking the time to spell it out for me

edit: thx to everyone who responded, it helped me a lot with understanding exactly how emulation works

7†
CoolFiverIsABabe•

N64 still isn't emulated perfectly on many systems.

51
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-19
badaboomxx•

Not really, I remember, if I am correct, desert strike wasn't 100% emulated correctly and had an issue with the shadows. I know it is rom to rom basis, but 100% emulation in the SNES wasn´t perfected in 20 years.

2
MikeIronFist•

Think of it like this: The 3DS is like a small car. The Wii U is like a pickup truck.
Imagine trying to put the car - and its passengers - into the bed of the pickup truck and THEN trying to drive it to your destination. You'd be lucky if you could even get the pickup to move! It doesn't matter that the truck is so much more powerful than the car; it wasn't made to carry the entirety of the car itself while doing its job.

That's the kind of performance problem software emulation faces, to oversimplify it a bit.

When a CPU does an operation, ideally it happens as fast as the CPU can manage. When there's an emulator involved, the CPU is working to recreate the emulated hardware's behavior, so it has a workload that is several orders of magnitude higher than the original system. Multiple operations are being done on the real CPU to produce a single operation on the emulated CPU. It's never just a matter of one machine being more powerful than the other; you need several orders of magnitude more power to do it well.

There's certain situations where there's exceptions to this (e.g. PSone Classics on PSP/Vita) but in general, emulation is a hefty workload for a CPU to take on.

40
Rubadubrix•

What about if you had the source code?

1†
dryingsocks•

you could port the game to run natively, which needs a lot less resources, but it's way more complicated. The Wii U and the 3DS have very different hardware

8
Shawnj2Wii U 5.5.1 CBHC CFW+ vWii w/HBC•

Think about it like this- in order to run 3DS games on a Wii U, the Wii U processor needs to create a virtual 3DS processor capable of running 3DS CPU instructions, which takes a lot of work.

2
lefsler•

One way of looking at it is . Look at emulation as 2 different things, one is translation where the software has to read the instructions on the binary and translate into something that can be executed on that machine and the other is execution itself..... its like asking someone to read a book in english while telling tje story to someone in japanese at the same time, taking in consideration linguistic expressions and jokes . Not all emulators goes for perfect emulation speed, but they get so close that you cant tell . Also emulators bot only translate the code, but also music, trxtures and model files... most complex consoles, like the 3ds, even need system calls (like open files) to be emulated to some degree. Emulators are some of the most complex type of softwares out there (sure, it depends on what you are emulating)

2
Ben-Z-S•

When you emulate you need more power than the system youre emulating. Youre essentially running a computer within a computer. At the same time it still needs to run the Switch hardware

1
HRudy94•

The processor itself would be powerful enough but as the 3DS is on ARM and the Wii U on PowerPC, it makes emulating the first one on the second much more difficult.

7
PanJanJanusz•

as the 3DS is on ARM and the Wii U on PowerPC

hmmmmmm, that makes me wonder because I know that it was discovered that Wii u had a arm processor responsible for system stuff, I might be wrong tho

3
tobimori_•

The 3DS (ARM) and Wii U (PowerPC) have different processor architecture and therefore the Wii U can't run the Games natively (like Gamecube Games with Nintendont). So they must be emulated, and that's something the Wii U's PowerPC processor is too slow for.

24
migs9000•

https://dolphin-emu.org/blog/2018/07/21/myth-debugging-wii-more-demanding-emulate-gamecube/

Emulation is more difficult than you’d think. You have to be 4 to 8 to 16 times faster to emulate that hardware. It’s a finicky process

12
ThePizzaMuncher•

It's not strong enough to emulate the 3ds, let alone the new 3ds.

Ninty could've perhaps made ports (they kind of did in reverse) but we're past the age where that can happen now.

10
therourke•

The wizard says no

3
_Yourmomrider69_•

It doesn't have enough power for something like citra, but if someone made a 3ds emulator which used a dynamic recompiler (which I highly doubt) It could work

2
SilverBolt52•

Yeah it def could be done but the amount of work required just to make a dynarec core, not to mention HLE calls. Each game would likely need to be patched too, as the dynarec and HLE would likely lead to a ton of bugs in most games. And nobody is going to dedicate that into a dying system that never even sold well.

Hell, we don't even have a Wii U N64 emulator. Or a dynarec for PSX. I know ReARMed and vWii Not64 get the job done but still... That's how left behind this console was in the homebrew scene.

1
o0banky0o•

It’s like if you did the work to port something, and as soon as you get it to compile, instead of whittling down the issues, you just wrote a separate program that handled the issues and left the port as is.

To be clear, I super, way, overly don’t know what I’m talking about, this is just another angle to cognate this shit at, please improve or discard

1
suckerpunchermofo•

It might be possible, but it would require a lot of work and very good coders.

1
CyberXarex•

well if you could natively port the games with no emulation (cough cough nintendo) it would probably work

1
Najatski•

I dont think there is anything stopping it from running 3DS games...

-9
Fat-Nuggs•

I know a lot dont like the 3D but you cant play games in 3D on your wii u. Also like already said the wii u cant emulate it, youre gonna need more processing power

4
Najatski•

I know you cant play them in 3d. You could play them in non-3D mode, correct?

1
[deleted]•

Read the other comments on this thread. It's not possible at all.

4