Deku never trained before OfA, and that's okay.
[removed]
Posted Sep 16, 2020, 4:00 PM UTC
[removed]
Posted Sep 16, 2020, 4:00 PM UTC
They handle physical training in the program itself, so if you showed up with arms that blow in the wind like a goddamn used car lot human windsock-lookalike, you could be assured that you would be able to get in shape quickly enough. They even blend your physical training with your Quirk training on a personal basis, so it's arguably advantageous to go in undeveloped, if you're working on the assumption that you can get in in the first place, something Izuku is counting on.
That’s like saying that you should try to join the NFL without being as fit as possible. Sure you could possibly still get in but you would be at a disadvantage compared to literally everyone else applying. The other UA applicants either had a quirk, a good physical state, or both. Deku had neither of those things. He had zero advantages over anybody. If he doesn’t have a quirk to help him then he should make his body stronger to compensate.
But how important is physical fitness to be a hero? Obviously, it's better to be swole than not swole in literally every single circumstance ever, but just how much of a requirement is it?
Endeavor’s quirk does absolutely nothing for his physical fitness but he still got buff enough to not only have high reaction speeds but also to survive getting dragged through a building without instantly dying. High End completely outclassed Endeavor in physical power but Endeavor managed to keep up because he didn’t just accept that others would be stronger.
That’s like saying that you should try to join the NFL without being as fit as possible. Sure you could possibly still get in but you would be at a disadvantage compared to literally everyone else applying. The other UA applicants either had a quirk, a good physical state, or both. Deku had neither of those things. He had zero advantages over anybody. If he doesn’t have a quirk to help him then he should make his body stronger to compensate.
It's more like signing up to join an NFL training program. And Deku is at a disadvantage to everyone else applying. Being able to lift a few more pounds isn't going to change that. Whether or not he ought to apply at all isn't the discussion I'm trying to have. Just whether or not being more in shape would help. It probably wouldn't, and he can get fit as part of the program.
The showing up totally noodle-armed comment was hyperbole, I admit.
Endeavor’s quirk does absolutely nothing for his physical fitness but he still got buff enough to not only have high reaction speeds but also to survive getting dragged through a building without instantly dying. High End completely outclassed Endeavor in physical power but Endeavor managed to keep up because he didn’t just accept that others would be stronger.
Yeah, but he (almost certainly) got that as a result of UA training. Everyone gets more buff as a result of that training. "Going beyond" is an in-universe element that just... exists. It's an established fact that pretty much anyone can just do better if the stakes are high enough and they want it badly.
Todoroki, by contrast, is pretty physically fit, but is stated to ignore his body in favor of his Quirk by Stain.
Not complaining, but think there was another post just like this yesterday about Deku and Asta.
That's what this is in response to. The comments on that thread were not very complimentary to Deku. I didn't want to reply bomb them, so...
Well you played yourself fella
Reply threads are not allowed, per our Post Rules 2:
DO NOT post a thread as a reply to another thread. Reddit will notify the user of your reply when you post it, we promise. Just because your comment is 3 pages deep and the world can't see the magic genius that is you, doesn't mean you post it as a seperate thread.
But it's not a reply to any one user. It's just a note on the general thought.
Hm maybe post it again in 1 or 2 days then, so it's not that tied to the previous rant and less reply-like
Thx
You still need some degree of physical fitness. Why would you try to join the military without getting into shape?
No, but I might join ROTC with an average amount of fitness.
Izuku didn't have an "average" level of fitness before meeting All Might. I'm pretty sure most of the former's classmates would have had a better handle on OFA than he did. You don't train once you're in the academy. You train in preparation for the academy.
Not everyone did. And being the weakest person on the football team doesn't mean you're weak. Again, this isn't about suitability for OFA - Deku had no reason to suspect that it existed, let alone that he'd be able to use it. Deku is more physically fit than a number of his classmates, including Mineta and Aoyama. Pre-training, he's able to hang on to All Might as he jumps hundreds or thousands of feet into the air. He's hardly weak, he's just not at the level where he can use OFA safely.
I didn't say he was weak nor did I say that everyone is stronger than him. I said he's under average compared to most of his classmates.
Bakugo, Todoroki, Shoji, Sato, etc didn't get their muscles just sitting around waiting for the U.A exam. They still trained their bodies alongside their quirks. That's why they'd be capable of using higher OFA percentages from the start and not need to go through an intensive ten month training program.
You don't wait for ROTC to get into basic shape. You do that before so that you can stand alongside your peers at the very beginning. That way, you don't hold them back.
I agree with your title but there's some minor things I disagree with
I know what you were trying to say but it doesn't really work and you could say this about knowledge too and if you're going to try saving anyone powers or not you need to be physically fit to do it
The test was about stopping the robots Mineta would gunk them up and Aoyama's would laser them
Jirou quirks is good for locating and finding enemies deku is just a walking wikipedia article
muscles aren't the end all be all but they're usefull and shinso's quirk would be useless on robots so even if he took he would fail. It's known that the test is biased towards flashier quirks
He shouldn't have assumed he would get in the first place he should've been more realistic and assumed he wouldn't get in any way
and if you want to be the best hero you can be you should train your mind and body
because her quick is something unique to her deku is just a living wikipedia article
and he wouldn't know if hakagure got in because they joined the same year
Hasn't Aizawa already said that the test is biased . Even then they're are multiple hero schools that probably have different types of test
That means that deku is reckless if allmight wasn't there he would've died
pretty much all the villians he's fought were defeat by "punching harder"
You keep mentioning Deku's knowledge of villians but you're ignoring some things
What if it's a villian deku has never seen before? his knowledge would be useless
Deku could honestly make a website that details thing about villians and it would be extremely useful to every one not just him
Yeah deku knows a lot about villians but just because something is good on paper doesn't mean it's good in execution
Honestly you're kind of over hyping deku when it comes to him being a hero with out a quirk
A story about a powerless person in a superhero world that just upkeeps an independent public website on powers sounds really cool. I’d read it, could go into a sorta journalist “dug too deep” into powered government agents or something...
Also, reminds me of a minor plot point in Worm where one of the protagonists mentioned that they edited their own Wikipedia article to be more misleading about their powers.
Now that I think about a story about that would be nice to read
What's worm I've never seen it before so can you tell me what's it about
It's an online web serial novel. It can be found here. Its main strength is creative powers, and creative uses of those powers, as well as interesting worldbuilding. Here's a WWW post explaining why people ought to read it.
Mineta is a shrimp, but smart. He can do it. It's a guarantee that without strength powers, you're going to run into someone who can out-punch you, no matter how hard you train. It's not a guarantee that you'll run into someone who knows more about hero-ing or Quirks if you obsessively study.
I wasn't actually talking about the test there, but their ability to operate as a hero. None of them are particularly fit, implying that you don't need to be to be a hero if you have other advantages. Deku did not know about the robot test, so it can't be factored into his decision not to train.
Again, I'm not talking about the test, here, but the ability to be a hero at all. Muscles are a helpful tool, but ultimately not necessary.
That's beyond the scope of this post. You're not wrong, but the point of this post is that assuming that A) he wants to be a hero and B) he's going to try, that C) physical fitness alone would not be the determining factor.
Sure, but that's a tradeoff. It's not like he's a couch potato. He's reasonably athletic, even during the Sludge Villain fight. I mean, shit, he holds on to All Might when he jumps over half the town. Training more would interfere with his study time, which I'm arguing is more important than further fitness.
I was using her as an example, since the only upper-years we know now are literally the top 3 students in school. There are almost certainly other students with shitty, Hagakure/Ojiro-tier powers that Izuku would have been aware of.
Yes, the test ought to be more freeform with less emphasis on physically trashing things, which would give our hypothetical powerless but knowledgeable Izuku more of a shot. This is an acknowledged, in-universe point supporting me.
Sure, but he can still do it, while others can't. If Power Loader or Mount Lady could have, then they could have stopped things right away.
He's got the world's best hammer. Plus, he's had to rework his entire way of using his Quirk, based on his analysis of other heroes' Quirks. Everything involving either Shoot Style or his finger snaps is a win for his studying, not his fitness. Even then, there are things like his awareness and response when he comes to rescue Iida during the Stain fight, or his strategy during the Villain Invasion, or his rescue of Bakugo based on his analysis of the Quirks, personalities, and positioning of everyone involved.
He's applied his research about Quirks to similar ones before.
They'd have to study all his notes, which would take just as much time and dedication as he put into making them in the first place. It would also involve more time to keep them updated.
I don't think he'd be particularly effective as a Quirkless hero. I just don't think fitness has much to do with it. That's the point. He's preparing to be a hero in a specific, tangible way. It's just not exercise.
Even if you know how a quirk work doesn't mean you'll be able to defeat and even then with the use of intellenge based quirks (nezu)
something you never mentioned is how any of his knowledge would work in actually saving some one or in combat
I misunderstood what you meant there sorry
Yes they have quirks to make up for the lack of strength deku doesn't him make a website that list the info
I'm not even saying he should've train for the robot test but in general
eri held onto deku when he fought over hall in retrospect that isn't impressive
to be fair you mentioned people such a mineta getting in so I assumed you were talking about the test in some regards
and I already said that muscles aren't the end all be all
I never said the test was good I just gave a reason why those characters made it into the program
even with a better test he still wouldn't get in because they test would have to be 50% knowledge and 50% actually doing hero work
To be fair I doubt either have anything that could stop the sludge guy power loader isn't strong enough to do what allmight did and I don't know what mt lady would do
yes he can dive recklessly into the situation and would've gotten him self killed none of that villian knowledge helped him then
something you never mentioned is how deku would actually do if he was facing a villian it doesn't matter how much you know if you can't actually apply it in a real life scenario ex:the sludge man who would've killed him
With shoot style or figure snaps that really isn't something you need to be big brain to figure out
That really isn't a good reason
If he made a databass about villians that would be extremely useful heros and civillians could use to easily identify villians and send the proper hero for the job if he's trying to help people this would be a great way
hell he could send it to a pro hero agency
I guess it depends how you view quirks in relation to fitness because depending fitness would be really good even someone like aizawa wouldn't be as effective if he wasn't fit
What type of hero are you referring too in this case?
When people talk about deku training they're referring to him training his body
Except that it did, in the Sludge villain episode. Plus the tournament, especially the human horse thing with the headbands. And the Bakugo rescue. I explained a bunch of examples where it helped.
I'm not sure if I'm understanding what you mean here, but there are plenty of times when the heroes either stand down or request other heroes with more suitable Quirks.
Eri can reverse harm to herself and Deku, and also Deku was intentionally trying to keep her safe, and wasn't leaping literally across the city. All Might didn't know Deku was there, and they jumped thousands of feet into the air, hard enough that the g-force made him pass out.
I meant the program. We know how Mineta passed the test, but he also got Aizawa's explicit seal of approval with his physical tests. And I know you said muscles aren't the be-all-end-all, but that is the main point of my post, so...
And he can do the hero work, at least when it isn't about punching robots. Evacuating victims is the main portion of the Provisional License Exam, after all. Bakugo and Todoroki's makeup exam is just... entertaining kids.
How about grab Bakugo and turn huge. She's mostly immune to damage as a giant. Power Loader could have attempted to scrape the Sludge villain off Bakugo, or at least focused his rampage.
But he can apply it. He jukes Bakugo during the first exam. He picks up on Gran Torino's movement right away, too, and he's not familiar with him at all.
Sure, he'd need some kind of device to be at all battle capable... but so do Jiro and Aoyama. Even No. 13 does, and he/she is a pro.
It does when you need to pick up on and replicate Gran Torino's movement withina week or he'll stop teaching you. Also you have no instruction and your power snaps your limbs if you use it wrong. Also, using finger flicks to create ranged air pressure? Not exactly elementary. Even All Might needs punches to do that, and Deku can't use punches.
It seems obvious to us, but only because it worked.
Already exists.
Some Quirks require physical training to be combat effective, like Mirio. Some Quirks don't require training to be effective, but require training to take proper advantage of, like Aizawa. Some Quirks require physical training to be able to handle at all, like All Might and Aoyama. Some Quirks don't need physical training at all, like Koda and Mineta.
But others just don't really apply to combat or only do so as a secondary use, like Nedzu, Shoji, or Nighteye (Nighteye can use his in combat, but intentionally chooses only to use it for information gathering). Deku could be one of them.
Deku would've died if it wasn't for allmight and the tournaments isn't what I meant by a real word scenario
And with the Bakugo rescue I was more reffering to deku being by himself
I will admit that , that was phrased wrong my statement was under the assumption that the hero curently there didn't no who the villian like it was a random encounter
and when that happens isn't that because they already have info on them I don't how their info stacks up to deku
I imagine a lot of people could do that in mha and with eri she's 7 as soon as he'd jump she'd fall off
I don't remember the phsyical test and I said in my first post I agree'd with your title I just felt something were off about it
The finger flick is very simple it's not complex at all
Then can't anyone just learn what ever deku know's about quirks but even then it's only limited to pro heroes anyway
That could be said about a lot of your examples because pretty much all require meet allmight , get quirk , and get more confidence
Deku with out all might would not be an effective hero due to occasional recklessness and his personality
Yeah but knowledge of quirks wouldn't have saved the people from the rubble unless we're talking about telling other students how to use their quirks then
That way they'd be able to save bakugo but they wouldn't stop the sludge man
With power loader I think knew that trying to scape it off wouldn't have helped anything
I imagine that if mount lady tried to grab bakugo from with inside the sludge man bakugo would just slip out of her grasp
Being able to handle and use them is what I meant by being fit for quirks
and yeah with koda they don't need to train physically (unless you mention voice training and minetas bleeding scalp)
Then deku would be a support hero? I guess that works