Seeking perspective on note-taking skills

I'm a high school teacher of 11th and 12 grade physics students. I have a PhD and several years' experience in higher ed (don't do adjuncting, kids); I therefore consider it part of my job to prepare these students for college.

Generally, I present some information and examples to the students on powerpoint slides, and then upload the slides for student access after the corresponding class. The idea behind this is that it incentivizes the students to take sufficient notes during class, and then only use the slides later as a reference if they need to check something. (Yes, I'm doing flipped-classroom and lots of interactivity; that's a different conversation.)

Due to the pandemic and the general changing of the times, students are increasingly asking that I upload the slides before the class, so that they can take notes directly onto the slides. It's also become apparent to me that in my existing approach, a student might say to themselves, "I don't have to take notes now because I'll have the slides later."

I'm seeking some perspective here from university professors at various schools and in various subjects. What note-taking skills do you want your students to have? What do you prioritize regarding the flow of information during synchronous class sessions?

EDIT: I should have thought to look for educational research on this sooner. I didn't expect to find a neatly packaged lit review with key points and citations to papers: https://www.cultofpedagogy.com/note-taking/.

Posted Sep 18, 2020, 2:31 PM UTC · edited

925
Narfjones•

Not a Professor but also a high school Physics teacher. I have also switched to a flipped classroom this year with the guidance of our Chemistry teachers who have been doing flipped for 6-7 years. The key that I have found is limiting the information the slides contain. Make sure that the only way some of the details can be written down is if they do it themselves. Also, make sure to mention to them that the slides are an outline and taking notes is necessary for understanding.

I also have personally started giving a small grade for notes. They get 5 points or so for uploading a picture or PDF of their notes for that section. I also make their quizzes and exams open note which encourages them to take good notes.

On a related but separate note I have found that only about 40% of my general classes and 20% of my applied classes know how to properly take notes. I have spent time on teaching them how to take good notes in the past but it was never very fruitful.

13
spatialwarpOP•

The key that I have found is limiting the information the slides contain.

I've certainly gotten much better at this than I used to be. The flip side of this is that my slides are mostly used, as they should be, for visual elements like graphs and diagrams. This actually increases the information contained on the slide, and I think it's why the students want to annotate on top of my slides.

Make sure that the only way some of the details can be written down is if they do it themselves.

Can you give me an example of doing this?

3
Narfjones•

I'll use your graphs as an example. When we cover distance time graphs, I will show the initial slides and then maybe an example one with some positive slope, some negative slope, and a 0 velocity and maybe even a section with acceleration. I won't label the sections on the graph but will describe them in the video. I have also taken to drawing them on in the video but I don't include my own annotations in the slides I provide the students later. I have been considering providing the slides ahead of time so that they could act as a kind of guided notes.

As for kids annotating over your slides, I think that would be great. I do it with my professors slides all the time.

2
spatialwarpOP•

Okay, withholding certain labels from visual elements. I can see that working. In general, the "annotation" approach is starting to grow on me, particularly because I can see how to scaffold the students up to higher levels of annotation analysis.

2
Narfjones•

I love annotating as I lecture. Having the graphs and images and stuff premade in slides makes it much easier for me and for the kids to understand because it's neat and clean instead of my handwriting on a chalkboard.

2
PastaIsMyCopilotProf, CC (US)•

limiting the information the slides contain

This. I provide ppt slides beforehand for students who want them. However, I have many slides with a single word, short phrase, or single diagram. The sample problems embedded in the ppt files give only the problem, no details of the solution.

3
mathemorpheus•

i'm a dinosaur, but (under normal circumstances) i lecture live in a classroom at a blackboard and don't give out any notes. i expect the students to take their own notes from the lecture.

7
gasstation-no-pumpsProf, Engineering, R1 (USA)•

Me too, except that I wrote the textbook they are using based on my lectures, so if they want the notes, they can read the book!

6
spatialwarpOP•

This is good to know, because I'm sure you're not alone. What subject do you teach?

2
abydosaurusAssociate Professor, Organismal Biology, SLAC (USA)•

Yep, this has been my standard for several years now. Plenty of research to suggest handing out notes has a negative effect on learning.

2
spatialwarpOP•

I went looking for some research myself, and I was surprised to find out this very comprehensive summary report: https://www.cultofpedagogy.com/note-taking/. It suggests that providing support and/or scaffolding for student notes is more effective than not doing so, but that giving the students complete notes is worse. Does this align with the research you saw?

2
abydosaurusAssociate Professor, Organismal Biology, SLAC (USA)•

Yes. The idea is that if you give them everything, they either a) do nothing or b) simply revert to reading and re-reading and re-reading and try to learn everything by rote memorization. If you have students that struggle with note-taking, giving them an outline or a list of terms or (this is what I do) blank diagrams or anything that is a kernel of adequate notes can help a ton. For my upper division courses, though, I give them nothing as they've learned how to process information and don't need it.

1
gasstation-no-pumpsProf, Engineering, R1 (USA)•

I'm probably an outlier here. I found note-taking in college pretty useless, and I don't expect it of my students. I do expect them to read the textbook, come to class, do all the homework, edit their (and their partner's) writing, and ask questions whenever they don't understand anything.

Disclaimer: I was a math major, and math is learned by solving problems, not watching other people solve them and taking notes.

7
emarcomd•

I used to upload my powerpoints and the semester I stopped doing that the class' average grade went through the roof.

Also - less text. The more text that's up there the more likely they are to take a screenshot of it then never look at it. It's the equivalent of taking a phone picture of the slides in the in-person classes

GOD BLESS YOU for trying to teach these kids note taking now. I literally have to tell students "you should be writing this down" before they even bring their notebooks out.

6
mrainey7•

I teach Analytical Chemistry, and I have students who are capable of memorizing dozens of slides and entire textbook chapters, but fail to connect the sections to each other.

I’ve started having them draw graphics for how the material is all related and writing little narratives explaining why the content is presented in the order that it is.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
spatialwarpOP•

I do agree with you in general that new info channels like powerpoints, videos, and LMSes have taken focus away from summarizing texts as a default learning mode. (A cynical voice in my head also blames the absurd price-gouging of textbooks.) I suspect that, as with all things in education, some instructors use these newer tools very well to encourage learning and critical thinking, and some do not.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
PersephoneIsNotHomeYou're going to need a lot of stickers•

I ask mine to do main topics of the book chapter every semester. About half really can't - they can't distinguish between main topics and important details, the miss out important things etc.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
PersephoneIsNotHomeYou're going to need a lot of stickers•

Really a lot of it has to do with not reading. What they read is badly composed, unvetted, poorly thought out, stream of consciousness stuff on the internet. In 144 character bits or diary-like blogs. They are not reading anything that is informational, substantive or has even been edited .

I am not judging what you do for entertainment and I like a good meme as much as the next person, but if what you read is by people who mistake weary for wary and is written in a second and replied to in a second, you have no template for thoughtful discourse and don't even know how to deal with content that has substance.

It is the cognitive equivalent of feeding people Doritos , ice cream and McDonalds because they like it better and then wondering why they won't eat salad and have metabolic problems after 17 years of that.

Parents bear a huge responsibility for this - you are the ones raising you kids. You can't believe the number of students I have that have been to exotic and cool vacation destinations but never to a museum, art gallery, library etc.

2
NyxPetalSpike•

I tutored general chem while getting my undergrad degree. There were only TWO students that had a clue how to use a text book without just stress reading the whole thing. I had students where 90% of the chapter was highlighted.

This was 20 years ago. Cluelessness has been going on for a long long time. When I was tutoring, power points weren't a thing.

My niece is taking college prep course in high school this year. Only one has a text book (Algebra II) and it's online. The rest , including biology have no books, real or virtual.

Can't show how to read a text book if the class doesn't use it.

1
raisorsssharp•

I may be an outlier. I don’t share my ppts at all. Access to that information is an incentive to come to class. However, my slides are bare bones. I tell my students repeatedly is not what’s on the slides that’s important, but what I say.

3
PersephoneIsNotHomeYou're going to need a lot of stickers•

I think it is harder to take notes in a zoom class - for one thing, I don't even really have the room, the sound isn't great and if they are on a laptop stuff can be small and other logistical things.

You can do guided notes - basically the PPP with key stuff missing.

When I taught school, I periodically stopped and said, what should your notes look like - it is a good review, and it is explicit.

I have to do that now in college because they don't know how to make bullet points or anticipate a structure (like I says there are 2 of these that are the same and different - don't write a book, write a chart).

2
galileosmiddlefingerProfessor, Psychology•

I do partial slides. I do think there's an argument for giving them notes, especially in information-dense lectures, so that they can listen and annotate rather than blindly write down everything and try to interpret later. Partial slides with some blanks and missing content are a reasonable compromise that lets them listen while still keeping them engaged with the lecture so that they don't miss any of the blanks.

1
spatialwarpOP•

Ironically, this sounds very similar to what many teachers in my school do, which has the local name of "guided notes". They'll provide a handout with sentences with blanks to fill in as the teacher covers the material. I had been dismissing this approach as too guided, too training-wheels -- something I needed to wean my students off of. But your way of doing it sounds like it could require the students to think and engage without spending ages doing rote copying.

1
galileosmiddlefingerProfessor, Psychology•

One difference is that guided notes sometimes use the placements of blanks to underscore the "important" (i.e., to be tested) material for students. I pop in blanks at random across the lecture with more concern for keeping them consistently engaged, but the blanks aren't special cues. This is something that I have to clarify in any course where I use this strategy because they do sometimes come out of HS thinking that they only have to study the fill-in-the-blank content.

3
spatialwarpOP•

That is an excellent technique, thanks!

1