Anybody using Vim without dedicated number keys?

I'm considering building a Kyria intended mostly for programming. I am not sure about the missing number keys though, as I use numbers a lot for vim movements. The Iris would be the alternative I would go for instead, but I love the layout of the Kyria.

Posted Sep 19, 2020, 12:23 PM UTC

822
Danilo_dk•

If you use numbers a lot, then I think numbers on the home row (like you would often see on 40% keyboards) is a good thing. I've not used Vim in a while now, but I have used 40% keyboards for longer than I have used Vim. It has never been an issue.

6
HugoProOP•

Does it not feel awkward typing numbers quickly followed by a letter? I get that numbers on the home row are awesome, but the concern I have is that something like that:

Press ModKey => tap homerow => release ModKey => tap homerow

would be weird. I have never used a small keyboard, so I have no idea though.

1
Danilo_dk•

I think I subconsciously slow down a bit when it comes to typing numbers. Or at least I don't think I have any issues typing numbers among regular alpha characters. But if it is an issue for you, you can always consider alternatives, such as using a one shot layer, or putting your numbers on the row above it or in a numpad configuration. The possibilities are vast with QMK.

3
HugoProOP•

Damn using a oneshot layer is a good idea. That's pretty much perfect, I haven't though about that. I think I will give the Kyria a try, thanks!

2
Jack-o-tall-tales•

I use a TT(number_layer) key and it's amazing. You can tap it to toggle fully to the number layer and type as many numbers as you want or hold it and only type numbers until you let go. It's great.

4
FunnelCakesPAB•

Does it feel awkward typing letters quickly followed by a letter?

Press shift, tap home row, release shift, tap home row.

It’s the same concept, and if you put your shift and layer keys on a thumb it’s even easier to get used to! You’ll be surprised how quickly your brain remembers when you use it to design a custom layout.

2
HugoProOP•

You're right, typing uppercase followed by lowercase is the same thing, so it should not be weird. And thumb buttons are the primary reason why I want a split keyboard, as I feel pain in my wrists. And the Kyria thumb keys and stagger look really comfortable

5
FunnelCakesPAB•

Awesome! I think you’re going to love a split board like the Kyria. I am always more comfortable and have better posture with splits. Bonus- put your pointing device between the halves to reduce shoulder strain.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
SiaBillionaire•

If you can wait a bit, there is a Kyria Plus in development which is a basically a Kyria with a number row (plus some other changes).

There is a channel for it on the splitkb Discord.

https://discord.gg/D7D7Vpg

5
jonas_h•

I was going to wait for the Kyria Plus, but I don't want a number row. Do you know if you can break it off or if there's a list of changes somewhere?

1
johnm•

Check out the pinned comments on the splitkb discord.

Short answer: if you don’t want a number row, stick with the regular kyria.

2
jonas_h•

Alright, thanks

1
Liebach•

Also, some features (like hotswap sockets) will be backported from the Kyria+ to the Kyria, but it’ll be about a year before that happens. So unless you want to wait a year at least, go for the Kyria now.

3
X_DIAS•

I've recently started using a corne for work, and i use vim bindings. Doesn't bother me a bit, and my main number input is a numpad style on the left side, on the same layer i have my nav keys hjkl. Is actually smoother than having to move my hand to the dedicated number keys.

3
autocorrelation•

I'm a fairly heavy vim user and using a 40% doesn't cause any issues for me. In fact, I always found the number row pretty error prone on a standard full-size because of the row offsets (one of the advantages of an ortho setup IMO is that it helps accuracy on the number row).

So with a bit of practice you should be okay. Layering isn't annoying for inputting one character -- mod-taps are fast and one-shots are low-strain. The annoying use case is switching between several layers one at a time, back-and-forth. The regex \d{5}(-\d{4})? isn't very fun if alphas, punctuation, and numbers are each on different layers. Layers aren't intrinsically slower though, they probably just take a bit of training before one's "mental speed" gets faster than one's "finger speed" of moving the hands around on a full-size. If you don't use symbols often, you also won't much training to speed up.

My main use for numbers is calculations and data entry, so I find it really handy to have a layer with the numpad on the right hand and operators on the left hand. This makes one-off numbers a bit more difficult than home row, but it takes advantage of ten-key skills built up over the years.

Something you may experiment with is having numbers accessible in different ways. There's no rule in the books that says that you have to only have a symbol in one place on a layout! You can, for example, have one layer with a numpad for one-handed data entry, but also another layer with numbers strung out on the home row for easy one-off input.

3
richardgoulter•

Firstly, considering code: a couple of lines from, say, hello world in C:

#include <stdio.h>
int main(int argc, char **argv) { ... }

Secondly, considering vim: in addition to every key on the keyboard, I know I at least use [] a bunch (especially with unimpaired mappings). ^0$ also would require a layer movement. *# too. etc.

My point is, your fingers will be dancing around the keyboard; even if you weren't making use of numbers for movement. (There'd be less 'dancing' with an Iris, though). I don't see numbers as a significant step over that.

​

On the other hand, if you feel you want a number row and are willing to wait, this comment from a couple of months ago cites a Discord comment about a kyria+.
https://www.reddit.com/r/ErgoMechKeyboards/comments/hijfoa/kyria_stagger_but_with_a_number_row/fwgjxrb/

2
thockinator•

I'm using a 40% for a while now and it's fine. Imho if you can get used to Vim controls then numbers on another layer should not be a big issue. Switching layers via thumb keys works very smoothly.

2
ILikeShorts88•

I'm a software developer who uses a 36 key keyboard with vim, qutebrowser, and a tiling window manager. It's perfect.

2
BoredomViceAndNeed•

Any chance you’re on OS X? I’m getting used to my new 40%, and would love to know if there’s a good expanded functionality tiling manager! Currently just using spectacle.

2
ILikeShorts88•

I'm not currently on macros, but I used to be. It got a full rewrite recently, but I used to use chunkwm. It is now called yabai. https://github.com/koekeishiya/yabai It is fantastic. Very well documented.

2
PBMagi•

Same. Wouldn't use a number row if I had one; much prefer numbers on a layer: don't have to move my hands.

1