r/singapore•
Xshadow1

The problem with the way we talk about Meritocracy

Discussion

In many Singaporean discussions, it seems like the word "meritocracy" is used as some kind of special weapon, a single word that you can use the swing a debate in your favour. Just say what the person you're arguing with is in favour of is "not in accordance with our meritocratic values" and you've won.

The problem with this is many people often adjust what they mean by "meritocratic" or "meritocracy" to fit whatever is currently being discussed. This often leads to people using the word in ways that have implications they're obviously unwilling to commit to. For example, if you say that places, whether in a school, a job or anything else, should be given to the most qualified candidate, regardless of any other factor like race, nationality, background, etc. in order to get the best person for the role, you're unleashing a whole set of new implications that you probably wouldn't commit to. A system that only takes into account "merit" as is defined by some measure of ability, is one that perpetuates a "rich get richer, poor get poorer" system. This kind of meritocracy, which aims to obtain the candidates with the most "merit", wouldn't agree with helping the disadvantaged, but rather would try to help the best get better. If you want the best candidates, after all, why waste resources bringing up those who start with a disadvantage, instead of putting said resources into maximising those who start with the biggest advantage? If you support this sort of "best candidate" meritocracy, but don't support this treatment of those with different starting points in life, why do you even support this form of meritocracy? You're supporting a system that puts maximising efficiency over ensuring equitable societal welfare, but yet not supporting the way to achieve the most efficient outcome.

Then there's the issue of "regardless of race, language or religion". Many people seem to want a society where these are not inhibiting factors for opportunity, yet at the same time want a society where opportunities are distributed with no regard to said factors. Unfortunately, that's not the society we live in. Not in Singapore, not in the current world we live in, not in any world we ever have lived on or any world we ever will live in. It's the classic tension between equality and equity, that is inherent to any unequal society, which is to say any society.

Do we want our meritocracy to be one that creates an equal outcome, or an equitable one? Whatever you think about it, I think it's extremely important we stick to a consistent idea of the kind of meritocracy we want. That's not to say we can't change our views, because we should, and we should do so often, but at any given time, we should try our best to think of meritocracy as more than some ill-defined term that we strive for, but rather a real, clear goal. If you can't commit fully behind the kind of meritocracy you're talking about, then when you're talking about meritocracy, you're talking about absolutely nothing.

Posted Sep 21, 2020, 12:44 PM UTC

6840
Loading comments…