The story is Mythic

SpoilerSpoilers Ep.7

I've been seeing a lot of speculation on what the voices are, or the ghost, in general trying to explain or expecting one for the supernatural stuff.

I think the story is being told like a myth of old. Epic prophecy and magical realism are just part of the package and it would detract from the story if there is some mundane explanation...

Just a though I had, wondering if others feel the same.

Posted Sep 22, 2020, 3:46 PM UTC · edited

79
zalexisLord Buckethead•

I've been listening to almost all Guzikowski's interviews that are RbW related and his storytelling absolutely comes from a mythological perspective as opposed to say scientific. Here and here are 2 of my past comments where I mentioned this in relation to Mother's character. But this approach extents to the story as a whole and the universe, I'm sure of it. I fear the people expecting hard SF explanations for things might end up disappointed.

5
MinimumEar•

If "because magic" turns out to be the actual explanation that will be disappointing primarily because I was expecting "harder" sci-fi... but i guess it's possible that's where things will go.

Realistically "because advanced technology" isn't necessarily that much better.

2
zalexisLord Buckethead•

I don't think that is all magic but I also don't think that some of the technology and science (or lack thereof) will stand the scrutiny of some of the ppl I've encountered on this sub lol

2
StragemqueOPAtheist•

Where do you draw the line? So much already presented is 'because magic', mother flying with seemingly with no propulsion, her deathray, her transformation to necromancer, the ships just being able to hover and so on.

This show is clearly not hard scifi, and uses a bunch of made-up jargon already, whatever the mirror surface is they tried to kill mother with for instance.

An explanation for the ghosts is just going to be totally arbitrary and kill the mystery.

2
Shrink-wrapped•

They're already leaning on the "sufficiently advanced technology looks like magic" theme.

The Alien universe never really tries to explain its technology (that black goo stuff, for example), and I don't expect they will here. At least I hope they don't.

Soft sci-fi with realistic characters and interesting plots trumps any half assed midichlorian nonsense. Sometimes it's better not to see behind the curtain.

2
cory120•

If magic exists in a universe, it is also "science". If it existed there would be some way to explain it, on a scientific level. Even if we were hundreds of years away of being capable to explain and understand the mechanics. I personally love fictional universes that meld hard scifi with supernatural themes in the same reality more than I like either pure scifi or pure fantasy. I kinda hope this show leans towards that, or at the very least handling in it in an open sort of way where you can read into it how you'd like.

2
MinimumEar•

This is somewhat pedantic, but if it's explainable based on science then, by definition, it's not 'magic' - which is literally defined in the dictionary using the word "supernatural" - above nature.

An all-powerful God, unconstrained by any physical laws, is an example of a "magical" being. Technology that looks magical, but remains constrained by physical laws - not magical.

1
StragemqueOPAtheist•

Thanks for confirming this, yeah I hope the show doesn't suffer because of this. I know hard scifi is all the rage now with the expanse but l think there is space for a lager variety, and we've not really had this type of mythic story before.

2
zalexisLord Buckethead•

Idk how much confirmed/debunked is there. I'm trying to stay away from these words since they can so easily trigger ppl lol. I will say that this is my perception of what I read/seen/heard. And I linked some sources so other ppl can form their own opinions.

And it doesn't have to be all one or the other. The people involved (Scott Free Productions/Guzikowski) surely must be aware of audience sensibilities and some research was done, technical advisers employ to see how much they can accommodate RL science. But my perception is that story wins. And Guzikowski's POV, who wrote the story, doesn't seem particularly preoccupied w/ the hard science of it all as much as w/ universal philosophical questions. And faith. He's definitely preoccupied w/ faith in general (NOT exclusively framed by a particular religion).

I wish more ppl were aware of this so they can adjust expectations accordingly. And be able to enjoy the story/show for what it is, not hate it for what it isn't. Clearly this is NOT The Expanse. I mean, he literally dropped the "indistinguishable from magic" quote when talking about Mother. The costumes are inspired by The Middle Ages and the necromancers by Medusa but ppl want the specs for her eyes :)

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1