Question from a layperson

From reading these posts, it seems like a "good" precision for a measurement is on the order of 2mm.

But when the guy holding the prism-on-a-stick doodad is just kind of holding it upright it seems like there would be a lot more than 2mm of imprecision in the horizontal axis just depending on how it's held. The base of the stick is sitting on some stake I think, so I understand how the vertical axis works.

Some photos I see in this reddit the stickty-stick is at all kinds of wacky angles. How is that reproducible?

Posted Sep 26, 2020, 2:34 PM UTC

18
LordHypnos•

Depends on the type of survey you're doing. For precise surveys, you wouldn't use a 360 prism on a pogo. You'd use a mini prism as close to the target as possible.

2
ubiq-9•

The layman's answer is that when I'm just sort of holding it upright (there is a bubble level on the staff, but it's finicky) and saying "she'll be right", we're usually not chasing millimetres. You'll see it with topographical or detail surveys, where you're trying to capture how the land generally rises and falls - but a good storm or a few animals walking over dirt could be enough to move the actual surface more than a few mm. Millimetre precision also takes ages and costs more.

TL;DR you're right, that wobbly stick is not millimetre-perfect

2
MannyNH•

Well it definitely affects precision. But you can do a horizontal offset where you aim at the point you want for angle and then shoot the prism for distance. Our instrument is setup to shoot two distances and then averages the two. So it helps cutting down on the imprecision. But human error is inevitable that’s why our precision standards are less than perfect. 😊

1
rackle_rackle•

*accuracy. The instrument is still measuring to the mm (same precision), but not measuring the right thing ;)

2
dbcspace•

The stick has a level bubble attached to it so in theory you can hold it perfectly plumb, meaning that horizontally, the top of the stick is precisely above its' point on whatever feature is being located.

'Located' is the term used when you take an observation in order to assign a coordinate and elevation so it can be shown on a map.

There are currently some GPS units that, when leaned out of plumb, can account for that lean and still assign a valid coordinate / elevation to the feature being located.

1
Arkelodis•

There are 3 vectors to account for.

Height is screwed up if you change the height of your pole or incorrectly enter the numbers. This ussually is not a problem.

Left and right or angle. From the total station perspective the pole target or pogo could be out a bit to the left or right. Ideally you would sight the bottom tip of the pogo and lock in your horizontal adjustment or angle of the shot. Now that should be ok regardless of the pole angle.

In and out or distance. He is where the rodman must pay attention. He needs to keep the pole perfectly plumb while the instrument is reading the distance. To check that he is plumb it is best to take a few reading to see that they are consistent.

(Now of course there are poles that know what angle or orientation they are at regardless of plumbness, but these are mostly for GPS I believe. I have not yet tried one.)

1
Martin_au•

A good accuracy is what is suitable for the project requirements and task at hand. For GIS/asset surveys that may be 50mm. For topo/detail it may range from 2mm to 50mm, often in the same job. For construction set out it may range from 1 to 50mm often in the same project. I’ve done jobs where were were targeting sub 0.1mm, and others where sub 1m is fine. Chasing an arbitrary accuracy for all data is pointless and expensive.

There’s several reasons why the rod person may be holding the prism pole off vertical. A photo of it happening is not a cause for concern, and anyone who can’t achieve the accuracies required doesn’t usually last for long in the industry.

1
conniekat8•

Precision is related to what you are doing. Sometimes all that is needed is a tenth of a foot, or two, sometimes you need 0.01 feet. There is a variety of instrumentation and techniques of using it that will allow a field surveyor to achieve required precision.

When you see a GPS antenna on a stick, people are usually doing RTK (Real Time Kinematic) surveying method, and when you use it with a precise level bubble on the rod you can get to about a tenth of a foot (good for grading and dirt topos).

As others pointed out, newer equipment has internal gyroscopes and magnetic sensors so based on the lean angle and the rod height, it can calculate local antenna eccentricity and direction relative to the point you are shooting.

Different equipment also has different ratings for achievable precision...

If you really need something to 2mm or 0.01 feet, you are not going to use RTK GPS. You will either use static GPS (mounted on a tripod and leveled over a point) and instead of using 2-3 minute observations, you will use an hour or two, (this is called Static GPS). Another way to achieve higher precision is by using what is now considered conventional equipment. Meaning a high precision grade total station and tie into local monumentation or local control points - just depends on what you are doing.

In most day to day surveying, 0.01 foot (close to first or second order work) is not required very often, even in densely populated urban areas. It may be needed with steel construction (bridges and highrises) or if you are ever hired to create a control network for a public agency. (We just did one for a local municipality) and used a combination of conventional methods and static GPS.

Precision, accuracy and error theory is usually studied for couple semesters in school, and consideration for what is required in terms of precision and accuracy is a consideration on every project. In some states, licensed surveyors are required to indicate on their survey the precision used for each survey, and certain types of surveys have legal precision and accuracy requirements.

1