Baltimore Sun Editorial: Vote 'for' Question 1, constitutional amendment on state budget authority
baltimoresun.com/opinion/editorial/bs-ed-0928...Posted Sep 29, 2020, 2:34 PM UTC
Posted Sep 29, 2020, 2:34 PM UTC
This amendment removes the Governor's authority to formulate the budget - the Governor was given this power by Constitutional Amendment in 1915 because the process - which was formerly solely in the hands of the legislature was simply corrupt. While it is true the Maryland is the only State with this arrangement, claims of "transparency" are dubious at best. This hands all of the power in budgeting, with the exception of setting the overall amount, with the legislature (and in Maryland, that means PG, Montgomery, and Baltimore City hold all the cards). Whether this is necessary or not is up for debate - it is a reaction to Democrats pitching a fit over Hogan's priorities - it is a similar sentiment from the left that got Linda Lamone a lifetime appointment as the State Administrator of Elections. Be careful what you wish for.
I was about to write up my disagreements with what you said, but I think some people smarter than me put it better than I could.
I would recommend reading the entire article, but here's the relevant bit about the 1916 Amendment:
The governor’s extraordinary power was placed in the state constitution in 1916. That provision prevents the General Assembly from amending the governor’s operating budget to increase spending on any program beyond what the governor has proposed for the budget year.
The constitutional amendment came in response to deficits that were the result of poor budgetary practices. Back then, there was no unified state budget. Instead, separate appropriation acts for different activities were passed without rigorous accounting, eventually leading to the sum of appropriations exceeding the revenues available. Needless to say, this was an exceedingly embarrassing situation for political leaders of the time.
In this respect, Maryland was not unique. Around this time, academics and government reformers proposed that the remedy for similar problems across the country should be the “executive budget.” Some versions gave the executive ― whether mayor, county executive, governor, or president ― the responsibility for preparing a comprehensive budget, and cutting back agency requests when necessary. For more than a century, the benefits of this version of the executive budget have been substantial, particularly because of the contributions of civil servants with budgetary experience.
The stronger versions of the executive budget, in contrast, intentionally weakened the legislature. This approach was adopted by the state of Maryland, and also by the City of Baltimore (which is also considering this election a ballot provision that would restore some budgetary power to the City Council).
The theory of the stronger executive budget was simple: give one person power. It was thought that governors as managers could be above politics and more fairly and efficiently allocate resources than could result from the legislature’s deliberative process. If instead the government’s finances were mismanaged, the voters could hold the governor accountable by throwing the bum out in the next election.
This approach was a fundamental departure from the “checks and balances” basics of American government, in which it has been assumed that requiring negotiations between the executive and legislative branches will produce better public policy.
As we look to down the road to Washington, D.C., it is obvious that this expectation is not always met. But our disappointment there stems not from the constitutional arrangement but rather from the failure of the president and the Congress to do their jobs.
It is also important to note that Maryland’s budget system gives the legislature far greater power over the capital budget, which is financed through state borrowing. The capital budget process permits state legislators to add capital projects, subject to a total ceiling, which typically requires offsetting cuts to capital projects proposed by the governor. Additions by the General Assembly are subject to an item veto by the governor, which then can be overridden by a supermajority vote.
The proposed constitutional amendment would adopt much the same process for the operating budget.
...
In sum, the strong executive budget adopted over a century ago has outlived its usefulness. Rebalancing the executive and legislative powers of the operating budget will allow citizens and legislators to propose modifications to the governor’s budget, requiring the governor to engage with those proposals. It will allow more voices to be heard and make it more likely that the competition for the state’s limited budgetary resources will allocate funds where they are most needed. We encourage you to vote “for the constitutional amendment.”
Yes, it's the same tired arguments from the Sun. Vote for this amendment and Montgomery, Prince George's, and Baltimore City will continue to wag the proverbial dog. This is nothing more than a highly partisan political move and a reaction to the State having *gasp* two Republican governors in the past 20 years despite a 2-1 majority of D's in the general populace. It consolidates more power to a legislature that is already drunk on power and has shown zero restraint on taxation (hello Kirwan!!!). You can try and shine this turd to oblivion and back, it still stinks.
Bro that’s democracy. Majority rule.
Ah the joys of not having civics in school any more...
We are not a democracy - we are a Republic. Did you vote on the stimulus bills, etc? No? Your representative did? That's a Republic.
Majority rule. Yes, I get it. That majority is unchecked and this just makes it more unchecked.
You mean the people elected by the most populous counties are going to have more of a say in the budget process? That sounds like a more fair system to me. The people's branch should have more say. This isn't partisan and I don't think the authors of that piece I linked had partisan motivations; one is an academic and the other used to head the nonpartisan Department of Legislative Services.
No, actually, they won't. This does nothing to give constituents more say in the budget process. It adds zero transparency and just gives an already too powerful legislature even more power. The fact that Kirwan is still being discussed in the face of the pandemic caused downtown is all the evidence you need as to how out of touch liberals are in Annapolis. Thornton was supposed to be the end all and be all - it wasn't and now it's Kirwan and whatever comes after that. I hope the citizens from the three most populous counties enjoy paying their taxes because they are about to get a belly full them quickly.
Are there any sources for reasons not to vote yes? I’d like to see more information first
My local paper (The Capital) urged readers to vote no, but their reasons didn't really make sense to me. Their argument is that this is more partisan politics meant to give the Democrats more power, but it wouldn't really do that. This is more about the balance of power between the executive and legislative branches and would have more or less the same impact with a Democratic or Republican governor. This even used to have bipartisan support, it just didn't pass because legislative leadership liked using the current backroom process to keep legislators in line.
I remember reading a good article by some academics on Maryland Matters about this a week or so ago if you're interested in looking that up. I can't really think of any good arguments against passing this, to be honest.
Thanks, I’ll look that up when I have a chance
I wanted to read it again anyway, so here it is for you.
Nope, not giving Hogan a line item veto.
This specifically wouldn't take effect until the next governor's term. Also, if the spending is reasonable, the Dems would probably be able to override a veto. The point is to shine light on whatever that spending may be instead of letting the result of some backroom budget negotiation go unnoticed.
The governor would, in return, have the power of a line-item veto so that spending the executive saw as wasteful or unnecessary could advance only with a three-fifths override vote from the state legislature
We have that right now and Larry hogan isn't a lifetime governor.
Also this gives the legislature which technically should be more representative of the state a lot more flexibility in creating a budget.
nope. dont want the legislatures to add more spending
That's not what this would do, though. The legislature would only be able to reallocate money, not add to the budget. And the governor could line-item veto anything egregious to make the legislature publicly defend it. Literally every other state in the country has some version of this.
hogans veto has no power, it can be overridden by a vote, and has been.
as long as one party controls enough to override, its worthless.
still a big nope.
This specifically wouldn't take effect until the next governor takes office. There are also still conflicts between the executive and the legislature when they're both the same party. And you're still ignoring that the legislature will still be constrained by the spending limit set by the governor; they can't add money to the budget.
It's fine if you still oppose it, but the reasons you've given don't really make sense if you look at what the amendment actually does.
This may be one of the more important things on the ballot in Maryland considering there aren't many competitive races. This constitutional amendment would make Maryland's budgeting process more transparent and more in line with the rest of the country. Literally every other state legislature in the country has more ability to influence the budget than Maryland's. It's time for us to change.
I don't agree largely because it will just become vote trading for narrow interests of any sort of swing area of the state. If MD was CA or TX size it might make sense to do it that way but we aren't.
Further we occasionally get conservative governors and this allows that to make a difference. It would be virtually impossible in MD to get a legislature that is at all conservative, so this measure would make MD much more blue and less purple (not that it isn't very very very blue).
Personally I think you only get good governance when you have a competition of ideas, this will just lead to even firmer one party control of the state so you it isn't a positive thing.
Why would MD want to become more like the rest of the country anyway when we have a more wealthy and equal society than the rest of the country? Better schools on average than the rest of the country and so on... Nope we must be doing something right being a follower in this case is a bad idea.