I finally got to use all 3 hand planes yesterday
Finally got to flatten a workpiece using the 3 different types of hand planes yesterday: Jack, jointer and smoother. My god. First of all, I’m a mad man for trying to flatten without a jack/scrub this entire time. Second, there hasn’t been a better feeling in my woodworking then when I took my #4 to the properly flattened piece. The pure joy I experienced taking such a fine, full length shaving is indescribable
Posted Sep 30, 2020, 12:26 AM UTC
Ah that’s exactly what I’m wanting to try! Excellent. I’m excited by your excitement.
I’m someone who’s taken up the bevel up jack plane route aka get a few blades and expect it to do everything. I’m so curious to what that perfect #4 shaving feeling is like (or why I need that #4)
I've got a really crappy #4 that I got started with, and upgraded to a Vertias bevel up jack. So long as the blade you're using is sharp and doesn't have more than a whisper of camber on it you can get just as fine a shaving from a long plane as you can with a smaller one like a smoother. I use the jack now for everything, a blade with an aggressive camber for hogging off, a slight camber for trueing and a flat one for smoothing, and it does a pretty good job at all of that.
On longer boards I'd like to have a jointer to for sure. It's not needed on most of what I do, but on the occasional larger project I do wish I had a nice big dobber but I make do for now.
And somewhat unintuitively it's also the longer boards that make me wish I had a nice smoother. Sometimes the jack is too big to smooth slight hollows on large pieces that don't need to be dead flat. A smaller plane would get a nice finish without having to flatten the whole thing down.
But as for fine shavings, yeah. Any plane can get you something a fraction of a thou if it's well tuned, I should think.