r/spikes•
Camichael

[Standard] Lurrus Rogues aka 'Rogue Two'

Standard

Hi Spikes! This is my first post here and English is not my native language, but I will try to do my best.

​

Since Zendikar Rising came out, I started trying different brews of rogue decks. I thought they could be competitive and I love midrangey/flashy decks. Unfortunately Uro made trying to play a deck that needs the opponent to have cards in the graveyard impossible. Anyway, now that Uro is not hunting the nightmares of our favourite tribe players, finding the best build of Dimir rogues is not trivial, as you may choose different cards and different styles of the deck. After lots of tries, I think that the Lurrus version of the deck is the best one, so I would like to show you what I came out with and discuss it with you.

​

The first thing that you need to think when you put Lurrus in your companion slot is, what am I losing? Those are the main cards various rogue lists play that cost more than 2 manas:

​

[[Rankle, Master of Pranks]] and [[Nighthawk Scavanger]]

I put them togheter because I feel the same about them: the more I played rogues the more I felt that you can not afford to spend 3 or 4 manas on curve to play non flash creatures if you want to win games. In my version of the deck without Lurrus I cut Rankle after a couple of games and played less copies of Scavanger as the days passed (to be honest I still think Scavanger is a good card, but it's not the right meta for it).

​

[[Zareth San, the Trickster]]

Zareth is a really good card, someone would say he's the main reason to play rogues. I agree that if you are not playing Lurrus the only question about Zareth is how much of them you want to put in your deck, but while this merfolk legendary was absolutely needed to steal some wins when Uro was around, now you have plenty of ways of winning without him against all the current standard decks.

​

[[Brazen Borrower]]

This one actually hurts, Brazen Borrower is an amazing card and I would play all the copies I can in my rogue deck. I think this spiteful faerie is the main reason to not play Lurrus, but if you think Lurrus is the way you need to make some sacrifices.

​

Now that I told you what are the reason to not play Lurrus, let's talk about the reason to play it. Here's my list:

​

​

Companion
1 Lurrus of the Dream-Den (IKO) 226

Deck
4 Thieves' Guild Enforcer (M21) 125
4 Merfolk Windrobber (ZNR) 70
4 Soaring Thought-Thief (ZNR) 236
4 Frantic Inventory (M21) 50
1 Lofty Denial (M21) 56
2 Into the Story (ELD) 50
4 Drown in the Loch (ELD) 188
1 Call of the Death-Dweller (IKO) 78
4 Heartless Act (IKO) 91
2 Mystical Dispute (ELD) 58
1 Bloodchief's Thirst (ZNR) 94
2 Didn't Say Please (ELD) 42
1 Negate (RIX) 44
1 Hagra Mauling (ZNR) 106
4 Agadeem's Awakening (ZNR) 90
8 Island (ZNR) 269
3 Swamp (ZNR) 272
4 Temple of Deceit (THB) 245
4 Clearwater Pathway (ZNR) 260
2 Zagoth Triome (IKO) 259

Sideboard
3 Cling to Dust (THB) 87
2 Mystical Dispute (ELD) 58
2 Negate (RIX) 44
4 Duress (M19) 94
2 Feed the Swarm (ZNR) 102
1 Bloodchief's Thirst (ZNR) 94

​

So, the reason to play this deck is that you have lots of ways to win the game and usually it has interesting choices. The deck is low on creatures, but if you get a good aggro draw, while not needed to win games, you can run out any opponent in a moment. While this deck has an aggro plan, you are not too much dependent on it to need to play bad creatures in the deck. Did you draw them? Good. You don't have it? Start countering your opponent plan until you can do something better. The second way to win is a control plan in which you remove, counter and draw cards while your small creatures pressure with damage. This plan is also empowered by lots of ways to recur your threats that mean you can really play a long game. Last but not least: the mill plan. Milling is not the main objective of the deck, you usually just want it to enable your powerful payoff cards. This said, while rogues alone are usually not enough to win games by milling, the revive package of this deck allows to hit several Thieves' Guild Enforcer together on board during late game easily winning the game in a couple of turns

Let's see some of the cards choices.

​

The rogue core: [[Thieves' Guild Enforcer]], [[Soaring Thought-Thief]], [[Drown in the Loch]]

Nothing to say here, Drown in the Loch is so good in a meta where greedy decks are playing lots of creatures and the only thing you can't counter in control decks are flying sharks. Being able to play it effectively is the only reason because you may think of building a rogue deck. The two rogues are simply the best cards to enable it and threaten the opponent life total, nothing more to say.

​

[[Merfolk Windrobber]]

I was really not sure about this one, but I was so wrong. You may think that you want it in the deck because you are low on creatures, but this guy does so much things. Early mill to enable your payoffs? Check. Block and Draw? Check. 1 mana 3/1 flier when you hit you're aggro draw or to finish the game? Check. Late game infinite draws if they can't remove Lurrus? Check. Also milling them to death while doing it? Check. My winrate became so much better when I understood you don't cut the windrobber after game 1 (or at least, not more than one or two copies).

​

The removals [[Heartless Act]] vs [[Bloodchief's Thirst]]

To begin, you really want some removals in this deck, Drown in the Loch really invites you to play some sort of counter/removal game. Heartless Act being instant speed (you really want to keep mana open on your turn as much as you can) and better arguably against any deck that is not mono green puts it to me over Thirst, that is still good against [[Lotus Cobra]] and aggressive decks. [[Hagra Mauling]] is a 1x because while it's a very good card, you don't want lots of tapped lands and usually prefer to not spend 4 mana on a removal.

​

The counterspells:

Ok, here start the complicate choices. You want some more countespells, but finding the right split is a problem. I'm pretty sure you want some mainboard [[Mystical Dispute]] in this meta, I found myself boarding them in against lots of the best decks and sometimes they are just crucial, you may argue on the number of copies. One [[Negate]] and one [[Lofty Denial]] feel like the correct number, they may end being cut in game two against some decks and you don't want lots of denials against ramp decks if they get out of hand, but even Negate feels actually playable in every matchup right now. [[Didn't Say Please]] is probably the most controversial choice, the first iteration of the deck had [[Neutralize]] in this spot, but after some games I felt that I needed a little more of mill to activate my payoff cards on bad draws. Tried it and never came back.

​

The card draw:

The worse part of my first rogue brews was that while they could destroy an opponent really fast, they tended to run out of gas really quick. In addition to this, this iteration of the deck really, really, really can grind out any kind of opponent and against most of the meta decks you want to hit 7-8 lands on curve. I'm pretty sure about my choice of [[Frantic Inventory]], it's never a bad card in a deck that likes to stay open until the opponent's end step and can play long games: that's exactly what this deck likes to do. [[Into the Story]] is also working really fine, I am actually not sure that 2 is the correct number, you may want 3 of them (but feels really greedy with Frantic Inventory in the deck). As I said you really like to have lots of mana and you will end cycling [[Zagoth Triome]] a lot, I'm still unsure on the correct number of them, you also don't like in the same way playing tap lands before turn 3 and we already have temples.

​

The revive package:

This is the reason I built this deck the way I did. Lurrus is a good card and lots of games with this deck become a counterspell war where you can get this good boy for free and get the value. If it gets countered don't worry, your [[Agadeem's Awakening]] now became so much bettter with Lurrus in the graveyard and there's more! Your broken land allows you to win also by milling the opponent as you can now replay your milling guys all together. Sure, you need lots of mana to play it, but this deck is really good at hitting the land drops. I have to admit [[Call of the Death-Dweller]] is a little bit reduntant, it plays well but if you are looking for a card to cut from the deck it's probably this one.

​

The sideboard:

[[Cling to Dust]]: graveyard hate, removes annoying escape cards, cheap card draw if needed. 3 is a lot of copies, but you will need them if your opponent is playing Cling to Dust or Kroxa

[[Duress]]: good against control, best way to snipe [[Lucky Clover]] on the draw

[[Feed the Swarm]]: in case a [[Felidar Retreat]] resolves, also decent against mono green

​

Hope you enjoyed my way too long post. I will not talk about specific matchups because I have already written too much, but feel free to ask about them.

Edit: grammar. Edit2: modified the list as suggested by u/maniacal_cackle to make it importable on MTGA

Posted Oct 3, 2020, 11:14 PM UTC · edited

3870
expatbayern•

If you feel like rogues can't afford to take a turn off to play Nighthawk at sorcery speed (I mostly agree), how do you take two turns off to play Lurrus?

38
CamichaelOP•

In the matchups you want Lurrus I feel that the 3 mana cost to put it in your hand is not actually a problem, as I said I often found myself in counterspell wars and 3 mana draw a card that can't be countered does not feel that bad of you can keep some mana up. Lurrus is also a recurrent threat and I can't explain how much value you get from doing it with a land and differently from the vampire you don't want it on curve and can generate value even if it gets removed.

4
ChunkyMoose•

dont play it as a companion

3
TheZardoz•

I’ve found main decking lurrus tends to work out way better than using him as a companion. Sure it’s a few slots in your deck but the value ultimately always seems to pan out.

3
Kaziel0•

This has the added benefit of allowing you to have some of the higher CMC Rogues that are worth including. Maybe you're not going to run 4/4 for the full compliment, but running 1 or 2 of the Nighthawks and Zerath San is probably worth it.

1
ToxicCommodore•

well damn its a good sideboard for best of 3. which rogues is currently not the best at lol.

1
Revenus•

Nighthawk is too good to take out, and rankle closes out games. Not sure how Lurrus really helps you vs the big boys TBH.

16
MrAbeFroman•

Without rankle, nighthawk and zareth, the deck isn’t competitive tbh.

7
CamichaelOP•

I suggest you to give it I try, I actually played the deck with those cards and think this version is more competitive. This one plays in a very different way, it's more like a mono blue deck playstile with more removal and a late game plan.

1
picabo123•

yeah this deck has an insane amount of grind to it I can only see a good aggro draw beating it easily otherwise its a pretty skillful match.

2
CamichaelOP•

Yeah I took some time to find the best play style, it has really interesting choices. Have you tried it?

2
AcesFullMoon64•

Strongly disagree. I’m not lighting the world on fire with my list, but I’m still refining it. Rogues is absolutely competitive without the 3 CMC and 4 CMC bombs.

1
[deleted]•

I was running lurrus before the season switch, but I also ran 4 ruin crabs and was using lurrus to revive thieves' guild enforcers, crabs, or otherwise trigger more mill.

5
CamichaelOP•

I tried the crabs before Windrobber, but the latter was really better at doing what I wanted, as I said this deck is good at killing but it's not the main plan. Actually I still think the best version of this deck may have crabs in it.

1
[deleted]•

I had 4 copies of windrobber, crab, thought thief and enforcer as the main creatures. It was good but I took lurrus out now so I can put zareth san in the deck. Cheating permanents onto the battlefield is too strong.

2
CamichaelOP•

Have you tried it after the ban? As I said I don't think Zareth is necessary to win game as much as it was when Uro was around.

1
itsjustsambro•

For me you're giving up too many good cards for a way to get value back later in lurrus, if anything I'd board him for the mirror maybe to get back some milled creatures. Nighthawk unanswered just wins and borrower is too good a utility to leave out

7
CamichaelOP•

On knighthawk you are right, but it's still a 3 mana card and you can't afford to tap out on turn 3 and let an Omnath or another big threat run out with the game. I still want a couple of them in a deck without Lurrus, but this version really embraces playing at flash speed. On borrower you may be right, but if you give a try to the deck you will see why I don't feel so bad giving them up.

1
itsjustsambro•

Yeah but you're not necessarily tapping out on turn 3 for it anyway, say you run 3 of them and you have other flash cards and instant speed interaction in hand, you're gonna want to hold up mana for a kill spell or counter and drop this guy on turn 5/6 if the game hasn't ended yet so you have counter backup or another guy to flash in

2
Nihil6•

Dropping Nighthawk on curve is ballsy as fuck in most cases.

1
AlmightyDun•

I hope you get some vindication knowing that Seth Manfield the pro player has registered Lurrus Rogues in the Grand Finals Standard event this weekend!

https://mtgazone.com/deck/dimir-rogues-by-seth-manfield-2020-season-grand-finals/

It's a good deck!

5
CamichaelOP•

I was looking at the hot takes in my old post after losing another game versus rogues and noticed that I really didn't see your comment. I guess the last 4 months really got me some vindication :)

1
AlmightyDun•

Yeah the hive mind often gets fixated on a specific thing and can't see the bigger picture!

Nice to be right once in a while though!!

2
5thClick•

The less Nighthawks I run into the better. For whatever little fair magic there is in standard right now, that card breaks parity like no other

4
mainnefukyall•

Yeah, I've learned to put respect on Nighthawk. Playing aggro in Standard I have lost games just bc of one single copy of Nighthawk brought back just once by Agadeems Awakening in more than one match.

3
CamichaelOP•

Depends on what you are playing. If you are aggro sure, but everything I see right now are Sultai, Omnath and Rogues that will only deal with the vampire and win the game because you are tapped out. It's still very good against Omnath, but I even like more counter their broken stuff and keep beating with the small guys.

2
realaccountant•

I agree that tapping out for scavenger or Rankle often leaves rogues too vulnerable! Do you think keeping borrower in while maybe playing 1 or 2 lurrus in the main deck would be a good compromise? I’m also surprised that cunning nightbonder doesn’t seem to appear in anyone’s 75 - an underappreciated aspect of the card is that she makes your flash spells uncounterable

3
CamichaelOP•

I'm not sure I would play Lurrus in the mainboard to have borrower, being able to hit it everytime you need it is just too good when you really want to be able to revive it, while you don't really want to draw a 3 mana card before turn 5 or 6.

On Nightbonder, I actually tried her some time ago and felt really unimpressed and actually, in this deck getting your 1/2 drops countered means you are getting ahead on mana while you will be able to get them back, not a big deal.

2
lucifey•

Yeah I think the concensus is nightbonder and slitherwisp were traps. They look good but rarely pan out. And rogues is already pretty low to the ground and actually doesn't even have many {1} flash mana costs outside of brazen or zareth.

1
Squeezymo•

Any way you could just add a few copies of Lurrus in your deck rather than keep him as a companion? With all the card draw you should still be able to hit him frequeny, then you could keep the good roguey boys like borrower and rankle?

3
CamichaelOP•

That's an option, but I'm not sure about both if I want to draw it when I don't need it and if I want to risk to not draw it when I need it. The companion slot feels like the right place to me, but for sure missing Borrower sucks, so I might be wrong.

1
Squeezymo•

Either way, I like your idea. I know when I play rogues and they are down to 1 card in hand, I don't feel too threatened if I'm holding removal and they don't have too many threats. Your card draw would basically be game over for me at that point.

2
Hebrews_Decks•

Looks more like a combo a deck that can mill someone out really quickly while maintaining tempo.

I’m into it.

3
CamichaelOP•

Yeah, that's one of the way it plays, but also the full control mode with some tempo is really a thing. The deck is feeling so good. I don't have much time to play because I'm studying for my master thesis, but today I started from 0 points on Plat 2 and finished 4 points Diamond 4 after a 9-1 streak. Yesterday I went from Gold 3 to Plat 2 with only 3 losses and while I was still adjusting main deck and sideboard, besides that from those games my sideboard plan has improved a lot. I am so proud that for one time one of my brews is going so well!

1
AcesFullMoon64•

Nice post. I’ve been running Lurrus Rogues with some success. The people that just knee jerk say Rogues are terrible without Scavenger or Zareth are incorrect.

I definitely got some ideas from your list. I would suggest trying to find a spot for some amount of Mind Carvers. It works really well speeding up your clock. And the one mana cost allows you to keep mana up for counters and removal.

3
CamichaelOP•

I really like mind carver, but it's difficult to find a spot for a couple of them and I think it's mainly good versus decks that we are already good against, while the problem is probably aggro and advebture (I mean, I'm winning every single game at the moment, but they feel the worst match-ups). Yeah, I'm pretty sure lots of the comments on the deck are just wrong, they don't consider this is a completely different deck.

1
mainnefukyall•

Imo theres not only not enough good 2 drops in Standard, except Maybe if you could go Grixis, but also very few playable 1 drops at all which makes justifying Lurrus rough.

If you want to play Lurrus Rogues I'd recommend Historic where you can do Grixis, Dimir, or wet Rakdos and get a lot more playable 1-2 drops. Rakdos gets you Robber, but it's hard to get UU to play Brazen Borrower in anything but Dimir.

2
CamichaelOP•

Maybe you are right that I want to play rogues, but not Lurrus rogues specifically, if I posted it on spikes it's because I think the deck is competitive. Yeah, you really miss good 2 drops in standard, but once you hit one for Agadeem you are fine. Anyway, when you hit Lurrus your plan is often milling the opponent, so not having too many good 2 drops is not a big drawback for the good boy.

2
mythril_07•

I think Lurrus rogues makes sense more in historic. I saw a list on twitter that had [[Curious Obsession]] , [[Oona's Blackguard]] and [[Faerie Vandal]].

Card draw plus an alternate way to pump the team. Pretty solid. Standard Lurrus Rogues needs more tools imo. But looking at the sets coming I think it gets there.

2
MTGCardFetcher•

Curious Obsession - (G) (SF) (txt)
Oona's Blackguard - (G) (SF) (txt)
Faerie Vandal - (G) (SF) (txt)
^^^[[cardname]] ^^^or ^^^[[cardname|SET]] ^^^to ^^^call

1
CamichaelOP•

That's a really good point, there are for sure 2-3 cards that I really want to substitute with a good 1/2 drop while there is no such a card in standard. This said, I think the deck plays well enough to still be worth considering.

1
T4p5y•

I played against a very similar looking Deck yesterday in Plantin Bo1 while playing a Rakdos deck. His deck felt so slow and very undangerous. I mean - sure it was just one game. But i saw your list and had the answer why. It looks just undangerous. I mean - i play 2 heartless acts, 2 scorching fires, 3 claims of the firstborn, 1 weaponize the monsters, 4 bonecrusher giants. So i had a lot of answers for his occasionally appearing threats. Just 12 creatures can be way too less in this Meta and your opponent sees your lurrus, so he will safe hold back one threat for it at least. And it dies to everything (bone crusher, shock, thundering rebuke, counterspells, eliminate, and so on). Maybe play 2 copys of lurrus in your main Deck and keep some of those big rogue guys like nighthawk and rankle.

Dont get me wrong. I like the idea of the deck a lot due to my love to companions and lurrus as a companion especially. But it looks more like a cuddle cat then a threat. :)

Edit: little addition

2
CamichaelOP•

Ok, I saw your edit and will answer to the addition. The thing that really scares me about your deck is dragonfire, but I'm pretty lucky I'm not seeing lots of them on the ladder at the moment. This said, the other removals do not scare me. I ame the control player in the matchup and if we are trading resources I will probably win. Don't get me wrong it's probably on of the worse matchup I can think about, but the deck is tuned to win against Omnath, Adventures and Dimir Control, I don't see enough Rakdos at the moment to play around them.

Edit: ok I'm stupid and scorching dragonfire is not in standard, guess why I don't see lots of them? Anyway I'm not sure what are you referring to with "scorching fire", Fire Prophecy maybe?

2
T4p5y•

[[scorching dragonfire]] is in Eldraine and m21, so its still legit, but yes, maybe not often played. But i like it alot due to it disruption of „whenever xxx dies“-effects and especially back in the Uro-Meta due to the graveyard disruption. Thats why i also play and like that [[Spikefield Hazard]] spell/land from Zendikar, but i guess its a nobrainer in this days.

To your core: im totally with you and think you are way more into it and maybe the reason for my impression really was the fact, that rakdos is kind bad matchup. And Bo1 also is not that precious about matchups. I just wanted to give you some insight from the other side and how it felt, to play against that deck. In my eyes the more aggressive versions of that U/B-rogues Idea just feel more dangerous about the whole game. In my game against the list, similar to yours I knew from the beginning, there wont come something over 2mana-creatures and after 3 turns i knew the idea, so i was pretty chill with the ongoing matchup because beside some removal, counter and some nasty „thiev guild enforcer flash-deathtouch“-blocks comes no real „oh sh@&“-moment. :)

2
MTGCardFetcher•

scorching dragonfire - (G) (SF) (txt)
Spikefield Hazard - (G) (SF) (txt)
^^^[[cardname]] ^^^or ^^^[[cardname|SET]] ^^^to ^^^call

1
CamichaelOP•

Ok, my bad about dragonfire. I really appreciate your insight, I will keep this in mind.

1
T4p5y•

I hope i could help a little bit. Looked around and just saw that [[Ghostly Pilferer]] fits into the Lurrus restrictions and isnt too bad for a sideboard against some Escape-heavy matchups and maybe also against those Omnath Matchups due to [[Escape to the Wilds]] and against Adventure-matchups aswell.

3
CamichaelOP•

You have a good point, the deck sometime is slow (while sometime you get really fast hands), but the more I played it the more I felt the need to cut bad creatures. Don't get me wrong, I would play 4 copies of a good 1/2 drop if there was such a creature in standard that fits the deck, but every other card I tested just wasn't good enough. By the way I also think this deck doesn't necessarily need to be fast to win games, especially after sideboard the deck has a really solid control plan and enough card draw to keep up with any deck.

1
maniacal_cackle•

Hopefully this will make it impotable on MTGA:

Companion
1 Lurrus of the Dream-Den (IKO) 226

Deck
4 Thieves' Guild Enforcer (M21) 125
4 Merfolk Windrobber (ZNR) 70
4 Soaring Thought-Thief (ZNR) 236
4 Frantic Inventory (M21) 50
1 Lofty Denial (M21) 56
2 Into the Story (ELD) 50
4 Drown in the Loch (ELD) 188
1 Call of the Death-Dweller (IKO) 78
4 Heartless Act (IKO) 91
2 Mystical Dispute (ELD) 58
1 Bloodchief's Thirst (ZNR) 94
2 Didn't Say Please (ELD) 42
1 Negate (RIX) 44
1 Hagra Mauling (ZNR) 106
4 Agadeem's Awakening (ZNR) 90
8 Island (ZNR) 269
3 Swamp (ZNR) 272
4 Temple of Deceit (THB) 245
4 Clearwater Pathway (ZNR) 260
2 Zagoth Triome (IKO) 259

Sideboard
3 Cling to Dust (THB) 87
2 Mystical Dispute (ELD) 58
2 Negate (RIX) 44
4 Duress (M19) 94
2 Feed the Swarm (ZNR) 102
1 Bloodchief's Thirst (ZNR) 94
2
CamichaelOP•

I had no idea it wasn't, I'll try to modify my post

1
maniacal_cackle•

The Arena to Reddit conversion formatting breaks the import.

To get it back to that, you have to put four spaces before each line (that's how you get it in that separate box like I have).

Deck looks sweet though!

2
CamichaelOP•

Thanks for it, had no idea of this. Deck is super sweet!

1
TheMerc_DeadPool•

I run ghostly pilferer in my lurrus rogues build

2
dcrobbins1•

Try a mire's grasp in the SB- good replay with Lurrus. I might try one Mind Carver main just to see how it goes. Erebos's Intervention could be worth a look for removal/kroxa exile.

1
thelordmuck•

The word that springs to mind looking at this list is "suboptimal."

-4
CamichaelOP•

As I said, I tried the "optimal" lists and I'm trying to discuss why, to me, this list is not that "suboptimal". I might be wrong for sure, but I bulit my idea playing the decks.

2