What is the opinion of feminists on the Patriarchal model of Domestic Violence?

As far as I know, the idea that domestic violence is an outgrowth of patriarchal subjugation is well regarded in feminist circles. The article below shows a number of issues with this model, and I would like see what feminist opinions and/or refutations of this criticism are.

http://pubpages.unh.edu/~mas2/V71-Straus_Thirty-Years-Denying-Evidence-PV_10.pdf

Posted Aug 1, 2011, 6:28 PM UTC

050
TAKEitTOrCIRCLEJERK•

Male-on-female domestic violence is the natural outgrowth of human sexual dimorphism. When one group of people holds a disproportionate amount of power over another group, a subset of the dominant population will exercise it.

Female-on-male domestic violence is the natural outgrowth of modern sociological and legal constructs. Men have been effectively told that their strength is not for hurting, so women are now more assured that they won't get annihilated if they instigate violence.

That's all super-concise, but it's probably 85% accurate.

1
girlwriteswhat•

I don't know. I'm pretty sure THIS image of marriage was a common source of ridicule for a long time. I remember seeing some newspaper cartoons from the 1800s portraying a wife beating her husband with a skillet.

Maybe we've never seen women as particularly violent because of our patriarchal assumptions that a man who lets a girl beat on him is not a real man and deserves what he gets, our patriarchal assumptions that men should be able to take care of themselves, and our patriarchal reluctance to see men as victims of anything?

Edit: what I mean to say is that we've got patriarchal assumptions that women's violence is a man's fault (what? Can't control your wife? Pussy), or harmless (because a man can take a licking and keep on ticking), or, well, funny.

4
NovemberTreesOP•

As far as I know even small group dynamics prevent extreme violence. I'm not sure that there's any evidence to support this theory except for some kind of a "biotruth" theory.

EDIT: That is to say, all of the research I've seen on domestic abuse suggests that single victim abuse is based on the victim not wanting to fight back. It's not a rational situation where two people think through the likely results of the introduction of violence to the situation, it's one person going "oh god I love them so why are they hitting me? what did I do wrong?".

3
girlwriteswhat•

The patriarchal terrorist paradigm is very much a form of gender essentialism.

2
girlwriteswhat•

I'm C&Ping something from another comment in another thread, responding to the assertion that feminism is about deconstructing gender norms:

I'm not arguing against a feminist strawman. Some arms of feminism have taken pains to demonize a lot of masculine traits that once had a very useful function (when the world was much harsher than now), such as aggression, dominance, sexual appetite, etc, and either downplay or laud these traits when they occur in women.

Look at domestic violence. VAWA is largely based on the "patriarchal terrorism" paradigm of DV, which theorizes that it is patriarchal social oppression of women on a microscale. The law has been written to reflect that paradigm. Primary aggressor policies target the "most intimidating party" (almost always the man), and mandatory arrest policies make sure someone gets arrested, because in the PT paradigm, there is one abuser (the man) and one victim (the woman). Men are explicitly excluded from VAWA's protections and benefits in over 60 passages. This results in an association of any domestic violence incident with "toxic masculinity". It's gender profiling, both of women and of men. Forcing them into roles of victim and abuser.

But since the early 1980s--more than a decade before VAWA was even enacted--there have been 282 empirical studies done that paint a very different picture of domestic violence. Some academic papers written by feminists themselves even cite these studies (using only half the data, however). These studies disconfirm the patriarchal terrorist paradigm in the vast majority of cases, and actually demonstrate that "matriarchal terrorism", though also rare, is actually more common than PT.

They also demonstrate that the vast majority of DV is reciprocal, with women hitting first roughly half the time, and that while women are slightly more likely to be injured because men are stronger, women even the playing field by biting, kicking, and throwing or hitting with objects, using knives, guns, etc. These studies found that reciprocal violence is often the result of things like substance abuse, poor conflict resolution skills, mental and personality disorders, poverty, feelings of not being listened to, etc. Not "Sleeping With the Enemy" by a long shot, and that of the few cases that ARE like "Sleeping With the Enemy", the abuser is more likely to be a woman than a man (quite possibly due to men having been taught to never hit girls no matter what from their earliest years).

Feminist academics are aware of this research. How could they not be, having cited some of these very studies in their own papers on patriarchal terrorism? They've resisted every effort to bring a more reality-based approach to both legislation and social policy. They have even gone so far as to behave in ways that I would characterize as suppressing data in the support of their theory. Less than a month ago, some feminists were testifying to the Senate Judiciary Committee, urging them to keep VAWA unchanged.

Why would they do this? Why, if their goal is to dismantle gender norms? Is it because feminists themselves can sometimes be the worst offenders when it comes to enforcing and reinforcing those norms--women as weak, oppressed, victimized, and never violent, while men are angry, aggressive and have a need to control women? Or is it because they held up their patriarchal terrorism paradigm as a support for their patriarchy theory, and can't stand to see it disproven?

Either way, their (not every feminist, mind you) efforts to suppress this data and obstruct measures to support and help male victims and their children...I can't imagine how many people have been damaged by this.

This is gender profiling. Gender profiling is a reinforcement of gender norms. The law itself is grossly unequal, both in its enforcement policies and in its allocations of protections and benefits. We already have a natural, lingering patriarchal view of men as being able to take care of and protect themselves. If feminists want to dismantle patriarchal gender norms, they should have been lined up two-deep at the door of the Judiciary Committee to demand VAWA be changed so that half of all victims of DV and their children are not left twisting in the wind. If they want to dismantle gender norms, they should have been shouting to the Committee that women can be violent, abusive assholes every bit as much as men can, and men can be pacifist victims every bit as much as women can, and demanding that the gendered language in VAWA that both targets men as abusers and abandons them as victims be changed. But they didn't.

2
OThomson•

So you are saying that male violence is natural, whereas Female violence is a social construct, misandry much?

0
TAKEitTOrCIRCLEJERK•

Regardless of gender, we all, at one time or another, have the desire to get violent. Unless you want to get your ass beat, you need both that desire AND the opportunity to be violent without extreme consequences.

Because men are bigger, they had that opportunity early and often, especially because DV wasn't even a real crime for, well, basically the whole history of humanity up until relatively recently.

These days, men face VERY STRONG legal and social consequences for violence against women, but women less so.

2
girlwriteswhat•

Men have always been taught to not hit women. Always. And men have always been taught to resist being seen as a victim.

You even see it now, in the responses of men and women on the DV surveys of reciprocal violence. The men downplay their own violence (showing they're ashamed of it). The women often overstate their violence compared to the man's description of it ("I hit that bastard 10 times!" "She only hit me three times.") Women are proud of the violence they inflict on men, and men are ashamed of both the violence they inflict, and that which is inflicted on them.

4
[deleted]•

Men have always been taught to not hit women. Always.

Lies. What do you think, Sean Connery skipped school?

Sounds like you did too. At least you must have missed the history classes. Thankfully today there is Google, which anyone can use to educate themselves. Could could start here for example.

-3
OThomson•

I completely agree, i just misred your tone as saying that for Men Violence is a natural impulse, whereas for Women violence is only used because of social pressure and not natural instinct.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

This

Women’s violence toward male partners certainly does exist, but it tends to be very different from that of men toward their female partners: It isfar less injurious and less likely to be motivated by attempts to dominate or terrorize their partners (see, for example, Kaufman Kantor & Jasinski, 1998).

1
NovemberTreesOP•

It's reasonable but poorly sourced and its 4:1 result is entirely conjecture. If it had some statistical evidence I'd be more interested.

5
TAKEitTOrCIRCLEJERK•

That article appears to argue against the patriarchal model.

2
[deleted]•

Maybe you've misunderstood the patriarchal model? Nobody ever suggested that women never use violence.

0
TAKEitTOrCIRCLEJERK•

No, I'm fully aware. Maybe you misunderstood or didn't read the full study.

2
[deleted]•

I have read it but it was months ago. What do you think contradicts the patriarchal model? The extract I provided here confirms it.

0