r/gamedev•
angrystuff

The number of Realms in world RvR, which is your preferred number and why?

So, I'm building a game that is heavily based on RvR. The two co-founders are constantly arguing on one point, how many realms should be involved in RvR: 2, 3, or more?

I personally like PlanetSide's style of 3 empires. The only disadvantage is that two sides can gang up on one, and that one might be the one of the minority realms, but being out numbered can happen in any RvR system so I tend not worry about it to much

My partner in crime however believes that 3 sides is confusing and almost always leads to one minority side getting farked. Again, looking at every open world PvP system that only has two sides, this almost always happens anyway. He also complains that 3 or more realms makes each realm smaller, and he wants "massive". I keep saying that a 3 way battle with 1500+ players on it is just as massive as a 2 way battle with 1500+ players on it.

Also, it's probably worth mentioning that the RvR side of the game is considered the something like an introductory part of the PvP experience - or at least something to do. There exists space outside of the core "Realms" where players can form their own sides and effectively have unlimited sides in PvP/RvR (we call it CvC (corporation)

So, what are your thoughts on RvR combat play?

  • Please note, I apologise in advance for any disjointed sentences, I have a (verified) flu).

Posted Aug 3, 2011, 8:02 PM UTC

77
KinglinkNetwork Programmer•

Anything bigger than 2.

3 sides tends to be a great target number. Yes two sides could team up against the third, but realize that's good. As long as the benefit from winning is good enough you have the possibility that team 1 might team up with team 3. or betray team 3 and team up with 2. It gets interesting.

If you go for 2, you fall into "good vs evil" paradigm, and instead of interesting realm vs realm you get stagnation. Look at WoW, I'm on a server and until they finally linked the PvP Servers, the alliance teams saw PVP as free xp/money/goods. Why? Because they had more talented people on there. The opposite is true on other servers. But let's say there's 30 percent of population that's a third realmwith a 45/35/20 split. Yes they might never win the crown of PvP but now the alliance would have to deal with both sides. The third race which might never win full glory now can help decide the battle in either teams favor. And depending on what the "win" condition is maybe the third realm might swipe it some time (DaoC did this well from what I heard. At least I think that was the first group with 3 realms on a RvR system)

6
thebudgie•

If you have 3 sides then you have more opportunities to achieve realm objectives while the other 2 sides are fighting. This is assuming that rewards can come from other than killing enemy players. DAoC had a pretty awesome system, though they did have to implement extra incentives to help out underpopulated realms eventually.

4
Eschatos•

If you don't have at least 8, you'll never achieve true complexity.

3
[deleted]•

My head hurts just thinking of the balance issues. Especially if classes for each side are all unique.

2
MasonOfWords•

3 is the correct number.

Guild Wars 2 has the best solution, I think. They have 3-realm RvRvR, and they reshuffle the realm groupings every few weeks. At the end of a period, a winner is declared, so there's a strong incentive to commit to a persistent goal. Really clever.

2
[deleted]•

3 or 5 : you always want odd numbers and dynamic relationships in competition. 3 is easier to manage than 5, but offers a bit less variety.

2, in general, is a stalemate waiting to happen. There's a fine line between "fair" and "boring". If games take more than a few minutes a la streetfighter, there's very little reason to have perfectly fair teams. As mentioned elsewhere, some people actually prefer to play as the smaller group, able to meddle without ever risking glory (since they didn't have a shot at it anyhow). Letting the battle sway to one side most of the time is great, as long as that favored side changes periodically.

1
jafarykos•

Did you ever play Dark Age of Camelot? They had 3 realms and dealt with imbalance by giving under populated realms more NPC guards. You could also give advantages to under populated realms such as teleporting closer to existing battles after death.

1