r/PhD•
qria

How to determine author order when both contributed equally

Humor
How to determine author order when both contributed equally

Posted Oct 13, 2020, 7:13 AM UTC

58418
wirrbeltier•

Haha, nice! Should have done that instead of flipping a coin.

54
Inareskai•

That's very fun. And I'd always get to be first Author if it was always based on HP knowledge.

26
Nerowulf•

Maybe next article they could switch?

11
Morrido•

No. The champion must stay at the top until defeated!

13
thecrazyhuman•

Defeat by death. And the challenger can choose his proxy

2
Morrido•

Oh, so that's how you get those papers with 50 authors...

1
bandrus5•

There was a gag paper written for a competition that ordered their authors by how disappointing the performance of each author's home country's world cup team was the previous year or something like that. I'll add a link if I can find it.

Edit: Found the paper.

8
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
Penguins_Penguins•

Omg this is phenomenal 😆😆😆😆

1
slowpokesardine•

Nope. The first author is still deemed to have contribute more.

-36
KingTemplar•

I mean maybe some people perceive it that way, but very clearly the authors themselves consider each other to have contributed equally.

26
roonilwazlib1919•

Depends on the field. In math the authorship is just alphabetical.

10
N1H1L•
3
slowpokesardine•

This paper should be referred to as Werner et al. in other manuscripts.

There is ambiguity over whether Milyavskaya could even list this paper in her/his CV as if s/he is the first author.

Why restrict this to two co-first-authors. Why not have 5?

In reality, no matter how accurately one tracks the contributions, it is never that 2 ppl can have contributed equally. Much of the contributions are subjective which are impossible to quantify.

I understand this isn't what most PhD students and advisors want to hear. Hence the downvotes.

-29
b29superfortress•

Unless they’re the only two authors, in which case it’s be “Werner and Milyavskaya, year)

18
slowpokesardine•

Yes. That nuance is accurate.

-20
ZachTheYek•

U must be fun at parties

12