r/exmuslim•
Ash09

Marduk, Aten, Yawheh then Allah

Monotheism, eventually, emerged in the ancient world as a political and intellectual necessity.

Marduk the ancient god of Babylon, -the epic of creation-, was raised above the great gods of the time, Anu and Enlil, to the one true god by the king Hammurabi during the early second millenium BCE, Hammurabi of course is famous for producing one of the earliest ancient legal codes in history.

Meanwhile in Egypt, there was another god that approached a universalistic monotheism state, more closer than Marduk in mesopotamia.

Aten, the Sun-disc god of egypt, was brought to dominance and total power over Ancient egypt during the 14th century BCE by the Pharaoh Akhenaten (Amenhotep IV).

one of the hymns that glorify Aten:

You set every man in his place,

You supply their needs,

Everyone has his food,

His lifetime is counted,

Their tongues differ in speech,

Their characters likewise,

Their skins are distinct,

source and another

Sounds familiar to Quran.com/30/22?

Sigmund Frued wrote in his book (Moses and Monotheism) that Moses was in Egypt during the god Aten's reign and maybe carried the idea of monotheism and a single powerful god to Canaan, where it eventually would launch the Judeo-Christian ideology and give birth to Yahweh.

Yet, Marduk is considered the most influential deity that led to monotheism in the ancient world. He (belief in him) helped defeat and obliterate the god of ancient israel so the Israelites would later respond by creating a monotheism of their own.

The political emergence of Allah, a product of the Monotheistic Evolution, that helped unify the small and fragmented polytheistic tribal states of Arabia, was inevitable. And after this, it would only be a matter of time and plagiarism.

The idea of Allah was just another step in a series of political, economic and ideological events that were sweeping the region at the time, gods are destined by our crippled psychology to emerge and/or whither away in time.

Posted Aug 6, 2011, 7:03 AM UTC

173
AgentLiquid•

Posts like these make my brain light up and is exactly why I love this subreddit, upvotes for you.

8
Big_BrainOn leave •

It's very interesting to read more of those groupings of coincidences (i.e. borrowing) in the texts.

You set every man in his place, You supply their needs; Everyone has his food, His lifetime is counted.

From the Quran:

"And there is no creature on earth but that upon Allah is its provision, and He knows its place of dwelling and place of storage {departure?}. All is in a clear register." - http://quran.com/11/6


Also from the Hymn:

Who creates people from sperm;

and from the Quran:

He created man from a sperm-drop; (http://quran.com/16/4)


Correct me if I am wrong but didn't the Israelites consider Yahweh to be their exclusive god and therefore that imply they believed in other deities for the Gentiles? And therefore the idea of monotheism resurged rather later on with the reformation of Christianity?

3
Ash09OPsince 2006•

yes you're right, the israelites were indeed polytheists, monotheism emerged, even before christianity, but it crystalized and took its current form with the reformation.

a good vid on the subject.

1