The video that convinced me to swap the 4XL for the 5

EDIT: link fixed

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ssVe1Me48hs (skip to 4:10 to see what I'm talking about)

I upgraded to the 4XL because (for me), the active multitasking on the 3XL was never good, but got significantly worse after the first major OS update.

Once again, a new version of Android, and now my 4XL (ymmv) kicks apps out of their active state way too aggressively. Yes, I've done a full factory reset, and the problem persists, even though I rarely had a similar issue under Android 10. Might this change with an update? I sure hope so... but I'm not so enamored with soli, active edge, or its battery life to wait and see.

I'm sure a lot of you are doing just fine with their 4XLs, but I'm not. Yesterday, I ran PoGo, Maps, and Google podcasts (playing in the background) simultaneously. And despite the podcast and map files being saved locally, the phone completely froze over and over again; unresponsive to the point of requiring a hard reset.

Despite the downgrade in processors, this is the kind of performance "upgrade" from the 5 that affects my uses more than anything. I was hesitant to consider switching out a one year old phone (again), but this pushes me over the edge.

My biggest concern is, what is Google doing under the hood of Android every year that borks my multitasking on a one year old phone?

Posted Oct 16, 2020, 6:21 PM UTC · edited

1822
I_WasJustinTimePixel 5 :pixel5black:•

Thanks for posting this. I was already convinced seeing that the 5 is a smaller phone, kept the 90hz display, and brought back the fingerprint reader. As cool as face unlock is, it's annoying having to rely on it when I wear a mask for work and when I'm out in public. This performance improvement is just icing on the cake for sure. Looking forward to receiving my 5 when Google Fi finally decides to ship it out

8
sufy12Pixel 4 XL :pixel4xlwhite:•

I love my 4 XL, i feel it's a downgrade to a pixel 5. The speakers and screen are awesome and face unlock.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
splendicOP•

I think for a lot of people the 4XL is the better phone. I wish I was one of them!

1
jtaran_06•

I like my 4XL as I patiently wait for my 5 to come. My biggest issue is battery life. I'm seeing reports 8 hours SOT and it's not even settled in yet. If I could get past 6 on my 4XL I'd keep it.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
Bc6P3o4u•

I completely understand your exp with the Pixel 4 XL. I had similar experiences with my Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge. When I got it in 2016, it was great, and I could multitask with no lag whatsoever. By 2018 (just within 2 years of getting the phone), the phone would lag, freeze up, and overheat when I used Google Maps, Snapchat, and basic SMS texting apps. I once took my S7 Edge on a plane since I had a job interview in New York, and by the time I landed, my S7 Edge was practically unusable. It would lag so much I couldn't even view my email or Google Maps to get directions for where I was supposed to go. The screen would freeze and the apps would shut down when I tried to open them. Not to mention the battery life was horrendous even with a battery case.

So in 2018 after that experience from my flight I bought a Pixel 3 XL which remains my primary driver today. 2 years later, it doesn't lag at all, doesn't freeze whatsoever, only warms up when I'm playing some intense game. The battery life is mediocre now with 5 hours SOT (although I believe the Pixel 4's battery life is probably worse), but still much better than 2 years with my S7 Edge. I don't regret my decision one bit.

I think part of the issues with your Pixel 4 XL may lie in the fact that it is a lemon, which isn't rare for most laptop/phone manufacturers, but is uncommon. Lots of the Pixel 4 XL users I've heard from don't experience lag/freezing and whatnot, but there still are several cases where Pixel 4 XL users do have lag, freezing, etc. like yourself. My suggestion when you get the Pixel 5 is to stress test the crap out of it and make sure it's fully functional the minute you get it. Stress test it for the first week to make sure it lasts at least 3 years. Test all its components to make sure they all work. That'll ensure its longevity.

3
splendicOP•

Great points, thanks for the thoughtful response.

I have to say, though, I never had a serious complaint with the 4XL (aside from battery) until after Android 11. I imagine Google will push an update to fix whatever's ailing my device because I've been reading about people with similar issues elsewhere. But considering I don't care so much about the other features that set the 4XL apart (radar array, active edge), I think the fact that the 5 seems to handle multitasking well, and has great battery life, I'm ready to "side grade."

But good point on really stress testing the next one.

1
xMrPopox•

my pixel 4 xl had also freezong issues after update to android 11. Wiped everything and flashed stock android 11 since then phone is like butter. No stutter no freeze it just works perfect. If you root your phone you can improve ram managment with costum kernels so that apps dont refresh.

1
calicub98Pixel 3 :pixel3black:•

Almost the same exact experience with a Galaxy S7, now on my Pixel 3. Have no intention of ever going back to Samsung after how laggy that phone got at 18 months.

1
nuupdog•

Thank you for this! I've been hitting my head against the wall for days trying to figure out which pixel I would get. I'll be getting the 5 and I currently have the 3 xl.

3
cdegallo•

App/management significantly regressed on the pixel 4/4a going from Android 10 to 11. I rarely had app refreshes from going between different apps on my 4 xl, and then after 11 is happening all the time.

3
Sw4y40Pixel 4 XL :pixel4xlwhite:•

2 years ago you upgraded to the 4xl? It only came out last year lol.

3
theoptimusdime•

This is the first thing I noticed on this post

1
splendicOP•

"MKBHD here, so I've been using this phone for a year..."

Yeah, weird brain fart. Was thinking about buying both the 3XL and 4XL in the last two years, and wrote it up wrong.

1
lower_90•

Hello, bad link...

1
splendicOP•

thanks. link is fixed now.

1
lower_90•

Link is bad, sorry if this posts twice something weird happened.

1
wazka2Pixel 5 :pixel5sage:•

Link is broken

1
splendicOP•

Thank you. It's fixed now.

1
veneno11•

Next year, you would want to swap it with Pixel 6 with 10 GB RAM because your Pixel 5 closes all apps. BTW, my Pixel 3 doesn't do as much reloads for apps that I use often like Reddit or Chrome. If you open an app only once or twice, chances are It takes the app off memory sooner, even though there's half of RAM is free.

1
splendicOP•

I don't mind simple redraws of the browser, or a text-based app so much, but the phone straight up freezing with 3 apps running (two onscreen + music offscreen) is bothering me the most.

1
deadlast28•

I am returning the 5, found it too small compared to the 4XL.

Also:
Didn't work with Android Auto on my Kenwood Head Unit (Deal Breaker).
Found top/bottom speaker balance terrible.

Given previous experience, who knows how long it would take Kenwood/Android Auto Team to fix the issue, (Constant connecting/disconnecting). Cable works fine with my 4XL.
Battery life was great in comparison, but not enough for me to give up everything else.

So i'll roll with the 4XL until the 6 where they hopefully have another XL :)

0
splendicOP•

Interesting. Is your 4xl running a Android 11?

1
deadlast28•

Yup, Android 11, Latest Security & Play System Updates. AA has been flawless on the 4 for ages (other than the occasional Google App screw-up)

2
Aktrejo301•

If you are wanting to have better ram management, then I would recommend you a custom kernel, like artemis or FSociety they are using a custom memory management that uses every bit of ram before it starts to kill apps and you see refreshes. The thing with google memory management is that they are using the same management facebook is using for their servers... Like it's not even for phones.... So yes you will keep seeing it as long as you stay in stock

-1
splendicOP•

So in your opinion, why does the newer phone manage to keep more apps active before killing them? Is it simply the extra 2GBs is enough to push past whatever bottleneck the 4XL is hitting (remembering on my device at least, there wasn't as bad of an issue before Android 11).

1
Aktrejo301•

Yea the extra 2gb is what is helping it have more apps in the background, but I can have almost the same with my p4xl and FSociety

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-2