Stillhart•

So I don't get the people promoting packing the court. I realize it's pretty much the only way to undo this ratfucking we're getting right now, but if/when the GOP regains power, they'll just do the same right?

We've already seen in the past that when the Dems try to play dirty like the GOP, it doesn't work out well in the long run; the GOP is just better at fighting dirty because they've done it for longer and they have no souls.

Unless the Dems can find a way to pack the courts AND prevent the GOP from doing the same when they get in power, I don't think it's a good idea to give them any good ideas... Can anyone explain how this would be a good long term play? What am I missing?

7
TheRealRockNRolla•

OP here. I just don't see a better option.

Barrett is going to be seated, there seems to be no doubt about that. So we're looking at a 6-3 Court with five hard-right conservative votes. Roberts is no longer the swing vote, so outcomes like NFIB v. Sebelius (the Obamacare case) or this Pennsylvania ballot-counting case, where Roberts prevents the farthest-right outcome evidently out of a desire to protect the Court's legitimacy, are no longer possible: the five more conservative justices can override him. He does have one small way to keep his hand on the steering wheel: if he is in the majority, he has the prerogative to assign himself the authorship of the Court's opinion and thus control the way precedent is phrased. But this only goes so far - if the other conservatives think he's not going far enough, they can refuse to join the opinion and write their own majority. (By the way, liberal justice Stephen Breyer is 82, ten years older than the oldest Republican justice.)

There have been conservative SCOTUSes before and the nation hasn't completely fallen apart, to be sure. Although a decent chunk of that is attributable to Republican nominees in the last 35 years or so turning out to be less ideological than the Republicans hoped (Souter, O'Connor, Kennedy), so it's not for lack of trying. But what the PA ballot case shows us is that there will be five votes for some truly insane outcomes, and I don't think people are prepared for how bad that could get.

For instance, Section 5 of the Voting Rights Act already was gutted by Shelby County v. Holder in 2013, but Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act is still in force. It is, arguably, even more important, because it allows plaintiffs to show impermissible discrimination by pointing to its effects, rather than proving politicians' intent, which is infinitely harder. Roberts has detested that particular benefit basically since he graduated law school. Section 2 is on the chopping block and, once gone, will permit states to enact radically restrictive voting policies tailored specifically to cripple pro-Democratic groups’ ability to vote. This alone could make the country’s election results look a whole lot redder.

Another thing that's been weighing on my mind is Baker v. Carr and its progeny, from the 1960s. Baker v. Carr held that the drawing of political districts is a justiciable question, i.e. something that the courts can validly decide as opposed to a political question that the legislature/executive have to work out for themselves. Reynolds v. Sims then decided a few years later that state legislature’s districts have to be roughly equal in population. Wesberry v. Sanders decided the same thing for federal congressional districts. While malicious redistricting is still a very viable way to artificially increase a party’s power – Wisconsin has basically become a one-party state due to the GOP’s ruthless exploitation of taking control of redistricting in the 2010 elections – these decisions provide a significant check on that process. These rules have been bedrock assumptions of how politics work for as long as anyone can remember, but there is nothing to stop a partisan Court from tossing them out. And then the door is open to any Republican-controlled legislature seizing control of redistricting to lock itself in power by concentrating huge numbers of Democratic voters in one district while dividing rural areas into many sparsely-populated, deep-red districts.

There is definitely a lot else a 6-3 SCOTUS can do to hurt the country, to be clear. I would expect prisoners' and criminal suspects' rights to be severely rolled back, restrictions on firearms invalidated, all kinds of religious exemptions to progressive laws/policies/regulations created, and so on. The modern regulatory regime created by Chevron could be dismantled, forcing Congress to shoulder the impossible task of crafting detailed regulatory policy for all the countless topics that agencies currently do.

But what really makes this scary is the power of a 6-3 Court to further rig the system in Republicans’ favor, and create a self-perpetuating cycle. Right now, Democrats can win the popular vote by as much as six points and still lose the Electoral College; models show they aren’t at 50-50 odds in the Electoral College until they have a popular vote lead of several points. Similar biases exist for the Senate, which will get radically worse naturally with time. So Democrats already have to significantly overperform in order to compete on an even basis with Republicans. A sufficiently partisan SCOTUS has immense power to put their thumb on the scale in Republicans’ favor even further – opening the door to massive voting restrictions, allowing GOP legislatures to lock themselves in power indefinitely, dismantling any remaining protections against dark money in politics – and in doing so, make it so that Democrats have to overperform by truly unattainable levels to have a shot at power. The inevitable result is the GOP becomes far more likely to win the presidency and Senate each cycle, and in doing so, keep the power to replace any justices who retire or die, ensuring the judicial pillar of this one-party regime stays in place. In such a scenario, and given that the conservative information bubble has become such that 40% of the country will never, ever, ever let reality stop them from voting Republican no matter what happens, I don’t believe it’s possible to create a blue wave big enough to take back the levers of government; and even if that happened, you would likely have two years to somehow unfuck this system – in the face of a militantly conservative Supreme Court free to strike down whatever it wants – before midterms lost you one of the houses of Congress and made further reform difficult or impossible.

That’s what I’m really afraid of: the self-perpetuating cycle. The erection of ever-higher seawalls against Democratic voters, so high that no possible blue wave can overtop it. Such a system could last generations before something causes it to peter out, or dissolve into civil war once enough people stop recognizing its legitimacy. It is absolutely critical that this process be prevented before it can get started, and that has to start with drowning out the five radical voices on the Supreme Court by adding more young, committed liberals. And that, in turn, requires taking the presidency and the Senate and ensuring that they will understand the stakes and act as radically as the situation requires.

Expanding the Court is radical and very dangerous, and could provoke an escalating cycle that makes the country ungovernable anyway; but if we do nothing, we are at the mercy of this 6-3 Court, which as I’ve described has the power to start the country moving towards one-party white nationalism. We have this one opportunity where the incumbent is so abysmally bad that we can actually take back all of Congress as well as the presidency, and thus have the power to start reforming the system. We cannot take the risk that we will keep the Senate in 2022. We cannot take the risk that we can keep the White House in 2024. We have a chance now and may never have one again. As dangerous as expanding the Court is, it has to be done and the next two years are the only time to do it.

14
PM_me_Henrika•

It's the prisoner's dilemma in a massive scale. When one party is known to always, always act in the self-interest and produce a worse outcome, the other party is forced to choose to act in the interest of everyone's interest and damn themselves for eternity, or act in their self-interest and damn the everyone for eternity.

It's not the one side that has to choose that needs to bear all the fault. It's the fault of the first party who declares that they will act against everyone's self-interests in the very first place.

If you have a better alternative to this...please speak up. I think that's the msising thing.

12
Stillhart•

Thank you, that does actually help me understand it a little better. I still have to think through the implications of it both ways, but this gives me a better framework for thinking about it.

I guess it feels a little like... well I used to be a "nice guy" and I got taken advantage of a lot. I finally realized at some point that I needed to take care of number one (i.e. me) sometimes or I'd ALWAYS get the short end of the stick. The world just didn't work like I was taught when I was a kid and I needed to adapt to how the world actually worked.

This feels a bit like that. The Dems can continue to be the "nice guy" and try to always be conciliatory and play by the rules even when the other guys aren't. Or they can realize that it's not working, it will NEVER work, and they should just start looking out for number 1.

6
PM_me_Henrika•

Thank you for your response. This inspired me to think back in history. What would have happened if the world continued to play "nice guy" even after 1939? How would the world today be like if nobody invaded and defeated Hitler?

3
dugganEE•

Nationally, the republican voter is aging. Unless something really big changes, the odds of a republican president will continue to go down every four years. Everybody sort of has this hope that if we can fix the court, gerrymandering, etc everything will just stay fixed.

But yeah, packing the court is a start. It's better than not packing the court.

5
ParableOfTheVase•

I've heard this before. Oh boy have I heard this before. Even back during the Clinton administraion (back in the 90s!) there were talks that Republicans as an institution was at its end.

It's erie how that discussion was exactly the same as it is now: older Republican voters are declining in population, young upcoming voters lean Democrat, urbanization promotes liberalization, minority communities are increasing in numbers which lean Democrat, etc, etc.

Anddddd... less than a decade later Republicans ended up controlling all three branches during the Bush administration.

The point is, never assume one side will gain and hold on to power forever, the pendullum always swings. Be careful when dismantalling checks and balances, as it always come back and bite us in the ass.

7
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
dugganEE•

TBF, both W Bush's first campaign and Trump's campaign did not win the popular vote. I think W enjoyed an extraordinary incumbency advantage, as the Iraq war was still popular and the wound of 9/11 still fresh. W lost by tens of thousands of votes. Trump lost by millions. I'm not saying that two datapoints make a trend, but the hypothesis that Republicans are dying faster than they're registering and that has election implications is supported by those data points. If that trend continues, eventually the existing anti-democratic mechanisms will not be sufficient for the GOP to have national power, which is why they're trying to install new anti-democratic mechanisms. Undoing those new mechanisms is the holding pattern strategy to win by default twenty years down the line.

1
CFCrispyBacon•

You can dilute the power of appointing a Justice until it no longer matters who appoints who. Double the size of the DC circuit to 22, and appoint every member to the Supreme Court (except Neomi Rao, whose appointment time slot can be her impeachment trial instead). Pass a law having them rule on cases by drawing 9 names out of a hat, or just have the entire thing be a giant en banc panel. You can have an abbreviated vetting process...because everyone on the DC circuit is ALREADY setting up to be a Supreme Court nominee. If the Republicans want to try to pack the Court at that point, they'll be spending YEARS to add enough seats to make a difference.

5
earthwormjimwow•

A requirement to have served X amount of years in the Federal Courts system is not a bad idea. That would have precluded a few liberal justices too, but I'd be fine with that. It is ridiculous that being a Judge is not a requirement for a nominee to the highest Judge position in the entire country.

3
TipppptoeOP•

Unfortunately I think it’s better than waiting 40 years for 3 justices to die. But not much better. It would be best if the two sides could agree on term limits as some part of a broader compromise. But while one side negotiates, the other engages in an all out war with no means off the table in waging it. Maybe once the Dems get a trifecta they will come to the table. We can only hope.

4

When sherman declared total war, the south remembered...and a 110 years later, still yearn for their slaves back.

And this is how they are doing it. By emulating china and russia.

2
Stillhart•

It just feels wrong to me to be all up in arms about how fucked all of this is and then to do it ourselves. I don't see a good solution either way though so yeah...

1
chefboyrdeee•

Pack the court, pass a law that limits total number of justices.

3
Stillhart•

That can backfire in a few different ways, IMO:

  1. The GOP can pass a law undoing that law when they get a majority again. Laws are easy to change like that.
  2. Even if you make a Constitutional amendment (much harder to change), what happens when we get back into this position again? Then we no longer have the ability to pack the court. It's just kicking the problem down the road.
5
BEEF_WIENERS•

I like the idea of amending the constitution so that Justices serve a single term of (number of justices times 2) years and they're all offset so that every single administration gets to appoint 2 justices. If there's 9 judges, 18 year term. If there's 11, 22 year term. Limit the justices to some specific number as well with that same amendment and make it so that the most senior justice serves as Chief Justice, which would normally be the last 2 years of their term.

When it comes time for the Justices to be replaced they do NOT need to be senate-confirmed, and if one should die in office or be otherwise unable to finish out their term then the President appoints a justice to finish out their term, whether they had 6 weeks or 6 years left.

6
DeadLikeYou•

They were the ones to start this ball a-rollin when they announced they wouldnt place garland, and now are trying to go back on that rule and place ANOTHER blatant conservative justice on the bench.

Fuck the democrats for going along with the ratfucking in the first place with garland, but fuck republicans for starting this mischief in the first place.

Just appealing to "no dont do this, we shouldnt" just means that conservatives will give their own bullshit justifications on how they will do it anyways, and worse.

1
chefboyrdeee•

I agree that it is a temp fix. Unfortunately, that's all I have at the moment, and am open to other ideas.

0
seddit_rucks•

Laws are easy to change like that.

Yes, but not as simple or easy as if the law didn't exist. For example, suppose you have a GOP Congress and a Dem President. GOP tries to overturn the cap on the SC's size, it's going to have to survive the veto.

Obviously such a law would be trivial to strike down in other circumstances. But it's at least a potential block on further packing the court.

0
earthwormjimwow•

The GOP in its current form is not electable to majority power if the playing field is fair. The hope, is that a court that has been packed by Democrats, and campaign finance reform like HR-1 will force the GOP to fundamentally change.

For example, aside from an incumbent advantage, the GOP has not had a President elected with the popular vote in a long tme. Several "red" states are gerrymandered to the point where Democrats need a 5+ point advantage to win an election.

If these reforms go through, we could be seeing decades of Democrat rule if the GOP doesn't morph, a repeat of the early 20th century. I do not like the idea of one party assuming control for significant periods of time, Chicago is a good example of what can happen if one political machine rules indefinitely, but I do hope that it will lead to a correction in the opposition party.

2
boethius_tcop•

Add dc and Puerto Rico as states - and if possible (probably much harder) - consolidate the dakotas. It’ll make it much harder for them to come back in power.

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
only_self_posts•

Apart from impeaching and then removing via 2/3 of the Senate, there’s no other option. The only impeachment was in 1805 and ended in acquittal.

Who knows, maybe the Democrats get to 67 in 2022, but that hasn’t happened since 65-67. They would need to get to at least 55 seats this cycle for it to be even laughably considered. Then in 2022, they would have to gain 12 seats in the reddest states without losing any.

0
GarbageTheClown•
0
Stillhart•

Thanks, I watched the whole video and I don't think that really answers my question. We're all in agreement that what's going on now is fucked. He's stating the painfully obvious.

My question is: does packing the courts really work in our favor if it just sets a precedent that the GOP can and will follow the second they get the opportunity to do so?

2
HenkieVV•

does packing the courts really work in our favor if it just sets a precedent that the GOP can and will follow the second they get the opportunity to do so?

Firstly, the worst has already happened: Conservatives have a 6-3 majority, with a clear pattern of partisan-hackery. So opening up the floodgates to Republican court-packing can't make it much worse than it already is.

Secondly, it takes a change to the law to pack the courts, so Conservatives will need to control the Presidency, the Senate, and the House before they can return the favour. So it's not something they can just do after a single succesful cycle.

Thirdly, it's not just about who controls the Supreme Court, but about their rulings. The constitutionality of the ACA is going to be fought over for a couple of years still. A packed court might save it. That's worth something, even if Conservatives do at some point get back control of the Supreme Court.

1
GarbageTheClown•

The point of the video is that the precedent has already been set, if the GOP decides to break the unenforced ethical rules, then the other side should do the same. If the Dem's don't pack the court, it's not reasonable to assume that the GOP won't given the opportunity.

It's a prisoners dilemma but one side has basically already committed to betray the other.

0
Telewyn•

Any law can be changed. Laws aren’t fundamental or empirical in any way.

Refusing to change broken systems is not the path to any future worth striving for.

0
obvom•

The last time the court was expanded was when there were 9 circuits, so nine judges. We have more circuits now. Without a partisan shit show, competent non-biased judges can be appointed. Clearly the GOP doesn't believe that helps them too much, which is their own fault; they can suffer the consequences when a truly non-partisan court decision regarding voting rights or labor laws comes down against their bullshit. We don't need the left-wing version of Scalia to defend against republican religious bullshit from the SCOTUS.

0