Starting a 529 for Nephews - Similar experiences?

Saving

Hi all - I have 4 nephews, ages ~4 - 12. Unfortunately, their parents are nearly poor and struggle just to get by much less save for education. In contrast, my wife and I are DINK and doing fairly well (maxed 401k, Roth IRA, HSA, plus saving on top of that).

I was looking into 529 plans, and liked Vanguard's NV-based one. However, min buy-in is $3k, or $12k for all of them.

Where I am struggling to make a decision is on if I allocate $12k for this. It would be a great thing to do for the kids, and I'd feel good about giving them a potential leg up in life when they've not had much of that so far. However, we are by no means in the clear financially with about $100k debt between mortgage and one car. I feel somewhat selfish, but $12k could also do us a lot of good financially (probably would dump into brokerage and left to grow for now). For the sake of argument, I have this cash in hand and can go either way.

Although any comments on the specifics of 529 plans are also welcome, I'm curious if anyone else here was in a similar situation and decided one way or another. If so, which way did you go and how do you feel now? Did you wish you chose differently when you had the chance? Thanks for reading.

Posted Oct 22, 2020, 11:16 PM UTC

818
Lots-o-gas-gas-gas​•

First of all, it’s great that you want to give a head-start for your nephews future education!

I opened my kid’s 529 and started putting in $$ when he was in grade school. Tapered off while in middle school as I noticed he was going through a TOUGH transition that lasted through graduation. We then started putting that $$ in index funds/regular stocks. My husband pointed out we had enough in the 529 to cover his freshman year in college and if he wanted to continue we could sell stocks as needed.

However, not every teen is ready for college. He tried his best during that Fall semester at a big SEC school and knew exactly what was best for him by Christmas break. I am very proud of him for speaking his mind and already had started investigating trade schools, which 529s also cover. My husband kind of saw the handwriting on the wall as our son was growing up, all I saw was "he has to go to college".

We already had a regular stock account and a Roth at Fidelity so instead of continuing to fund the 529, we threw our $$ into those knowing we could cash out as necessary.

7
ke151OP​•

Thanks for the response and insight!

Good reminder that trade school is covered too! My initial thought was at least for the first three, it can always be transferred to the next youngest if they are not planning on needing it.

We'll also consider just growing our brokerage accounts with intent if chipping in when the time comes rather than a formal 529 plan.

1
max10355​•

I’ve been looking at accounts for my niece and nephews and will probably choose my state’s plan because I can get a tax benefit and the minimum investment is very low. I haven’t looked into the benefits of using Vanguard but $3k a kid sounds like a lot. If you really want to use Vanguard but aren’t comfortable with the minimum investment, you could pick a different plan and rollover once you save up $3k. Keep in mind, though, if you use a state tax-advantaged account and then rollover into Vanguard you’d likely have to pay tax on your previous contributions.

4
ke151OP​•

Thanks for the heads up. I'm in Michigan and I believe the state plan has a VERY low minimum. So maybe that will be the way to compromise.

2
Jfortyone​•

I think the minimum in Michigan is only $25. They just changed all the investment options last year and the fees are lower. Plus you can deduct income tax as a Michigan resident. Seemed like a pretty easy decision for me to choose mesp

3
ke151OP​•

Thanks! Yeah $25 x 4 is easier to commit to!

1
notalazer​•

Michigan allows a state income tax deduction of up to $5000 per individual per year (Max $212.5 saved) or $10000 per couple (Max $425 saved). Investment options between many of the well designed 529 state plans are similar and the MESP is no exception. With the immediate discount, you should probably not look much further.

2
ke151OP​•

Thanks, will look at MESP as prime path

1
DudeWithOneNut​•

Hey there, just did this for my two young nieces. Big heads up: opening the 529 in your own name and then withdrawing from it and giving that money to your nephews will count against them on the FAFSA Wayyyy more than if the account is owned by the parent or the student themselves. If its a student or parental asset, financial aid can be reduced by ~6% of the amount withdrawn from the 529. If its not the parent or student, the money counts as untaxed income, and can reduce their financial aid granted by up to 50% f the amount withdrawn.

Don't work against yourself. Consider having your siblings (in law?) open a 529 in their children's name, and then contribute gifts to that account instead of opening your own.

3
Frenits​•

Wouldn’t you just be able to change beneficiaries from yourself to the niece & nephews as they need it / become of university age?

1
ke151OP​•

Thanks for the heads up. This is a good point since probably they'll be pretty eligible should they fill out FAFSA.

The challenge will be getting their parents to do it, for at least one of them even online banking is past their capabilities. But probably worth the effort since the end goal is to help the kids as much as possible.

1
squarecandylookround​•

529s are great because you can change beneficiaries in case they opt not to attend school. I used savingforcollege as a reference point to look at the each state's plans and benefits depending on whether you are in or out of state. Some states give a tax break while some don't care and have a combination of low fees and minimums. I personally love vanguard for most things but opted for NY and Utah's 529 programs since their fee structures and low buy in meant I didn't have to commit too much at a single go.

2
ke151OP​•

Thanks for the info, I should definitely research my state options more before doing anything.

1
WrapDangerous1861​•

I am doing this for 4 of my nieces and nephews, an amount per month per kid and setup auto payment, it's so easy. I used my state 529 for the tax benefits .

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
Topher_86​•

As long as your e-funds are adequate and your debts are low-interest and secured you should be fine investing in whatever you’d like.

The ROI on this might not be a direct financial gain for you; however, the ROI may be an extreme financial gain for your beneficiaries and their parents. The potential reduction of $12k+ high interest debt may be the highest returns possible for your funds overall.

One thing of note is that your nephews may not need the funds for school. If the EFC’s are pretty low for the parents your nephews may find adequate financing on their own OR if they choose to go into business for themselves a 529 might not be a great fit. 529’s can have benefits but also have limitations.

I have personally chosen to go with a taxable account for my god daughter so I can have the flexibility of what I can fund and when (if exit timing at college doesn’t really make sense)

2
ke151OP​•

Thanks, are you just "earmarking" some funds for later gift or trying to do a UGMA/UTMA type of thing?

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1