Vision: Cone or 360?

Answered

Hello, a brief question here.So far as the PHB goes I haven't seen any indication of a ruling on this.In terms of vision do you allow your PCs full 360 degree vision, or give them a cone in the way they are facing?

Edit: Video link with stamp time https://youtu.be/dvkvlmcM8og?t=392

Posted Oct 26, 2020, 5:14 PM UTC

210
FalseRhubarb•

360 - there are no rules about facing in this edition. The one exception is in darkness when using a bullseye lantern, which may brighten an area in a specific arc. Even then I generally just use 360 for simplicity.

7
AlbolynxModerator•

There is a Variant rule for Facing in the DMG which more or less implies that by default it's 360 vision.

2
elporcho•

unless you run your game on pause, the players can freely rotate, which means non-360 vision is just an inconvenience.

7
HikaruXavierGM•

As mentioned in the other posts, its 360 by default. If you wanted to run a more 'spooky' setting where vision is restricted, that is 100% your discretion.

Its easy enough to rotate tokens so the mechanics of it shouldn't be too much of a burden on the players.

2
AutoModeratorMOD•

You have posted a question about FoundryVTT. If you feel like your question is properly answered, please reply to any comment in this thread with the word Answered included in the text! (Or change the flair to Answered yourself)

If you do not receive a satisfactory answer, consider visiting the Foundry official discord server and asking there. Afterward, please come back and post the solution here for posterity!


I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
MacDork•

If you're trying to emulate what a player would see IRL, the only case where limiting their vision cone makes sense is in a situation where their character is somehow restricted from turning their head/body to look around.

1
mirtos•
  1. Rules on facing haven't existed since ad&d. Assume we're talking D&D. unless talking variant or houserules.
1
ba_Marsh_Wiggle•

360° vision is the default, but just for fun...if you were to use a cone of vision, how many degrees would you assign? 90? 180?

1
BakaEngel•

I have successfully used a 210 cone, if I remember correctly. It's been a while since I've GMed that campaign. Somewhere around that number worked well though. You want to make sure they can see characters to their immediate left and right. What this essentially did for us was make it so directly behind you was dark. The immediate left and right rear spaces were partially obscured and it continued diagonal from there.

Worked pretty well for immersion, but it did require some home rules to make it make sense. While they're walking around, no problems, spin and turn as you like, buuuuut combat becomes a different story. What's to stop them from spinning in place on their turn and then doing what they want from there? You could arbitrarily tell them when they could turn, of course, but this can lead to favoritism, arguments, etc.

What we did was essentially allow your character to 'target' and continually face one opponent, so if that opponent moved on their turn, the character would just turn to follow at the same time. If you were not targeting a particular character, or if you wished to look a different direction even though your target hadn't moved, we just made it cost your reaction. A little costly, yes, but we also play with some variant combat rules such as flanking and an automatic movement system I designed to make combat more interesting, so it fit for us.

Thinking on it more, I believe I may simplify it further for my game. No following opponents automatically, allow a single ninety degree turn as a free action, anything further than that is your reaction.

2
ba_Marsh_Wiggle•

Interesting! I experimented with a 120° cone, but it didn't quite feel right. I might give your idea a test run one day :) thanks for your thoughts

1