Looking for low cost equivalent to some Cisco equipment

Hey guys and gals. I'm hoping you can help me.

I'm a self-taught guy who recently deployed a network in a small organization of about 700 PCs using some Cisco equipment they had purchased years earlier and never used.

I was able to successfully install a firewall-on-a-stick method running 10 VLANs over three campuses with the generous help of IRC, forums, and other communities. We used Cisco 3560 switches, 4506, and Aeronet 1231Gs.

We are now looking to do something similar pro-bono for a small school, and looking even at used equipment, the costs of Cisco is far beyond what they can absorb. Do you know of any resources to find the best pricing on Cisco, or, I've read that HP's Procurve switches are becoming more prevalent, and I dare say more preferred by many in the industry. What switches/APs would be similar in capability to the 3560s and 1231Gs?

Thanks for your input!

Posted Aug 17, 2011, 4:53 PM UTC

2133
scritty•

HP switches are acceptable for low-end access stuff.

You might be able to get some of the older foundry switches for a very low price, config isn't very hard if you're used to IOS, Brocade, Huawei or JunOS CLI.

8
weneedsound•

Maybe a year ago I would agree with this statement. Or, if you only limit yourself to buying HP E-Series (Procurve Switches.).

HP has a whole line of new 'A-Series' products aimed at datacenter and core enterprise.

Just looking over HP Networking's recent news articles, it looks like they are getting some excellent wins. Pepsi, SHI, Dreamworks, CERN, Marriot, BMW.. etc.

0
adamjcisco•

Raises hand. I buy and sell used Cisco. I'll help you get pricing on what you are looking for.

I told my coworkers being on Reddit for a large portion of the day would be beneficial to the business.

5
Cobarde•

Do you have a website or anything? I'm looking into building a home study lab very soon and literally just started price hunting to get a general idea of the cost.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
Pas__•

Hm, it looks as Reddit's Markdown parser only eats nice URLs, starting with http:// (or https://). You might want to fix that.

2
adamjcisco•

Thanks!

2
st1cky•

Whats all that's needed for a home lab? I clicked a link to someones home lab a couple months ago but can't find the link/post anymore.

2
hintss•

basically just a stack of cheap hardware, maybe 2 switches, 2 routers, if you're doing voip, 2 phones, etc.

basically just raw hardware to study/practice/gain experience on.

1
jayrod422CCNP R&S, CCNP VOICE, CCNP Wireless, JNCIS-ENT, CCDA•

look on ebay for cisco 3550 switches used.. you still get the same cisco feel with less features the school is not going to use.. and they are cheap... you also could just do 1 or 2 core 3550s and for the access portions in the idfs use 2950s.. the 3550s would do the majority of the routing while the 2950 would just do your basic stuff.. i saw 2950's for around 10-20 bucks each on ebay this morning...

4
baltimoresportsCCNP R&S•

I agree. Maybe I'm brainwashed to love Cisco but i'd go down the used route. 3550s and 2950s should get the job done.

1
rad4ChristOP•

I'll look into those! The 3560s were what I had to work with, and as I said, I learned Cisco in a month, and still know no where near what I feel I should. I'm only utilizing VLANs, Multicast support, and some controls to keep QoS. We use a pfSense FW for DHCP/routing/etc.

Anything the 3550s or 2950s lack that I may need in such a set up?

1
[deleted]•
6
rad4ChristOP•

You sir, are a gentleman and a scholar!

0
weneedsound•

I would advise against buying used gear.

  1. Cisco won't support it or sell a contract on it.
  2. You can't RMA it if a power supply goes bad. If there is anything that causes a 3560 to go bad; it is the power supply.
  3. You don't know the history of the device you are buying.
  4. Can't download software (There are ways if you don't care about being legit, but I bet the school would like to be legit.)

If I was going to buy with a price constraint, I would go HP. E-Series (Old Procurve line.) = Easy to setup, limited features, cheap per port. A-Series = Harder to setup fully featured switches (No more complex than the 3560s). Cheap per port.

5
[deleted]•

Agreed, used gear can cause problems.

First, you might not have up to date images on the hardware so you might be installing a switch with a known bug that impacts a feature you need.

Second, it is unlikely that all your switches will come with the same software image, so you may find that some switches will support a feature, and not others - and some may be affected by bugs and not others.

It is not legal to upgrade the software on a grey-market (eBay used) switch, even copying the image from one to another wouldn't be legal. And as a school that is educating children on how to be upstanding citizens, you do want to be honest right?

What you CAN do is get certified refurbished hardware for a fraction of the cost of new hardware. This is totally legit and you can get a support contract on it.

If you do go the route of used hardware, at least get some spares so when that power supply does fail you aren't waiting for weeks to repair the network, or making some temporary kludge that never gets removed.

1
CiscoJunkieCCNP•

Seems like most people here are on the right track. You didn't mention any numbers (users, traffic loads, etc.) but I think you'll find ProCurves are excellent substitutes for Catalyst 2k/3k switches. Depending on the loads, you may be able to get by with a simple managed switch connected to a basic router.

If you're new to some of the more advanced switching concepts, study up and have a topology in mind before you start purchasing equipment. You'll save money in the long run.

EDIT: Note to self: finish posts before submitting.

3
Cadmus009•

We moved from Cisco switches to ProCurve last year when Cisco had some supply chain problems. So far the ProCurve gear has been solid. It is not too steep of a learning curve coming from Cisco. In most cases they are less expensive than a comparable Cisco switch. I also liked the lifetime NBD warranty, which I've learned Cisco is now including on some of their lower end models. I'm not 100% on the lifetime warranty side form Cisco, but I'm sure there are others who could speak better to this than I can.

We moved from 3560G-48PS to the E2910al (which also allowed us to move our uplinks to 10gig). On the Aeronet side, we still use a few 1242AGs that we inherited when we moved into our office space. We still use Cisco on the firewall/router side as well (2800s, 2900s, ASAs, etc.).

(Also, since this is for a school, make sure to check into educational pricing to get some further discounts.)

2
rad4ChristOP•

This is a small private school, so unless it's dirt cheap used right now, there's not a whole lot they can do. We want to move them to a better infrastructure down the road, but getting ANY sort of infrastructure is paramount now (i.e., not using a DSL modem as their central NW appliance...)

1
[deleted]•

Have you at least contacted a Cisco partner to see what discount they can get?

If you're in BC Canada I can help - my business is registered as a Cisco partner. I'd love to sell hardware to a redditor.

Educational discount is usually very deep. Don't just assume Cisco gear is expensive without actually trying to get a good price.

Edit: added the tool and plug my own business

2
Floyd2002•

I was gonna say, if you WERE a partner then www.cisco.com/go/partneradvisor would be perfect for you! :)

1
Jank1Network Engineer•

You can get some pretty decent Cisco Catalyst C3550 Layer 3 switches on Ebay for dirt cheap.

1
kungfumastah•

I'll jump on the HP bandwagon and vouch for them as well. We use them pretty extensively here (I work for a state R&E network). For the most part, a switch is a switch is a switch. As long as you can pass VLANs you are pretty well set.

2
rad4ChristOP•

Thanks!

1
danstermeister•

I would refer to my earlier comments regarding the Catalyst 3k series of Cisco junk.

Juniper EX is rock solid, has more features, is more admin-friendly, and is actually cheaper than the 'equivalent' Cisco. Once you've gotten your brain wrapped around a Juniper, using a Cisco will feel archaic.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
colmoutardCCENT•

Have you thought about checking out Enterasys' stuff? We use their stuff in our DataCenters; cheaper than Cisco and quite reliable.

1
djdementia•

You should post the budget and port count. Any idfs?

1
TheSojournerCCNA | RHCSA•

Check into Dell switches. I haven't found anything that beats the Aironet line in APs.

Check with Vology Data Systems, a discount reseller. Refurb Cisco equipment with lifetime replacement warranty. Pretty good prices.

Also, check TechSoup's Cisco program.

0
djscsi•

Agreed, I'm using the Dell PowerConnect 2700 series at home and they are hard to beat for the price. I paid $40/ea for 2 8-port gigabit managed switches. Also doing router-on-a-stick with a bunch of VLANs. I couldn't find any equivalent Cisco switch for under a couple hundred bucks that would do this. For the AP, the opensource linux packages like DDWRT/OpenWRT should be able to do VLANs, but I would try looking for used 1200s, that's what I'm using here - they are really good units.

edit: for the router itself I picked up a cisco 1700 with IOS 12.4 and a single 100mbit port off Craigslist for about $30. solid network on the cheap.

1
CookedNoodles•

Dell switches are quite awful and are mostly rebranded 'noname' switches (tiger etc...).

They tend to give them away to people who buy a lot, and we just refuse to use them / stick them on ebay. Dell switches are really not worth the trouble.

Procurve on the other side I've never had any issues with, except one that started flaking out, but it was 8 years old.

1
TheSojournerCCNA | RHCSA•

I use them a lot for customers. I'm not talking the 2700 series like posted above, but the higher-end series. Never had any problems, and some customers are still running their original equipment many years after first deploying them.

3
AnonymooseRedditor•

The higher end PowerConnects are actually made by Extreme Networks.

2
rad4ChristOP•

For basic VLAN support, this might be a way to go. I'll look into these. Thanks!

1
niyrex•

Cisco equipment is over rated. They just happen to be what most IT schools teach since they cornered the market early on. Extreme Networks make some pretty good shit if you are looking for switches and stuff. I have also heard many good things about Vyatta though I have no personal experience with them. I do know that Extreme Networks sells there stuff quite a bit cheaper than Cisco and from what I have experienced, beats the living snot out of Cisco gear in performance.

-2