r/pakistan•
ReddBert

My letter to Prime Minister Imran Khan (Can anyone help to make sure it reaches him?)

[Long Post]

Embassy of Pakistan

To the Esteemed Prime Minister Imran Khan

[Address]

[My city], 27 October 2020

Esteemed Prime Minister Khan,

You made news headlines on two consecutive days in my country, [my country]:

  • Yesterday 26 October a call to fight islamophobia, and
  • Today a response to the bombing of a religious school in Peshawar.

Freedom of speech isn’t sacred. Shouting “Fire!” in a public space is a famous example. Hate mongering should similarly be suppressed. But then, fair criticism should not be the victim.

Please allow me to share my thoughts with you. I think that

- what is at the root of what is possibly perceived as islamophobia, and

- what is at the root of the bombing

are one and the same: The inability to consider the possibility that one is wrong. I want to make the case that the (long) way to a solution is education.

Kids should learn there is only one reality, and no one gets to choose what it is. Your opinion should align with reality.

Kids should learn that an opinion that is backed with verifiable facts is an opinion one should have respect for. And as a corollary, opinions that are not backed up by verifiable facts do not deserve the same level of respect.

Kids should learn, that if something is true, it can be scrutinized to the full extent and will be found true. If something is not true, it will be shielded from scrutiny.

Kids should learn that adults are not always right. The largest religion in the world is followed by one in three people. If they are right, then two out of three adults, about 67%, are wrong. If the followers of the largest religion are wrong, then the percentage of adults who are wrong is even higher. It is not hard to understand that there is quite a non-negligible chance that one has a wrong religious opinion. Take the number of gods. In Sweden the majority thinks that number is zero, in Mexico the majority thinks it is one, and in India that there are multiple. Whatever the answer is, it is a mathematical certainty that in two of these countries the majority of adults is wrong. And we are talking millions of adults. Similarly, it should be taught that the strength of conviction doesn't make a wrong opinion right.

Yet kids are not taught this. Teaching kids that adults are not always right will help them to master tolerance for other beliefs.

Kids should learn that we can use the universe as a source of knowledge. They should not only learn that they have to eat vegetables and fruit because it contains vitamin C, but also why we humans have to do that and tigers, dogs, and horses don’t. To make vitamin C, an enzyme is necessary, encoded for by a section (gene) of DNA. But in humans, part of that gene is missing. We can’t make the enzyme, so we can’t make vitamin C. Gorilla’s and chimpanzees have to have vitamin C in their diet too. They lack exactly the same part of the gene. Kids should learn that it is one of many lines of evidence for evolution and the origin of mankind.

As long as those facts can not be freely taught, the problem of islamophobia and religious violence will not go away. Given that there are no bombings in my country, I think that at the very least the problem I identified above is at your end too. You are the prime minister; it is yours to fix. Chasing the Peshawar terrorists is good, but it is not an effective solution as the root of the problem is not addressed.

There is reason for optimism though. Kids are typically raised with an understanding that honesty is good and that arrogance (claiming something to know for sure without verifiable evidence) is bad. It is up to you to make use of these values recognized by anyone irrespective of religious conviction to make the world a better place. I’ve read your wikipedia page. I was sufficiently impressed to write this letter without the idea that it would go wasted on you. At my end, I will try to suppress the prejudice that someone will suppress this letter from reaching you. I have more ideas about what and how to share information if you are interested in improving dialogue. With one reality, if everyone tries to be honest, everyone will be moving in the same direction and at least some of the differences in the world would disappear.

With the most respect, yours sincerely,

[Reddbert]

[ContactInfo]

Posted Nov 1, 2020, 7:23 AM UTC

1114
MomoK9•

Damn, this is good. I, as a Pakistani, also believe that education can fix many problems. But not just facts like "the mitochondria is the powerhouse of the cell" but how to be responsible consumers of data. Why and how it came to be. How do we KNOW that what someone is saying is indeed supported by facts and not feelings. Good on you mate. I hope he gets to read this.

7
ReddBertOP•

Thanks!

And indeed, facts just because of the facts isn’t going to help very much (excellent example!)

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

4
ReddBertOP•

Thank you. Could you find that for me? I did not succeed.

2
darth_budha•

Replace "Kids" with "Children".

4
ReddBertOP•

Thanks

2
WisestAirBenderPakistan•

I wonder if you could get this published in a newspaper

Though this seems to be suggesting that Islam might be wrong. I don't know how acceptable is saying thay

2
ReddBertOP•

Interesting suggestion.

Are there newspapers that publish in English? Any suggestions for names of newspapers?

1
kingskarachi•

Yeah everything is fine, except for the islam is wrong part, that is not gonna fly here. People are entitled to their beliefs, suggesting one is wrong means insisting you are right, which is true for the other party. So not going to agree with that. Other than that it is good, but from the tone of it, it seems like OP doesn't have an in-depth understanding of how Pakistan works and how Pakistani society is.

1
WisestAirBenderPakistan•

I wish Pakistan worked this way

2
kingskarachi•

Me too, but there is something odd with Pakistan that outsiders dont understand, can't blame them we ourselves don't understand lol.

I have yet to comprehend how Pakistan has survived this long.

1
kingskarachi•

Agree with everything, except for the islam is wrong part, that is not gonna fly here. People are entitled to their beliefs, suggesting one is wrong means insisting you are right, which is true for the other party. So not going to agree with that.

Other than that it is good, but from the tone of it, it seems like you dont have an in-depth understanding of how Pakistan works and how Pakistani mentality is and how politics is run in the country.

1
ReddBertOP•

People are indeed entitled to their beliefs. I totally agree. There should be no government or other organizations or whatever pressuring people into believing something. But I don’t see a problem with a government or organization promoting people to be honest and refrain from arrogance to the extent that other people are harmed. The people who are responsible for the bombing in Peshawar should not walk free because what they did was in line with their religious convictions. Religious freedom ends where the rights of others are violated.

If person A shows person B that person B is wrong, that doesn’t mean that person A is right. They can both be wrong. Example: If B says that 2+3 equals six then person A is right when he says that person B is wrong because the answer must be odd. But if person A says the answer is 7 then he is also wrong despite his answer being odd. If one person interprets the Quran one way and another person in another way, the same goes. My point is that beliefs should be personal and that no one should force beliefs onto another person or bring harm to another person. One might be wrong. To reduce harm to others, I encourage the government and Pakistani citizens to promote the value of honesty and to discourage people from being arrogant.

I totally agree with you that I don’t know how things work in Pakistan. That doesn’t stop me from having an opinion on it nor do I have the idea that it can’t possibly be better than it is. A hockey coach isn’t a better player than any of the team members nor does he have to be to contribute to the success of the team. I’m trying to share my insight which I hope has some value towards a more peaceful world.

3
PoliticalSapien•

Good luck with sending this to our radical PM.

-1†