r/atheism•
ReddBert

Response to events in France

TL;DR In response to events in France, I call for a focus on truth to counteract, as honesty is a core value and children may more likely to pick it up. Most arguments are of equal importance outside France.

In view of the recent events, here is a proposal on how to proceed with education in France.

Samuel Paty died for teaching freedom of speech. His lesson resulted in a clash of values that cost him his life. What killed him was arrogance: It was the inability of the perpetrator to consider that his religious opinion might be wrong.

It is important to understand the consequences of our response to religion-based violence. Force will harden opinions and not be effective or even counter-productive. Yet strong measures are needed and to be effective we should address the issues at the root.

It takes a well-considered approach to be effective when teaching values that go against hard core values with which (young) people are raised. It also does require a multi-facetted approach, and to be effective use must be made of values that are shared.

Things to teach children:

A) About reality

- Something is true if it is in agreement with reality.

- There is only one reality. You can’t choose what it is. You have to change your opinion to align with reality. It is the decent thing to do.

- If something is true, it can be thoroughly questioned. If indeed true, it will survive any scrutiny. (It is how science works.)

- If something is not true, people will use tactics to prevent it from getting exposed as not true. They may defend it with excuses or may try to prevent you from scrutinising it for example by social pressure. These are red flags.

Will children irrespective of religious upbringings find this acceptable? I think so. However, it provides a foundation for them to start thinking.

B) About values

Use values that are generally recognized as good. It is good to be honest. It is not good to be arrogant. Ask children questions: Which is more valuable, an opinion that is supported by verifiable facts or one that isn’t? Which of those opinions deserve more respect?

If there is a higher power, do you think that higher power would like you to be honest? Do you think that the higher power would like people to claim to be right irrespective of their religious conviction and despite having no verifiable evidence for their religion?

Do you think that if there is no higher power, that it would be a bad thing to be honest?

Children will accept that honesty is good

C) About science

- In class you may get bad grades for not knowing the answer to a question, but that doesn’t mean that “I don’t know” is a perfectly good and honest reply to any question you don’t have an answer to that is supported by verifiable facts.

- Scientists are people who study reality. They try to find out what it is.

- You have heard about Louis Pasteur, Isaac Newton and Albert Einstein who are all famous for their discoveries. What is the name of the scientist who was the first to discover verifiable evidence for the existence of a higher power? [Answer: Despite the fame this would give that person, no one has ever discovered any. It would make that scientist more famous than all these three taken together]

- Teach overwhelming verifiable evidence for evolution. children already learn about the importance of vitamin C. Teach them why we have to have it in our diets while dogs, cats, bears, cows and horses don’t. For an organism to make vitamin C, an enzym is required. That enzyme is coded for by a gene in its DNA. In humans, part of that gene is missing. So, we can’t make the enzyme and hence can’t make vitamin C. Interestingly, gorillas and chimpanzees have to have vitamin C in their diets too. They lack exactly the same part of the gene. We share a common ancestor. While science didn’t set out to prove any particular religion wrong, any religion that teaches a different origin for man has got that wrong. (It is important to make the connection with religion, because they may not think of doing that themselves).

- How science does check and double-check with independent methods. One reality means that everything has to match even among the various scientific disciplines. And indeed, we can see from astronomy that the universe is very old. Radiodating rocks on earth, layers in drilled ice cores, stalactites and mutations in our DNA, they all tell the same thing.

- If aliens landed on earth, destroyed really everything including memories and books about all religions and all of science, and then left, the following would happen. In a couple of thousand years, the science books would be back. People would rediscover the law of gravity, math and the evidence for evolution in fossils and in the DNA. However, the various religious scriptures wouldn’t be back.

D) About religion

- There have been and are hundreds of religions. They can’t all be true. At least some of them must have been made up. Mankind is quite good at this, apparently.

- Faith is belief without evidence. Any religion that is made up can’t have any verifiable evidence for it. Such a religion has to rely on faith.

- Show that adults are not know-it-alls and build on that. The largest religion is followed by one in three people. If they are right, then two out of three adults, about 67%, are wrong. If the followers of the largest religion are wrong, then the percentage of adults that are wrong is even higher.

- You will never meet a person who is right about everything. No one can say what he is wrong about, though, so we all live with the impression that we are right. We should be humble enough to consider the possibility that we have an opinion that is wrong. When confronted with something that goes against our opinion, the decent thing to do is to use verifiable facts to figure out whether it is better to change our opinion.

- Don’t (just) teach characteristics of religions but also discuss how it is possible that religions that were not true have flourished for centuries or millennia. Young people have to learn how religions work: (indoctrination from a young age, unverifiable threats about the afterlife if you don’t abide by the rules of the religion and unverifiable promises if you do; ignoring parts of the religious books that are wrong or abhorrent, making faith a virtue, and polished routines to justify what is erroneous). Discuss the alternatives that a higher power would have to disseminate the knowledge that he wants people to know. It could have clouds shaped as text in the sky.

- Discuss whether it would be just if some people would be born in the right religion and go to heaven because of that, whereas if you were born with the wrong religion you would have to figure out it was wrong, go against social pressure to abandon it, figure out which one of many hundreds is correct despite the religious books containing flaws. (Am I to believe the book with the talking snake and donkey, or the one with the talking ant?).

- Discuss what if a god doesn’t care what religion you have but just checks whether you’re honest and respectful towards other raised differently. What if the higher power hates people that arrogantly claim to know the higher power’s mind.

CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

If we share the conviction that irrespective of our background, we strive to be honest and pledge to change our opinions in view of verifiable facts, then some of the differences that separate us will disappear (Egalite).

To deal with these delicate matters, it is best to provide the information in a series of movies. While the movies are there to change minds, they are not propaganda as they do not tell people what to think; they ask them to think and provide food for thought in the form of verifiable facts. They ask people to rely on generally recognized core values like honesty and being modest instead of arrogant.

Movies are relatively cheap (YouTube), and can be provided in multiple languages. It also is safer for teachers, as they do not run the risk of saying something in the wrong way and it is not them presenting the possibly shocking confrontation with truth. They are just the ones who were asked (required) to play the movies in class.

If a religion is true, their leaders can only welcome this proposal as people looking for truth backed by verifiable facts will end up there. It a religion is not true, their leaders have a hard time pleading for an exception.

If you have read this far, thank you! Please consider making the above (or if a proper translation into French is available in this thread its translation) more widely available and send it to teachers you may know, to the education department, and to Mr Macron. Nothing will improve until action is taken. Merci.

VIVE LA VERITE, VIVE LA FRANCE!

Posted Nov 1, 2020, 10:15 AM UTC

312
[deleted]•

In view of the recent events, here is a proposal on how to proceed with education in France.

Do you have any examples of how current education in France differs from your long text?

You said it yourself - Samuel Paty died for teaching freedom of speech. Not because freedom of speech is not taught in France.

7
kni_cker•

Woke not being woke enough . yikes . Good counter

0
ReddBertOPAgnostic Atheist•

Two posts so far of people taking issue with what I say. Am I missing something here? (Not a native speaker).

My point is: Brainwashed people are not big on freedom of speech as things will be said that go against their religion. Religion is the number one value. The religion teaches not to be honest with respect to the religion and to scrutinize it; it teaches to defend the religion (and kill infidels).

Teaching that freedom of speech doesn’t impress them. And in case of Samuel Paty, a religious nut killed him.

To reduce the amount of nuttiness, the nuts have to be addressed with values that they do share. My post put forward a number of such points.

0
[deleted]•

Am I missing something here?

You are suggesting "changes" that are more or less the status quo. You are promoting the teaching of better values to somehow lessen religious violence, but it is the fact that these better values are taught to religious fanatics or their children that is provoking them to violence.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
mindsofeuropa32•

I think he just worded it clumsily. He didn't mean that the teach was arrogant - it was about the attacker.

1
ReddBertOPAgnostic Atheist•

Yes.

1
DoglessDyslexic•

Hmm, yes, I believe you're right.

1
mindsofeuropa30•

What is happening in France is the inevitable clash between cultures that have different systems of values. You can't really expect that people will abandon their cultural identity unless they are forced to, which is why the options are: continue to live in one society with a lot of violence and low trust, impose the values of the dominant culture upon minorities, or separate and let each side live in accordance with their own norms.

2
Listakem•

You realize, of course, that French schools/teachers already teach science, history, geography ? I find your post hilarious as a French because you obviously have no idea about what is actually going on in a French classroom.

1
ReddBertOPAgnostic Atheist•

In my country they teach those subjects too. Of course.

But I was never taught how it contradicts the various religions. Do they do that in France?

In religion education class, I was taught the beliefs of various religions. None of my teachers ever said they can’t all be right. No teacher ever showed mathematically that the majority of adults is wrong with respect to the number of gods. No teacher ever taught that there was no verifiable evidence for a higher power. In other words, they were just tiptoeing around taboos. Is that different in France? You were educated there. I’m interested to hear about it.

Children are left in the lurch if they are not provided with verifiable facts and withheld logical reasoning. They should receive a vaccination against brainwashing. Even if the vaccination is only partially effective, it may mollify the adverse effects of the clash of cultures.

0
[deleted]•

You want to teach kids what to think instead of just how to think. If one learns a good epistemic toolset but is unable to apply it to their existing beliefs, forcing it upon them will just make them double down in defense of said beliefs.

While increasing the teaching of critical thinking and skepticism is a good thing, people must question their beliefs themselves. It's often a long process. The biggest issue with religious kids in western countries isn't as much education but the environment they live in - their parents, relatives and so on. They're not the ones attending your school, and will combat anything the child learned if needed. This is why all of this is a generational shift at best. Direct debate will not change much.

2
ReddBertOPAgnostic Atheist•

Nope, I do want them to get to think. In my opinion a foundation of shared-core values-based reasons has to be provided to open them up to start to think.

Made-up religions can’t permit themselves to encourage people to scrutinize the religion. So, this encouragement has to come from somewhere else.

1