One of the more annoying problems with artificial locomotion was solved a year ago and no one seemed to notice

Discussion

There's two commonly accepted ways to ascertain a "forward" direction in VR when using stick locomotion; either using your off-hand's direction, or your head. Both have considerable drawbacks, deriving direction from the HMD means that any glances or other head movements influence direction. Most flatscreen 3D games (though particularly FPS games) tie direction to the viewport camera/head so many early VR implementations did the same, but when making unintentional or rapid head movements (glancing to the side/behind etc) you will suddenly accelerate in that direction unless you make precise, well timed adjustments to the stick. Hand-based direction decouples direction from your head allowing for more natural head movement, but two handed weapons or any kind of hand movement can also cause issues, overhead swings of weapons, throwing or even looking at your wrist can cause you to stumble around erratically.

Saints & Sinners has a head-based option, but it drops hand-based direction for a feature that derives body direction algorithmically from the HMD and both controllers. Try it for yourself, launch S&S and start walking forward, then without letting go or changing the direction of the stick, look at your wrist watch. You still move forward as normal. Overhead swings of an axe, even waggling your hands around like an idiot doesn't really seem to phase it much, at most throwing you off by a couple degrees. It solves a significant problem that literally every other VR game with stick locomotion has and no one talks about it.

Here is a short video demonstrating the robustness of S&S' locomotion implementation: https://i.imgur.com/DjaYoH6.mp4

The first two clips are demonstrate how any general hand movement doesn't influence direction in of itself, the third shows how it handles head glances while arms remain stationary, there's a bit of drift when glancing, but only a few degrees. The last clip is me rotating rightwards in my office chair, glancing left and right. The stick in my off hand is pressed forward during the entirety of the video with no corrections made.

Just about every game with melee combat would massively benefit from this, but frankly it should be default with any game that uses stick locomotion. Can any developers give some insight into why there hasn't been similar implementations elsewhere?

Posted Nov 11, 2020, 11:59 AM UTC

22060
Loading comments…