Was Obama worse than Bush?

My friends said the other day that Obama's drone strikes actually outnumbered the deaths caused by Bush. I don't really believe that, but I'm not getting super easy clarification from Google or Wikipedia.

Can anyone point me to some clear figures somewhere?

Posted Nov 11, 2020, 8:48 PM UTC · edited

07
tsicsafitna•

From the invasion of Iraq in 2003 to the end of 2008, 106,377 civilians were killed, compared to 82,374 in the period 2009-2016. (https://www.iraqbodycount.org/database/). Important to note is that of the 82,374 casualties in 2009-2016, 66% happened 2014-2016.

Air attack (I assume including drone strikes) casualties were ~5950 in 2003-2008 and ~5300 in 2009-2016. The air attack deaths during Obama's years correlate heavily with the increase in casualties 2014-2016.

I think it's hard to really determine who was worse. Bush started the war, but Obama continued it.

Edit: Deaths are for specifically "violent deaths", not deaths due to starvation, disease, sanctions etc. Also, gun deaths were significantly higher during Bush's years.

6
IunderstandMathOP•

Thanks! Yeah, the question is a little trite and clickbaity 🤷🏻‍♀️

I know the estimated deaths from the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan are at least around half a million in total, so my friends' claim seemed really off to me. Granted, those are still basically ongoing events? So that's not exactly a Bush-only number, even if his admin started it.

But yeah, I was pretty confident there was an order of magnitude difference there.

2
AngelicDirt•

... Can't the point be that we never let either of them happen again?

4
IunderstandMathOP•

I'm totally for that. But I guess my point is that I'm very dumb and I want to be able to speak about these things intelligently. So I'm asking for help.

5
AngelicDirt•

Fair enough. GL. o7

3
fullautoluxcommie•

Bush Jr was worse than Obama, during Obama’s regime there were more deaths by drones in wars that killed more people during Bush. There’s also the lying about WMDs thing. For domestic policy: the Patriot Act was put in place under Bush then reauthorized under Obama.

4
Veuzi•

Bush was worse overall, but Obama was hardly an improvement

2