I fell in love with my friend's girlfriend and did a lot of emotional cheating, and continued to betray my friends, whom I promised I would stop.

Not a throwaway account . . . this needs to be said.


I had the most wonderful, awe-struck three months of my life with a best friend. We bonded over music and other shared interests, which we both found riveting and transcendent; we found an extremely deep chemistry that fostered boundless communication, optimism and altruism for each other, and a whole ton of empathy; we appreciated each others' company, insight, and conversation.

The thing is, I still find her ideal in many ways, and I've not any inclination to change that. She pairs with me psychologically in a close, mature, comfortable, sympathetic way; she gives me security and happiness in my self-concept, and she gives me a consistency of companionship that I've only found in small doses of memorable moments with others.

If I can be honest, I think she felt the same way too for much of the time that we were each others' confidantes and "disinterested" best-friends. As soon as we started to lead down the path of fantasy – as soon as we were found out, and didn't stop – we started envisioning each other as something more. We gave each other the sustenance that the other craved, and that she wasn't receiving in her relationship, and we clarified it as being on the wavelength of care-giving and companionship.

We loved each other to the extent that she wasn't the existential "other" to me as a "self" – she was a second "self," a "you" to a "me" – and we tried to ameliorate the relationship to be at the right level for both of us consistently. We wanted to move towards a feeling of long-term friendship, of agape, but didn't succeed in bringing it about. We ended up getting caught. We didn't save it for later. We had to bear the requisite shame and embarrassment of having something to hide from people we cared about.


I betrayed my friends – I told them I wasn't talking to her any more, and that I didn't want to mess things up – and really, I sincerely didn't. I just couldn't put things together to see the horrible judgment I was making.

I figured unconsciously . . . hey, this is transcendentally special. (And it was, at the time.)

It wasn't an active choice of her over them, of being in love over doing the right thing – it was an unwillingness to choose one or the other – so I two-faced myself and hid it away. I never tried to feel guilty about it, and we somehow absolved each other in loving the great meaning and passion which imbued our conversations. We weren't more special than them. We were just unequivocally close; we found so much strength in each other.

I was willing not to ever be the "other guy" to her, and I honestly never was. I never competed for her affection, never was jealous of the guy. I never saw myself on the wavelength of being her boyfriend . . . I just loved her for who she was and loved relating to her. In all honesty, that's where I felt myself as being.


So when the news came out that we had continued to speak consistently after we had been caught red-handed with texts a month or so earlier, shit hit the fan. I lost four good friends. All I want to do is say I'm sorry – not to get forgiveness, but just to express it, especially to the boyfriend in the situation – but I'm too cowardly to do that. Why? I don't think they want to hear it, and I was so wrapped up in a semi-depressive state over it that I don't even want to re-encounter those thoughts again. As such, however, I still haven't forgiven myself.

I'm also secretly wondering whether someday our paths will cross again. Fuck it, you know, I'm not desperate, and I won't ever make them cross again, but she has my contact information, and we'll probably be getting in touch again to reconvene and recalibrate at some point in the next era of our lives. I can't expect that we'll be on the same wavelength as before, but I'll be damned if this is the last I see of her.

We had such a special thing . . . why on earth didn't we wait?


I think part of the reason I haven't forgiven myself is because I'm still not convinced I did enough wrong.

I didn't mean to break them up. I didn't mean to seem like I was stealing her away. I never wanted to fuck with something that wasn't my business. She was hurting, and I helped. Now I see that I can't do that. Of course we knew that when we got into it, but we masqueraded as if it was something else. That amazing experience still hasn't left my mind yet, and the only thing I have negatively against her is that she was too damn hard to resist.

I just feel like a jackass, being so ambiguous in these feelings. Fuck me, wanting to be so loving. Damn it.

Where's my logic that I pride myself in having? Where's those mental boundaries? Why was I not stronger?

Why didn't I wait for her?


Feel free to dig at me with brutal honesty on all counts.

Posted Aug 26, 2011, 2:11 AM UTC · edited

3229
Loading comments…