Help me upgrade S2 brakes
Hi everyone. I'm awaiting my S2 and I'm already catastrophizing, because that's what I do, and I already know I want to significantly upgrade the stock brakes. I'm approx 190 lbs, and I'll be hauling a sidecar and kid totalling about 75 more pounds around hills with traffic stops, bike paths, etc. I'm looking at Magura MT5e or eStop and MDR-P rotors, but I'm confused as to differences, what I need, and how much is overkill.
Can you help me understand what I need for a full front and back replacement, while keeping motor cutout and brake light functionality? Is 220mm up front and 203mm back ridiculous? Just right? IDK, please help me, Super Squad, and thank you!
Posted Nov 15, 2020, 11:10 PM UTC · edited
With 3 batteries, sometimes 2 adult riders and more modifications that any other 73 bike we have ever seen, our bike is very, very heavy (unlike the S2 our S1 also has a steel frame which is heavier).
We run 203mm rotors front & rear with hydraulic callipers and have more than enough stopping power, our rotors have never warped and are still going strong.
If anyone tells you that 203mm rotors warp then they are either referring to poor quality, cheaply made rotors and/or they don't know how to set the brakes up correctly so the brakes then overheat and damage the rotors.
If you buy a decent set of 203mm rotors, set them up correctly and brake correctly then you will not have a problem.
It's better to have too much braking power than not enough braking power - If your bikes braking capability is too weak then you will have to work the brakes hard and this will cause them to overheat so fit the best brakes you can get!
We would suggest getting 180mm to 203mm adaptor brackets for front & rear and then fitting 203mm rotors to both front & rear. This is most likely all you will need to do to give you enough braking power.
This video may be of interest to you as they discuss the size of the rear rotor and make some good points:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ieeV3pLSoVo&feature=emb_logo
(We are not an official UK dealer & have no affiliation in any way to "Super73" the bike company)
Thanks for that...the video got me thinking. I guess it makes sense from a motorcycle standpoint to have that big rotor up front, but it is weird to think that ONLY approximately 30% of your braking force is in the back, because I feel like I mostly rely on my rear brake, but maybe that's my MTB brain not wanting to go over the bars face first.
When it comes to the mass of the S2/rider/sidecar/child/"stuff" I should feel pretty confident in 203mm front and rear for mild hills, right?
I don't see any downside to bigger rotors aside from mass - you'll have better effciency, cooling, fade resistance, etc., but not necessarily stopping power, right? I mean, that's the calipers and pads doing that work...I can see why on a motorcycle or downhill MTB that a huge rotor up front would be desirable, but for S2 purposes 203/303 should not be a problem?
203mm front & rear will be plenty if you have them set up correctly.
Bigger rotors will also give you better stopping power compared to smaller rotors if the smaller rotors overheat under load.
It is worth getting a good quality set of 203mm rotors - We upgraded our S1 160mm stock rotors for 203mm front & rear and have only one regret - That we didn't do it sooner!!
This may be of interest to you:
https://www.reddit.com/r/Super_73_Mods_Plus/comments/hp2hua/difference_between_160mm_203mm_brake_discrotor/