OhSnapsItsStonks•

As a Texan, this interchange makes no sense to me... seems inefficient regarding space used.

3
rollerCrescentOP•

The real interchange is actually quite small compared to most other major intersections in my area (pacific northwest). But the other commenter is right—this roundabout is very impractical in terms of how many crossing points there are. In fact, the original interchange is a traffic circle with four signaled intersections on it. I mostly just did this to experiment with complex road markings.

5
BadMacaroniArt•

I’m a truck driver who has to go around London a lot. Basically every interchange is inefficient and poorly designed in London. The problem with a 1700 year old city is none of it was designed for vehicles so they’ve just connected roads in any random order.

7
mc_enthusiast•

That's because it is inefficient. A parclo with double off ramps would have needed less roads and would have resulted in only 2 instead of 4 points with crossing traffic.

3
LLbeejay•

I don't think you'd for a parclo in the space of the irl junction, it's a really small area. Plus majority of the traffic heading out of Heathrow would be heading west out to the M25 junction so generally it tends to flow pretty well.

1
mc_enthusiast•

Probably true: parclos tend to take up more space in 2 quadrants compared to a roundabout, even if their overall space requirement doesn't really need to be significantly higher, and the asymmetric shape can make it diffcult to fit into an already (partially) built-up area.

1
OldKingTuna•

You are correct, roundabouts are less space efficient compared to a four way intersections. The benefits however are improved safety and improved left-turn traffic flow (in RH traffic locals).

And as a Texan, y'all don't need to worry about space efficiency. You've got space for days. ;)

2
OhSnapsItsStonks•

If safety is a concern why not use a Diverging Diamond Intersection instead of this particular style intersection (IRL, not in-game)? A DDI gives you those same benefits.

2
OldKingTuna•

Hmm, well in OP's case, the RL interchange is sort of a hybrid service/highway interchange. Northbound is local roads and east/west/sound are highways. I don't think a DDI would work in this instance. In general, I guess it's a familiarity thing. Even here in the States, DDI service interchanges seem to be slow to adopt.

2
OhSnapsItsStonks•

One reason is because the DDI completely removes the option to travel parallel with the highway through the intersections - you have to make either a left or right turn onto the smaller streets. The only places I've seen DDIs are in places where you wouldn't normally make that maneuver anyways. DDIs aren't meant to replace all, or even half, of all the highway intersections. They serve a specific purpose.

1
RoastKrill•

Space isn't really an object as on three of the four sides there is just fields, so it doesn't need to be compact. It's mostly this shape because most UK motorway junctions are similar, so drivers know what to expect.

1
zkrp5108•

Yea but....look at the results!

2
OldKingTuna•

Angle of entry when entering/exiting the roundabout are off. You want all angles to be < 45° where possible. Your GIF shows how significantly vehicles have to slow down to turn. Check out the satellite view as apposed to the map view in Google Maps.

2
rollerCrescentOP•

I upvoted this already but I just want to comment and say thank you for the feedback. I’ll work on that

2