r/Necrontyr•
ebonlance

How would you "fix" the Reanimator?

This is not an attempt to call for house rules or anything, just a thought experiment in game design.

I think it is widely thought at this point that the Reanimator pretty much sucks. It is expensive, fragile, and doesn't have much offensive output of its own.

I think this is an example of GW trying to design any buffs to RP rolls very conservatively, because of how bad it would feel for a 20 man blob of warriors to consistently get 4+ (rerolling 1s) RP rolls. Previously you could obviate RP by blowing away the whole unit in one turn, which is a lot harder now and so that +1 needs to come at a steeper premium. Honestly, the concern from designers here feels appropriate, as the RP changes are very strong on our troops.

To deconstruct the model's problems, it really boils down into three categories.

1) The Reanimator is expensive.

At 110 points, the Reanimator has to really perform well to make it worth including. If you make 20 RP rolls aided by the Reanimator's ability, the +1 only buys you about three more successes than you would have otherwise had (not including rerolls). So the rest of the model's ability comes down to its offensive output (which is not zero, but not very high) and its ability to maybe sit on an objective (also not great due to its short range). There is also the opportunity cost for opponents to consider - they will possibly prioritize killing the Reanimator first, which means your other large models may get one additional turn of usability. I think think this aspect of a model like this is underrated.

Realistically, I am not sure how cheap the reanimator would need to be in its current state to be included. If it were 80 points, I think it starts approaching the "sure, why not try one" territory but the marginal utility of its contribution still makes it unlikely to "make" its points back.

2) The Reanimator is fragile.

T6 with no invuln and not a lot of wounds. When you compare the reanimator to a Technomancer, you get more reanimation utility (for core units anyway) and chracter protection. An invuln save here would help, or maybe even quantum shielding.

3) The Reanimator's buff is too difficult to apply.

This is really the crux of the issue. The short range, LOS requirements, and the requirement that the model remains in that short range (and that the Reanimator survives) make it very awkward to use and exposes the Reanimator to increased risk of destruction.

At a high level, this needs to either pack increased punch, or have fewer restrictions. To make the reanimator really spicy, and to reinforce the theme they were going for of "squishy healer who should be targeted first", I would change it to the following:

"When a unit is being healed by reanimation beams, when models in that unit begin to reassemble, treat a number of dice equal to the Wounds characteristic of one reassembling model as successes instead of rolling dice for them." Getting a guaranteed return on something like a Skorpehk destroyer (or a Scarab swarm) turns the reanimator buff from a nice-to-have but not game-changing buff to something that potentially makes a unit impossible to remove unless the reanimator is targeted first. If this change (or something similar) was added while keeping the Reanimator's high cost and fragility, it may make the risk more likely.

Posted Nov 19, 2020, 3:55 PM UTC

1331
Loading comments…