[ANALYSIS] A Character Study of Wilbur’s Mental State on the Dream SMP
(or: A Formal Request For u/wilbursoot's Character to Get Some Therapy)
I am fully aware that the Dream SMP is a roleplay. However, it's a damn good one, and as a result, I'm fully able to overanalyse characters - and I think that's great! This essay is focusing on only one part of this character - I have hyperfixated on him so hard that honestly I would be able to write a second if you really wanted me to.
I'm also... very prepared to, in future, end up having this essay be completely wrong. That's okay! This is just for fun. Roleplay is lighthearted, not stressful, after all.
CONTENT WARNINGS: This includes heavy discussions of depression, trauma, mental health, and suicide. Keep in mind that any reference to ‘Wilbur Soot’ is referring to his character, not the streamer himself. I’m not going to diagnose a real person with real disorders, that’s weirdchamp.
This essay is a spoiler for quite literally all of season one, and the first part of season two. So.. be careful! I will be posting it later on Tumblr under the username general-light.
This essay is about 4.5k words long, and is broken up into approximately five sections. I know that’s a lot; I don’t expect this essay to go very far when it comes to social media. Still, if you read it, thank you a lot!
-------
Wilbur’s character on the Dream SMP is, I would say, one of the most tragic ones compared to the rest of the cast. Looking back on his entire life, it becomes clear with the power of hindsight that he was doomed to eventually crumble in his own mind right from the start of his life. Contrary to popular belief, though, Wilbur’s long-burning fuse does not start with his exile from L’Manberg, but with his childhood – a part of Dream SMP lore that is not often touched upon.
This “essay” will focus on explaining the roots and development of Wilbur’s mental health struggles, how they manifested, and how they impacted all of his decisions. Hopefully, it will serve to awaken people to the depth of his problems. I want to make it clear in advance that I am by no means a formal essay writer. I will mostly be including information that can be backed up by at least one in-canon reference, though I will include some interpretations of character histories as well. Ultimately, this is my assessment of the character – feel free to read and digest as you please.
Key note: There may be times when Wilbur’s own lines will contradict my assertions. Before you counter me with them, remember this key fact: Actions speak louder than words.
---> Table of Contents
> 01. Childhood, and Needing Attention
> 02. Trauma, Betrayal, and Distrust
> 03. Stress, Delusions, and Suicidal Tendencies
> 04. Dying With Trauma - Dissociative Amnesia
> 0X. Conclusion (and Mock Diagnoses)
--
> 01. Childhood, and Needing Attention
Wilbur Soot is the son of Philza Minecraft, and the brother to Technoblade, TommyInnit, and Tubbo. The DSMP canon is not very clear on the circumstances of each birth, but with stream evidence, right now, the best assessment of canon is that Wilbur was the oldest biological son of Phil, and Tommy’s biological older brother, and that both Technoblade and Tubbo were adopted into the family at varying dates.
It is evident that Wilbur thinks very highly of his father, thinking back to him in what he once assumed to be his final moments at the Manberg Festival. At least once in his childhood, presumably while he was very young (as Wilbur did not mention any of his brothers in the memory), he and Phil would partake in creative activities together – once, they made Chinese Lanterns, and this memory was strong and positive enough to persist even in his deceased state.
However, despite this period of idyllic peace in his life, it would appear that Phil’s attention would become unevenly divided among his children. In his life, Wilbur would come to display a hunger to be seen and noticed, which most likely stemmed from early experiences of feeling underappreciated and unseen - Phil would express that he didn’t expect Wilbur to be any source of major trouble, trusting him to take care of himself. A lot of Wilbur’s later actions could be interpreted as having been heavily impacted by his drive to be seen and acknowledged, such as his insistence on having at least one person witness his detonation of L’Manberg.
This assertion of imbalance is only reinforced by Phil’s instinctual reaction to his spiralling – Phil condemns Wilbur’s acts, claiming that it’s unlike the son he knows, while endorsing and praising Techno for his literal massacre. This act could be seen as a display of favouritism, implying that there was an imbalance of recognition in their childhood household. It is far more likely that Phil placed more trust in Wilbur to be mature and responsible, but this would backfire, as a higher level of trust would come to result in Wilbur potentially resenting Phil for his lack of parental interference in his life.
These childhood issues would leave a lasting impact on him throughout his entire life. It is possible that his lack of attention fuelled his self-identification as a “Dirty Crime Boy”, and his further acts of lawlessness, as delinquency is often a last resort for people who desire to be recognised for anything at all. This self-identification would fuel his desire to create a drug empire on the Dream SMP in the first place, which would steadily spiral into the creation of L’Manberg as a whole when the Dream Team called his actions into question.
It would appear that Wilbur has always been very fond of his brothers – entries from his later memories would reaffirm this, as he would spend time with both Techno and Tommy frequently. As a result, it would appear that the core of Wilbur’s desire for recognition focuses on Phil’s respect and pride, and nobody else’s. Despite this, Phil is not the only one he thirsts for attention from, almost as if Wilbur is attempting to supplement his lack of fatherly attention with anything else.
Notably, Wilbur inadvertently continues the cycle of fatherhood neglect in his own son, and we can see similar degrees of jealousy and acting out in Fundy’s actions, which only reinforces my assertion.
As a result, I assert that a key potential motive for creating L’Manberg could have been to attract attention from the other server members (and maybe Phil, who had been relatively absent up until that point due to his focus on his own home server). Despite starting an entire nation, Phil would scarcely acknowledge it, most likely because Phil was under the impression that he could handle himself – this likely worsened his frustrations later in life. During his Presidency, Wilbur would begin to struggle with disrespect from his own nation members, which would peak in the civil war fought about the Pet conflict.
This resultant fear that nobody respects him was a key catalyst for his drive to kickstart the first elections, believing that becoming democratically elected was the only way to achieve proper recognition and avoid being displaced among his own family again. Wilbur struggles for control in his own nation – this shows in his closing of the borders and his rules on the members remaining armourless.
The most notable examples of Wilbur’s lasting hunger for attention are clearest in exile. During Niki’s Birthday Party, notably while under the effects of nicotine and perhaps alcohol depending on your perception of the party, Wilbur would openly request attention on multiple occasions, frequently forcing his way into the spotlight of the situation as if he could not bear to go unseen in this situation. Later, he would admit that he only attended because he desired an audience for his detonation (this is the one time he admits this motive for keeping people around out loud).
During his stay in Pogtopia, Wilbur would grow frustrated whenever he showed any signs of losing his say in the commune. Despite not technically having a hierarchy, Wilbur would act like a leader, attempting to reinforce his authority by taking command of the people in it. When Tommy began to show signs of disobedience, Wilbur’s frustration at the lack of respect and recognition boiled over into him snapping at his brother [the classic “there is a reason you are not the President, and never will be” like].
Wilbur would frequently delay his button scheme so that at least one person could bear witness to it, implying that one of the reasons his detonation plan was on such a large scale was to seize attention. He could not bear the thought of burning out alone, intending to go down with an explosion. Chances are, this is a direct result of Wilbur’s thirst for attention. During the Festival, Wilbur was at his most clear about his motives regarding attention, openly wondering if Phil would finally be proud of him.
TL;DR for this section: Wilbur cares for his family a lot. However, for reasons we are not aware of, it is very much likely that he faded into the background in the family dynamic as the relatively plain and typically responsible son. His subsequent lack of recognition from Phil would serve as one of the sparks driving his creation of L’Manberg, his arrangement for the Elections, and his large-scale TNT plot.
--
> 02. Trauma, Betrayal, and Distrust
Before the War for Independence, Wilbur displayed a high willingness to trust people. L’Manberg was formed on a basis of blind trust among its members, and Wilbur was very happy to let this happen, having had no reason to distrust any of his battalion. This would prove to be a mistake, as Eret would take advantage of his blind trust and betray the nation in one fell swoop, leading to what we consider to be a canon death among the majority of the group.
It would appear that the majority of the war traumatised Wilbur, judging by the memories that his ghost self cannot recall. He doesn’t remember Tommy’s duel with Dream, or the first detonation of the nation, or his initial plans to surrender – it would appear that it is all a sore spot. Notably, Wilbur doesn’t remember Eret at all, and I stand to claim that his betrayal was the most traumatising part of the War for Independence to Wilbur.
After the nation of L’Manberg claimed independence, Wilbur became less trusting. He would refuse to open the borders to non-Europeans at all, requiring they had express permission to step on L’Manberg soil. He was by no means a trusting Presidental candidate, either, constantly wary about where his political party stood in the elections.
These budding trust issues would only worsen with the later betrayals suffered in the Election. Schlatt is implied to have been a friend of Wilbur’s, because he was initially called in as a candidate to support POG2020. However, Schlatt backstabbed him, and formed a coalition government with his main political rival before immediately exiling him and Tommy upon winning the Presidency.
Eret’s betrayal still affected him, even then, as the man would offer the exiles support, only to be turned down repeatedly. Wilbur was still not ready to forgive – it would appear that he was ready for Eret to turn around at any moment and take advantage of their new vulnerable position. He actually seemed insulted at the idea that he should look for support side of the man who traumatised him so harshly.
Later, as an act, Fundy would disown Wilbur and burn down the flag. Unfortunately, Wilbur was unaware of its falsified nature, and so the act would serve to shatter his trust further – if his son was willing to turn traitor and backstab him, who was next?
I assert that the last straw for his initial psychotic break regarding trust is the announcement of the Manberg Festival, because during it, the majority of Manberg’s members seemed content with Schlatt’s rule. It would appear that everyone who had once claimed to support his revolution had turned their backs on him as soon as Schlatt became powerful, and so Wilbur went into a state of moral despair.
He came to the conclusion that nobody had ever truly been on their side, and that the people just follow after whoever is strongest. Even when making plans with Dream, Wilbur worked under the assumption that none of his allies were really on his side, and that even Dream had an ulterior motive regarding the destruction of L’Manberg. Wilbur knew that Dream only supported him because he was going to detonate his land – this didn’t bother him, though, because ultimately, what happened in the aftermath wasn’t going to be his problem (we will discuss the implications of that in the next topic).
Wilbur even prepared himself for the likelihood that Tommy or Tubbo would betray him, though when Quackity proposed the idea of Tommy betraying them, this caused distress to him – it would appear that despite his own despairing ideas of loyalty, Wilbur wanted to believe that he could trust in Tommy no matter what.
Tommy is the one person Wilbur struggled to keep around, through manipulative tendencies and light pleading. I assert that, if Tommy had left Wilbur, his character would have worsened – Tommy was the one person keeping Wilbur together, by the end of the corruption arc. (Despite his trust, it would appear that Wilbur resented his brother somehow, ultimately intending to pass on the Presidency to him in order to detonate the nation in front of him. Wilbur’s emotions surrounding Tommy were very conflicting, and it is very likely that he himself was conflicted on how he felt about his brother.)
TL;DR for this section: Eret’s betrayal was the one key event of the War for Independence that traumatised Wilbur most. He would become conservative with his trust, and later, with the betrayals of Schlatt and Fundy, Wilbur would spiral further into the ideology that loyalty does not truly exist. Tommy is the one exception to his lack of trust, and even then, Wilbur seemed to resent his brother.
--
> 03. Stress, Delusions, and Suicidal Tendencies
In Wilbur’s own later words, whenever he was not behind a podium, he would scream and cry into a pillow. Wilbur had happy moments as President, but it is now very clear that he went through a lot of emotional turmoil at the head of the fledgling nation. He was absent for a lot of the members’ key conflicts, likely implying he was either elsewhere handling issues or simply uncertain about how to carry himself as the leader of an entire nation.
He would only make appearances in order to complete formal tasks, or attempt to keep Tommy in line in his absences. One such key instance was during the Railway Hit-and-Run with Dream, in which Wilbur was forced to step in to avoid a second war breaking out between the feuding nations. Tommy would eventually fight anyway, though fortunately the escalation was halted before the conflict budded into warfare.
The effects of leadership and struggling to be respected would play on his decision to run an election, and his decisions during the election itself. I would assert that, before the Results, Wilbur was at his most stressed in the first Debate, which ultimately devolved into a screaming match between the two lead parties (and a lot of doubt from Fundy). Wilbur would end it himself, claiming nothing was getting done, and exiting the courtroom without further notice as a result of the cripplingly stressful nature of the situation.
The formality of the title of President led to Wilbur never bringing up his issues with stress in discussion, leading to him bottling them up. I don’t doubt that his later problems with depression would begin their roots here, in a milder form, especially with his admission that he would cry himself to sleep almost every night. President Wilbur was not alright, and this would only serve to worsen with his exile.
Wilbur hardly rested in Pogtopia, frequently completing menial tasks and going back out to Manberg on intel missions. Despite the commune lacking a hierarchy, he was the go-to-leader, and that likely took a toll on him mentally as he coped with the (potentially permanent) loss of his nation.
His trust-issues sparked psychotic break exacerbated the situation, piling the stress further on his shoulders – he now had to cope with the knowledge that he was alone, and he had nothing to fight for anymore. Wilbur deteriorated with this information, losing hope in a positive ending for him and coming to terms with the fact that his old nation had died at the hands of its own aspirations. Wilbur seemingly lost faith in himself, as well.
The conception of the Explosion Plot would bring forth suicidal tendencies in his character. His refusal to wear armour became something that implied he no longer placed any value in his own life anymore. Wilbur had wired the TNT Room up with several blocks laying inside the detonation chamber, implying he intended to explode with it.
This would be further confirmed in the room’s first reveal, when Tommy and Quackity talked him down – he was fully aware he would be trapped with the TNT, and he had made peace with that. I assert that Wilbur intended to die with his failed nation, believing them to be alike in a depressing way.
As his (likely) depression and his suicidal tendencies worsened, Wilbur emotionally detached himself from the revolution, falling into the ideology that their victory was never meant to be. Even when everyone sided against Schlatt, he was in the belief that re-taking the leadership by force was, well, tyrannical at best.
The anthem of L’Manberg itself had claimed the land to be free of tyranny, and by imposing a new age of blood-soaked leadership, it would no longer be true to its one aims. He would wander away from the group as they planned their takeover in a very sad manner, implying that he had succumbed to his despair and the fate he knew he would eventually come to. When he ultimately detonated the nation in front of Phil, he begged for his father to finally kill him in a final burst of suicidal intention.
Wilbur would assert that he was the only victor in the situation as he looked over the destruction, and in a way, this is true for the war – his plans did come to fruition in the way he wanted them to. It is possible that he asserted he was the only victor because he was dying, as well – he had achieved his final goal of finally burning with his nation, the way he intended to.
It’s difficult to decipher Wilbur’s mental state in his final moments before death – it’s very likely that he was not thinking straight at all, and that none of what he said should be taken as a significant truth.
His last few words would taunt Phil with the fact that Techno was the traitor, and then he would talk to himself, mocking Tubbo’s new administration in a final haze of delusion. They’d taken everything from him – his nation, his sanity, his trust, his kindness. I don’t doubt that he felt an overwhelming level of spite towards the living in his final moments.
TL;DR for this section: Wilbur experienced a lot of stress during his Presidency and the Elections, to the point where he would often cry himself to sleep. His depression worsened in his exile, spiking into suicidal desires after his psychotic break. Contrary to popular perceptions of the scene, Wilbur’s mental state did not clear up in his death, and he remained in a state of bitter delusion up until his passing.
--
> 04. Dying With Trauma - Dissociative Amnesia
Wilbur’s ghost – I will refer to him as Ghostbur in this section for ease of understanding – is, despite acting differently to his living self, still ultimately the same character. In his deathly state, Ghostbur lacks the majority of his negative memories, his mind covering them up with blank spaces and falsified cover-up information. He appears to suffer specifically from dissociative amnesia – a type of amnesia that can be caused or worsened by high levels of stress and trauma.
When asking Tubbo about his memories, Ghostbur quickly backed out of it, claiming he didn’t want to hear anything more. He seems to have a desire to separate himself from his living self’s actions, being deeply troubled at the idea and knowledge that he used to be a bad person. When Quackity tried to forcefully remind him of his detonation plot, Ghostbur resorted to a state of denial, proving that he struggles to cope with the truths of his missing memories.
It is believed that Ghostbur’s memory is actively deteriorating – he forgets quite sporadically, even forgetting when he wrote a book of his memories. It would appear that he is trying to clutch onto some of them with the creation of the ‘What I Remember’ book, though its ending of a hasty scribble and the phrase ‘I don’t know’ implies that the act of recalling for too long sends Ghostbur dangerously close towards a breakdown of some degree. It is possible that the creation of the book itself, and the act of forcing himself to remember for an extensive period of time, was emotionally damaging enough for Ghostbur to repress the memories of the book’s creation as well.
Ghostbur seems to experience some variation of depersonalisation regarding his living self, referring to him in the third person and requesting to be referred to with the Ghostbur nickname and not his living name. Ghostbur struggles with his identity seemingly, trying to spend time around others in a hopes of reclaiming who he is and subsequently finding out how to pass on peacefully. Ghostbur doesn’t seem to be aware of why he is still in L’Manberg as a spirit – he seems surprised at the assertion that he has unfinished business.
Ghostbur remembers his death – he remembers being stabbed by Philza. Notably, he referred to Phil as Philza only when describing how he was “stabbed to death” in his book of memories. He doesn’t seem to remember exactly why he was killed, and does not remember asking for it at all, implying that he doesn’t know anything about his mental state at the time. Ghostbur recalls a large explosion, but not its source, and failed to tie its happening to L’Manberg’s state as a crater.
His familial memories are fairly intact. He remembers Fundy, too – most people assert that he does not fully remember his son, and it is true that he has likely repressed his memories of Fundy’s betrayal. However, Ghostbur recognises his son rather easily, and remembers him growing up. Judging by how Ghostbur acts around Fundy, he’s still very fond of him, and strives to fix whatever Alivebur may have done to ruin their relationship.
It would appear that Ghostbur is still rather depressed, despite his strive to become better. Most of the time, he avoids large meetings, and uses invisibility potions to remain unseen. Ghostbur frequently vocalises that life has no meaning, so there’s no point in being anything but kind. He also speaks about death in a very depressing manner, describing it as a long road with an abrupt death, and asserts that there is nothing in the afterlife. Ghostbur has expressed that he likes being dead, because everyone seems to prefer him when he’s dead, but has vocalised that he doesn’t want to go back to the afterlife, and has occasionally contradicted himself by expressing an offhand desire to be resurrected.
TL;DR for this section: Ghostbur’s lost memories are a result of his lasting trauma, and not the act of dying. The reasoning for his further memory loss may be due to the association of the lost memories with some degree of mental stress. Ghostbur is experiencing some form of depersonalisation about his living self, and is still somewhat depressed about his state of being despite having already died.
--
> 0X. Conclusion (and Mock Diagnoses)
Wilbur Soot needs therapy. Wilbur Soot needed therapy even when he was still the President of L’Manberg. He’s been through so much as a character that it’s no wonder he snapped in the end. His corruption arc did not begin upon exile.
He has gone down a steady downhill path of rising trauma, trust issues, stress, and ultimately succumbed to his own suicidal desires. (Yes, it is true that he was not the one to kill himself, and Phil did, but don’t forget that he was the one to pressure Phil into doing it, and that he initially intended for there to be TNT in with him when he pressed the button. The explosion plot was an over the top suicide attempt.)
In his state of death, I predict that either Ghostbur will eventually snap upon the weight of his forgotten memories, or he will slowly forget everything and fade out of existence. He acts happy now, and claims to be at peace, but he isn’t – not really, in my perception. He’s still sad, and he’s still traumatised – he’s just locked the memories behind a wall of blankness.
There is absolutely zero chance that his character is/was not suffering from some degree of mental illness. It would appear that, in his “corruption arc” (when his spiral was at its fastest and most clearest), Wilbur’s displays had a lot in common with the symptoms of something like BPD (Borderline Personality Disorder). In order to be diagnosed with this particular disorder, the individual must experience three factors of the Impulsive type. In particular, I think Wilbur best expresses several of these factors, which are as follows:
> A marked tendency to act unexpectedly and without consideration of the consequences.
Wilbur often acted rashly in the latter parts of his life – for example, in the Manberg Festival, he would stride out in the middle of a post-massacre festival in order to confront Schlatt, wearing no armour on his back. He would consistently refuse to wear armour, and it could be argued that his entire explosion plot falls under this factor. It could also be argued that his pitting Tommy and Techno in fist combat against each other could fall under this, too.
> A marked tendency to engage in quarrelsome behaviour and to have conflicts with others, especially when impulsive acts are thwarted or criticized.
Wilbur frequently fought with Tommy and Quackity when his plots were called into question. Even before his psychotic break, he would argue with Tommy when he acted out. This would happen multiple times (I can presently think of three separate arguments, two of which were in response to criticism of Wilbur’s plans.)
> An unstable and capricious (impulsive, whimsical) mood.
Wilbur tips between being scarily gleeful at his plan, playfully discussing warfare and teasing at his plotted destruction, to turning desperate and angry, turning his anger on those around him, to turning almost melancholy, remarking on his lack of a home sadly and disconnecting himself from the rebellion around him. It’s hard to guess what mood he will be in most of the time.
This would-be diagnosis fits with the assertion that his character also potentially suffered from PTSD (Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder) to some degree after the War for Independence, and the idea that his ghost self (who does not fit these criteria solely because he has forgotten experiencing the triggers for them) experiences dissociative amnesia as the result of a spike in said PTSD after the Manberg Rebellion.
Take my diagnoses with a grain of salt, though – it was probably unintentional, and I am not a psychologist (yet - I can hope!). I encourage further research on the topic, if you get this far in the essay.
Thank you for reading. I hope my claims didn’t sound entirely insane. This is, effectively, a longer and more in-depth version of my shortened summary of character!Wilbur’s mental health issues that can be found on his character wiki page.
Posted Nov 23, 2020, 2:37 PM UTC