Buy a new front wheel or build one?

So I recently had one of my spokes pop off of my wheel. This isn't the first time it has happened to my front wheel, I've had the spokes pop out on three separate occasions. They always break off from the rim so I'm assuming it's the rim's problem. It is a Dura ace HB-7700 24h laced to an Velocity Aerohead. I want to get rid of the Aerohead and reuse my hub. But the problem is, I'm not sure if building one is going to cost more than just going out on craigslist and buying decent front wheel. I ride nearly everyday up to 20 miles on the road. I go over many bumps and potholes everyday and I'm wondering that if I do end up building a new wheel, what's the best rim with 24h?

Posted Aug 31, 2011, 8:44 AM UTC

314
dyebhai•

Rebuild it with a Kinlin rim and high quality, stainless steel spokes. If you can afford it, use double or triple butted spokes.

5
Demonkid549OP•

Thanks, I'll look into it. I've never built a wheel before, so are there certain types of spokes I should get?

1
dyebhai•

I prefer DT Swiss. Just use high quality spokes. Read Sheldon's article and that will get you through most of it. You'll probably have to pass it off at the end to somebody with a wheelstand and tensiometer.

2
[deleted]•

I think it's pretty obvious that you need more than 24 spokes on a front wheel.

3
dyebhai•

24 spokes is plenty for a front wheel on a road bike, unless you are a very large person or carrying heavy loads. Eventually spokes fatigue, and the failure of the first spokes encourages others to fail.

3
mbeels•

Although I think if he's breaking spokes, then it isn't enough. A properly built wheel, with the right number of spokes for the rider weight and road conditions should really last for many thousands of miles, practically forever for most bikers. Breaking spokes means something is wrong.

1
dyebhai•

Spokes breaking at the nipple is a sign of a poorly built wheel. 1

Spokes breaking at the hub is a sign of fatigue, the eventual end to all wheels. This is life. 24 is plenty strong.

1
mbeels•

Agreed, consider going with a 32 or 36 spoke build, or else you may end up having the same problems on your new wheel. It is odd that you're breaking spokes on the front wheel, usually the rear has more problems. The Aerohead is a fairly deep and unforgiving rim, a box section rim may be a better choice if you have lots of bad bumps and potholes in your area.

What guage spokes are you using? I agree with dyebhai, double butted spokes will cost more, but will actually be both stronger and lighter. Something like the Wheelsmith DB14 would be a good choice for many riders.

2
Demonkid549OP•

So it's a better idea to just buy a new wheel with more spokes on it then?

1
mbeels•

Or a new hub/rim/spokes, if you wanted to do your own build. That would be my suggestion.

2
Demonkid549OP•

Well, I don't have to build a new wheel. Whatever is the most cost efficient way to get me a new strong wheel. I figured that since I had an extra hub, I shouldn't just put it to waste.

1
AUBeastmaster•

DA hubs are the sexiest hubs around, save it if you can, build up a DT rim or mavic open pro rim with some thick gauge spokes.

2
much_cobblers•

No-one has asked if it's the spokes snapping or the nipple failing at the rim, this is an important distinction. If it's the nipples, are they alloy or brass and how old is the wheel? I'm suspecting by the quality and age of a 7700 hub you probably have alloy nipples that are just past their best and a rebuild could be all you need with brass nips this time for longevity.

1
bearskinz•

fornt wheels don't matter. relax.

1