helixguy"East Dartmouth"•

I suppose this is part of the system of rehabilitation, but damn does it ever make your blood boil too...

36
wagon13•

We seem to have a system of whichever comes first. Rehab or punishment. It makes the punishment aspect seem too small. It also makes it seem arbitrary which doesn’t seem fair either. My mind wanders to the extreme scenario; that if you revenge kill someone for say, killing a family member you cannot do that exact scenario again so rehab is already done, why bother punishing in the first place. Then we get to punishment. So to me prison sentences should be set and followed, not the lesser of because it seems absurd that some scenarios are lesser of punishment or rehab while others are only punishment.

1†

The kind of person that "revenge murders" is the kind of person that needs to be rehabilitated.

It's not about doing the same thing again (otherwise murderer would walk free) it's about making sure they can return to society and not be a danger.

5
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
Sure_its_grand•

Nice to see she doesn’t think she should be in prison because she has ‘nothing left to learn there’. She actively participated in murdering someone...maybe she still needs to learn there’s consequences for your actions?

22
bleakjHalifax•

Legit question;

Do you think anyone would be able to learn in that setting, or do you more so believe it's just punishment?

Because in cases like this, I'm not sure they're ever going to "learn" to be better, but probably become worse and more callous due to the system, so I'm left thinking, we either lock them up for good, or we really have to change the system in general

13
Sure_its_grand•

In a minimum security prison? Yes. We’re not talking the bleak prisons from tv here. It’s not necessarily about ‘learning to be better’. It’s accepting and understanding/being accountable for what you did and how it’s impacted others.

6
bleakjHalifax•

So if someone comes to that acceptance, would you say they should be let free when they learn that, or would you still have times attached?

What about the person who never comes to accept what they did was wrong, but has served their time? Do we keep them because of philosophical differences, or let them go because we think they're going to commit a similar crime again?

4
Sure_its_grand•

There should still be times attached but I don’t believe you should be let out early just because you have behaved well in a controlled environment if you have made no effort to be accountable for your crimes. And, if you’re not a dangerous offender, once you’ve done your time you’re free to go.

4
CivilizationIIIOP•

A great point. I suggest that her thinking she should be free shows that she has actually learned nothing.

11
wagon13•

Agreed

3
TheBigLev•

Let's be honest here... People who are capable of murder in a premeditated fashion (not just a mental break or some kind of passionate momentary rage) are people who have learned to totally discount any consideration for others in pursuit of their own self interest.

I don't know that this is a level that can ever be left behind. It shows such a complete disregard for empathy, sympathy, and basic decency that to me it seems likely such a person will always be incredibly self absorbed. I don't think we can ever expect these people to leave that behind. Only in rare scenarios do people truly deeply change, and I think we can usually recognize that. Anything else and it is obvious the person hasn't, as in this case.

To have the arrogance to say I can't learn more here clearly betrays the fact that this is all about them and their 'suffering', and it pretty much outright states that they consider themselves a victim now. Absurd as that is.

20
BlownWideOpen•

I knew this convict a few years before she was involved in the murder. She was an absolute delinquent and a pathological liar. She's very manipulative, and following the case from arrest to post-conviction, it's easy to see where she's been trying to game the system and succeeding. Can't imagine how the family of the victim feels about any of this.

19

I had a unfortunate event of meeting her also. Complete pathological liar. I met her in Burnside after the murder ( back in my Hard drinking days / breach for me) She refuses to even take any responsibility for her actions. But also this was before she was sentenced. Not sure if she ever figured out she can't lie her way out but looks like she's still trying.

6
BlownWideOpen•

Since she was sentenced, she's tried to appeal and withdraw her guilty plea. Safe to say she'll never figure it out. Knowing her, she sees herself as the victim in the situation. Truly a sick individual.

5
shj1985•

She's never been sorry, always with excuses and never accountability. Trash person.

9
Equal-Young3288•

We need major reform for both the judicial and corrections systems. I am constantly reading about offenders with multiple convictions going back years getting unbelievably light sentences making a mockery of our system. This sick monster helped murder a pregnant women and stuff her into a hockey bag and now she thinks the system should give her a break? What the fuck is wrong with us? Why not require those committing egregious offences to earn their way back into society by giving back to their victims and families. Put these assholes to work to and send the proceeds to the victims as compensation and/or to offset the cost of their offence?

8
sailorjasm•

You kinda read my mind or something. I was just about to write this comment before writing mine but prisoners also need some type of counselling or some type of mentoring so that they don’t continue with their same criminal lifestyle. I doubt it would happen though. I don’t believe the people will actually put in the effort and money to change the prison system. I guess most people like it how it is ? 🤷🏽‍♂️

3
tossedsalads4u•

Yeah, but you never really hear the success stories, do you? Heck, there's a prof at Dal who did time for murder as a young offender. The system could always be improved as it will probably never be perfect but it does help.

1
TheWalrusTalkss•

I'm fine with escorted absences. They are just an (escorted) taste of what she lost for the rest of her life. Based on the article, I would be surprised if she get parole at the earliest date.

1
ill-independentDartmouth•

so? prisons are garbage, you ever wonder why the recidivism rate is so high?

1