Twilight Zone (2019) is a teeth grating cringefest

This is just an angry rant. But I’m seriously disappointed watching season 1. Spoiler warning.

I’m not sure how some of these episodes made it out of the writing room. The Comedian was just okay. Nightmare at 30,000 feet was decent. But nearly every episode after that has way too much hamfisted social justice tones that is so in your face it’s laughable. I was hoping to find some thought provoking horror or sci-fi, but it takes a back seat to the show shoving down my throat the fact that I’m privileged and oozing toxic masculinity.

Replay took an interesting concept and put a hot button sensitive racial issue on top of it. I didn’t have too much of a problem with this episode until the end scene at the college campus. The whole situation they set up there is so contrived and unbelievable.

Wunderkind was an obvious statement about Trump and honestly that one was hilarious. Not All Men was halfway interesting but kind of a played out concept. I feel like the writers discovered A Color Out of Space just before they wrote it. The toxic masculinity thing was so on the nose it hurts. I cringed hard when the random guard at the end told the woman to “smile more often”. You know, during a literal rage virus outbreak. Are women constantly bombarded with men telling them to smile? And seriously, is it really that offensive? I don’t get it.

Point of Origin is an agonizingly terrible attempt to tackle the issue of immigration. I found it very bizarre to compare actual immigration issues in the US to interdimensional meta-humans migrating to a different dimension.

I’ve actually been putting off watching the rest of the show because this hardcore social justice stuff is so offputting to me. I’m certainly no opponent of bringing awareness to these topics, but is the Twilight Zone reboot really the appropriate medium to be doing this? The original show always had some food for thought or a moral lesson, but it was never this in your face about it. I’m hoping the writing gets better by season 2 but I’m not counting on it.

Am I nuts or has this show just gone completely off the rails in the wrong direction?

Posted Nov 28, 2020, 12:46 AM UTC

117
oasisraider•

I agree that this reboot is too heavy handed. The stories all seem to start out promising, but they have a turning point where they go from strong to weak very rapidly. As for the comparison of the originals, the social justice comments and morals of the originals were more nuanced and didn't club you with the message. I believe this reboot feels more Amazing Stories than Twilight Zone. That said I love Amazing Stories (at least First season) and was over all disappointed with its reboot as well.

6
daphometisgone•

You can critique the new show but complaining that it has unsubtle social justice tones makes it sound like you've never seen the original series

4
Deadsea_93•

Social justice tones in the original was well written and not this "Fuck you" kind of writing that this reboot has. Illegal aliens are really aliens ? White men are bad ! Racist cop out to get Black family ! Trump bad cause we have a kid as President to represent him ! We crashed a plane and somehow everyone survived and they beat to death White man as they are all not White and it is beautiful justice !

Yeah these tones are dumb as hell. Replay is nothing like Color The Night...I Am Black. As it is about a group of racists that try to lynch a Black Man

Point of Origin is nothing like The Gift, which has similar themes

I could go on and on. Rod Serling wrote political messages without polarizing an entire race. He Is Alive and Judgment Night were well written stories that didn't paint White men or cops as evil, he went after ideologies

3
Joe_V_879•

Well said! Serling was a real writer with class. Its seems that most TV shows today are worthless.

3
wes205•

I’m way late but it’s distressing how half the users on this sub don’t get this.

Just watched Point of Origin, an overall upsetting and uncomfortable glimpse into a despicable truth of our reality. Came here for discussion and almost every comment has been “the government probably had a good reason for ejecting other dimensional beings,” “unsubtle and predictable,” “keep SJW out of the writer’s room please!”

This show makes a certain type of person uncomfortable and unfortunately that’s the same type of person ready and willing to spew hatred online.

1
xBIGREDDx•

I think there's a general consensus that season 2 is better, so at least give it a try. I definitely thought it was an improvement.

2
sirphreaksalot•

Season 2 is better, at least as far as I've seen.

Honestly, just wait until you get to the finale of season 1. I may be reading it wrong but it almost comes off as an apology for what season 1 was, especially in regard to the overt politics without temperance. It acknowledges what Serling did, even to the point of social issues but it does frame a struggle to balance everything out correctly.

I'm 4 episodes in to season 2 and so far it's much better.

2
irishyardball•

The series was always about social commentary. Sounds like you might not agree with what they are pointing out doesn't make the show the bad.

1