Anyone playing mono green stompy?

Deck Help

This is the list I threw together just as a baseline.

4 Experiment One

2 Narnam Renegade

4 Strangleroot Geist

4 Avatar of the Resolute

4 Steel Leaf Champion

2 Barkhide Troll

4 Pelt Collector

2 Yorvo, Lord of Garenbrig

4 Rancor

4 Vines of Vastwood

4 Aspect of Hydra

2 Blossoming Defense

9 Forest

2 Treetop Village

4 Wooded Foothills

4 Windswept Heath

1 Oran-Rief, the Vastwood

But I wanted to know if there is a discord or if someone has a recent list.

Posted Nov 29, 2020, 1:21 AM UTC

2027
SpideyStrawhatThoughtseize, Aether Vial and Manamorphose•

This is my most recent list: https://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/20-08-20-monog-stompy/

A few notes:

  • Hexdrinker is your best 1 drop (and best creature in the deck) and unless it's out of your price range you should run 4. I only run 2 because it's my loaner deck and I don't really want to put more money into it. On a similar note, some number of Horizon Lands (usually Nurturing Peatland due to Dismember in the side) are pretty useful to avoid flood.
  • If you're going with fetchlands to use Narnam Renegade, you should go full 4 Narnam Renegades. When you run ways to trigger revolt consistently, it is your second best 1-drop.
  • After that, it's just 4x E1 vs 4x Pelt Collector. Usually is a playstyle preference and meta call. 12 1drops is the good number. Without fetchlands I'd just run both playsets, and maybe you should look into it: test a bit and see if Narnam Renegade payoffs the life-loss of fetches.
  • 3 drops are a trap and the only one you should be playing is 4x Steel Leaf Champion because it has evasion, it's chonky and it provides 3 green to devotion. Yorvo is easily chumpblocked, Rhonas can be disabled more easily than you can imagine and Dungrove Elder is too slow and makes your deck unable to run Horizon lands or Treetops.
  • For this reason, you are low on 2-drops. I suggest to remove the 2x Yorvo and either complete the Barkhide Troll playset or add Scavenging Ooze or Syr Faren, the Hengehammer. These two are meta-dependant (although I run both because I'm lower on NC spells): Ooze is better if you are facing aggresive decks, grindy midrange and graveyard focused decks, while Syr Faren is better if you expect to face combo, control (yeah, you're not going to win the long game against control, just cheese a win) and big mana a lot because it allows you to go under them and have some form of turn 3 "combo kill" (t1 1-drop, t2 syr faren op down to 18, t3 rancor + aspect / double aspect / geist + aspect into syr faren makes 18 damage). Growth-Chamber Guardian and Wildborn Preserver are also cute things I've experimented with in the Pioneer build but I think they don't make the cut in Modern.
  • Your list is also heavy on spells. I only run 4 Rancor and 4 Aspect and run more creatures but I can get behind running a couple of Blossoming Defense as well. IMO Vines of Vastwood is outdated tech and Defense is better unless you are facing a lot of Bogles, Infect and Saheeli combo due to the added utility of disrupting your opponent.
  • The Oran-Rief effect is too low impact for the cost of entering the battlefield tapped. Hashep Oasis is better if you want some kind of pump from utility lands.
  • As for the sideboard, my list is a bit outdated and low on GY hate and should be running 4 Relic of Progenitus or something like that but these options are as clean as you can get: Veil of Summer helps against interaction matchups, Finks is great against midrange, aggro mirrors and Burn, Ouphe and Sphere because you can't reliably beat Tron and Sphere also help against combo, Dismember when you need removal (it is much better than any fight spell) and Gemrazer because it works great with your game plan, has synergy with +1+1 counter creatures and you always need some form of artifact hate.
  • If you keep the fetchland route, you can add 1-2 Temple Garden for sideboard techs like Knight of Autumn, Gaddock Teeg, Rest in Peace, Aven Mindcensor or Archon of Emeria / Eidolon of Rhetoric. It opens a lot of routes.

Hope this helps! Let me know if you have questions, I'll gladly try to help.

16
YellowmagicmanOP•

Thanks! You gave me a lot of insight into the archetype. I wanna know what you think about cards like Lifecrafter's Bestiary and Shapers' Sanctuary for the sideboard decks like Jund/Heavy removal? Also what do you think about Smuggler's Copter? I would guess it's not the best because of Aspect of Hydra. Thanks again!

3
SpideyStrawhatThoughtseize, Aether Vial and Manamorphose•

Glad I've helped :)

I play Jund and those cards are good against it yeah. I'd also suggest Evolutionary Leap: turning every removal, chump-block or even mass removal into another card is pretty good when you can hold up the mana. More Finks, Ooze and also Thrun and Questing Beast are also good against Jund.

And yeah, unfortunately Copter dillutes Aspect of Hydra and you don't really want to get rid of anything. Stompy is a quantity deck and just wants to smash with creatures, so card selection is not really needed. It's not like there's an abysmal difference between Avatar of the Resolute and Barkhide Troll in most scenarios. The only upside of Copter in the deck is evasion (which is already pretty decent with Rancor, SLC and AoR) and avoid flooding (which you can get with Horizon lands and Treetop Village).

2

Re: Vines being outdated. Just pulled this bit from the hardened scales discord, but you can target an opponent's creature with Vines to save yourself from [[temur battle rage]] or other combat tricks. Definitely useful against all varieties of death's shadow and prowess decks

3
SpideyStrawhatThoughtseize, Aether Vial and Manamorphose•

Oh, definitely. That's why I said that it was good against Bogles (well, only Spiritdancer), Infect or Saheeli CopyCat. There are instances where Vines could be better but I think that in eficiency Blossoming Defense is just better, although both make a good work.

2
MTGCardFetcher•

temur battle rage - (G) (SF) (txt)
^^^[[cardname]] ^^^or ^^^[[cardname|SET]] ^^^to ^^^call

1

What are your thoughts about ghalta?

1
SpideyStrawhatDeath's Shadow•

Wow, it's been a while from this but fortunately my thoughts about Ghalta are the same that when it was printed: in Modern Stompy is a win-more card. If you have a board that allows you to cast it cheap you're better off using your mana that turn to pump the board and swing for lethal. And it's a terrible topdeck. Hexdrinker is the big fatty the deck wants to run, although now 2 copies of that is more expensive than the rest of the deck together lmao.

1
butchthedoggy•

Hexdrinker is your best 1 drop (and best creature in the deck) and unless it's out of your price range you should run 4.

I could not disagree more with this. 98% of the time Hexdrinker is going to be a vanilla 3 mana 2/1. What would stompy rather be doing turn 2? Paying 2 mana in an attempt to level up Hexdrinker, at which point it gets removed, we've wasted our mana, and have no threats on the board, or play 1 - 2 other threats (Dryad Militant, Scavenging Ooze, etc.) so that even if one gets countered/removed, we still have a threat on board?

Not to mention Hexdrinker simply does not fit in the gameplan- we can't afford to spend our entire allotment of mana leveling up Hexdrinker (even if we're successful). We need to leave mana up for Barkhide Troll protection, Blossoming Defence or Aspect of Hydra.

-2
SpideyStrawhatThoughtseize, Aether Vial and Manamorphose•

Yes. 98% of the time Hexdrinker is gonna be a vanilla 2/1 which is something that Stompy wants. Dryad Militant's ability was an added benefit, not a reasom to play her.

Hexdrinker doesn't force you to level it up. You do it when you have spare mana (including leaving mana up to protection). It also happens to be the best topdeck the deck can get when both players have traded resources.

Also, dying to removal is not an issue. Hexdrinker is an absolute bait and people HAVE to remove it at some point of the game. This is like "Stoneforge Mystic is bad against Burn because they Bolt her and don't allow you to land Batterskull". Well yeah, one Bolt less to face. Same happens with this: that Fatal Push is not going to be there for Scavenging Ooze or Steel Leaf Champion.

You can disagree and we can debate but saying that Hexdrinker, an aggresive cheap creatures that can grow itself and protect itself in some scenarios, doesn't fit the Stompy gameplan (fast, cheap, big, resilient theats) is straight up lying.

4
butchthedoggy•

Yes. 98% of the time Hexdrinker is gonna be a vanilla 2/1 which is something that Stompy wants.

So how is a vanilla 2/1 better than a 2/1 that hoses GY strategies?

-4
rhiehn•

What exactly is dryad militant hosing in the current modern meta? It does turn off mystic sanctuary, but if you're at the point where that's relevant, and you can stick a 1 drop, hexdrinker is better against those decks. Dredge will laugh at dryad militant, because that's almost never going to be good enough against them and the deck hardly sees play anyway. Both are usually vanilla 2/1s, but hexdrinkers bonus upside is relevant more often, that's pretty much the extent of it.

2

I run 2 [[groundbreaker]] as some of my 3-drops since it triggers pelt collector twice. [[Dryad Militant]] is also a good option.

10
MTGCardFetcher•

groundbreaker - (G) (SF) (txt)
Dryad Militant - (G) (SF) (txt)
^^^[[cardname]] ^^^or ^^^[[cardname|SET]] ^^^to ^^^call

1
butchthedoggy•

I run 4 Groundbreakers (at least game 1), and I cannot recommend them enough. They singlehandedly win me games

1
cgoldbach01•

Any chance you can share your full list?

1

3 Dryad Militant 4 Pelt Collector 4 Experiment One 4 Avatar of the Resolute 4 Strangleroot Geist 2 Barkhide Toll 2 Groundbreaker 1 Steel-leaf Champion 1 Yorvo 3 Aspect of Hydra 4 Rancor 4 Vines of Vastwood 3 Ram Through 18 Forest 3 Treetop Village

2 Tormod's Crypt 3 Veil of Summer 2 Blossoming Defense 2 Force of Vigor 2 Weather the Storm 2 Nissa, Voice of Zendikar 2 Mistcutter Hydra

I haven't done any testing in a few months. Would definitely want to run some scooze maindeck and some sort of fog effect in the SB

1
lupusromanus1990•

I actually just picked it up in paper as well and am hoping to find a discord or something as well

4
xkeeperx25•

I like a one of wolfier silverheart to add to a trampler for some large game destruction

3
Theloudestbelch•

I used to play big stompy with him and overrun as the top end. If you untap with a soulbonded Silverheart and an overrun in hand, its an 18 damage attack at least.

2
butchthedoggy•

Too expensive- Stompy wants to curve out at 3, not 5.

1
TonyGFool•

https://discord.gg/eQpypbMG

And yeah I’ve been playing it lately. Pretty successfully, actually.

1
butchthedoggy•

I run:

4x Experiment One

4x Dryad Militant

3x Avatar of the Resolute

4x Strangleroot Geist

4x Scavenging Ooze

4x Steel Leaf Champion

4x Groundbreaker

2x Blossoming Defence

4x Aspect of Hydra

4x Rancor

20x Forest

Dryad Militant hoses some decks G1 without even trying to (I've played several games where I play Militant turn 1 and my opponent goes "oh.... crap"), and is great for evolving Experiment One.

Same goes for Scavenging Ooze. Storm immediately becomes more difficult (for the Storm playet), Burn has a much tougher matchup, and any graveyard strategy becomes significantly easier to play against.

1
HermesLoki•

I have brewed this variation of stompy:
https://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/aggrocultural-evolution/

I would say that it utilizes eldritch evolution to gain resilience and flexibility in exchange for speed. That being said I wouldn't say it loses a lot of speed, it probably averages turn 4-5 kills when not interacted with. It just doesn't have some of the same cheesy turn 3 kills that are possible with syr faren and aspect of hydra. (Also, sorry about the massive maybeboard, although it goes to show I have put a decent bit of thought into the deck and also how flexible it can be. The sideboard is incredibly flexible and can easily change to adjust to whatever new meta there may be due to being able to run one of creatures to tutor with eldritch evolution.)

In terms of a more stock list this is probably what I would go with:
https://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/stock-stompy-1/

Obviously the sideboard is not quite fully fleshed out but I would consider what's there to be good options.

1
YellowmagicmanOP•

Very cool thanks! I'm a huge fan of having massive maybe boards so that way I don't need search scryfall every time I'm looking for a new card.

2
HermesLoki•

Glad to help. Also, glad that you posted this since it's pretty fun to chat about niche-ish decks that it sometimes feels like no one cares about. Thanks for letting me know I'm not the only one with a huge maybeboard! It's good to know I'm not doing something wrong.

1