(OC) Every city in the world with over 1M population. Details and link to interactive version in comments.

Posted Nov 29, 2020, 3:29 AM UTC

Posted Nov 29, 2020, 3:29 AM UTC
This map is a followup to https://www.reddit.com/r/MapPorn/comments/jt2tho/oc_every_city_in_the_world_with_over_100k/ as people wanted a map that showed cities with 1 million population or more. The data source is mostly from citypopulation.de, but some countries use Wikipedia and for this map in particular I cross-checked several other sources like worldpopulationreview especially as censuses are not frequent in some nations. I made this with Google My Maps; the link to this one is here: https://www.google.com/maps/d/u/0/viewer?mid=1gcfrhqE_jie2izq-vrFzSkqrmB5S2Vn_&ll=0%2C0&z=1 .
A lot of data-related questions are answered in the previous thread; in particular, I tried to use a city proper-type definition for each country if possible (i.e. metro or urban areas may be split between multiple cities). And again, if you notice any mistakes, please tell me. I will not maintain this map as much as the 100k map.
Make sure to check your info if reporting mistakes; many big cities like Vancouver will not be on the list since it uses city proper, not metro or urban area.
Update: added Austin, removed Amsterdam and Copenhagen
[deleted]
You're right, for some reason the source uses the entire capital region.
If it's by city proper, why are the Australian cities on the map? Sydney city proper has nowhere near 1 million as it only contains the CBD and adjacent neighbourhoods. It would be better to go by metro area population to control for varying approaches to local government across the globe.
There is no real city proper definition for Australia that I could find except LGAs which are clearly not equivalent to other countries' definition as each city is split into many tiny ones.
Amsterdam has less than a million. If you also consider urban areas, a lot more places should be on the map.
Unfortunately theres no other way to get sensible data for Netherlands and Australia.
I miss Brussels
Edmonton and Ottawa dont have over 1M though, they’re both still at 900k
citypopulation.de, my source has them both at around 1.025M. It's more than official estimates due to net undercoverage and that Indian reserves are underenumerated, apparently.
[deleted]
Austin, Texas has over 1 million
980k city proper, sorry
Alright, I guess I can put it in when I get back onto my computer tomorrow. I wasn't aware that the city itself had estimates.
It's understandable though. It happened less than 4 months ago, and it's only an estimate, so I can understand why places like World Population Rievew still have it at under 1 million. But I do expect the 2020 census to show it at over 1 million.
[deleted]
It's on the map, not sure what you mean
[deleted]
Missing a lot. Inconsistent. As usual.
Which ones do you feel are missing or inconsistent?
Common dude. Almost all of them are.
You used municipal borders so ALL of it is inconsistent. And then you have Copenhagen and Amsterdam on there, but not for instance Brussels or Naples.
I don't even want to know what you did with China.
I've already addressed Copenhagen and Amsterdam in other comments and have removed them from the interactive map. And the point of this map isn't to show urban areas as you can find that anywhere including at the website I used for data (citypopulation.de)
OK so you adressed 2 out of at least a 100 mistakes/omissions, do you want a cookie?
It's very easy to look up the municipal populations of Amsterdam and Copenhagen btw, don't know why it was a problem in the first place?
Now explain China?
Or Vietnam? Why is it only showing 2, where are the other 3?
Indonesia? There's 7, where are the other 13?
Should we go country by country?
quite useless without names next to red dots, I'd like to know the cities when i look at map
The point is to show density; you can use the my map if you really want to see the name of each city.
so you provide map of the cities but cities don't have names and ask me to use the other map next to it, very efficient...
I understand you used city proper, but I think it’s a bit misleading given how definitions of a city can vary from place to place. Places like Miami, Atlanta, or DC should really be on here but aren’t because of arbitary city limits
Fair enough but a lot of maps like ones that use metro or urban areas already exist.