In-game, intra-party conflict!

Need Advice

Hello fellow DMs!

So, last night, one of my players (we're in Avernus, to be specific) decided that it would be fun to pledge himself into Tiamat's service. To be honest, it does seem like something fun and cool to me as well but the issue is that another one of players is a steadfast and true paladin of Bahamut.

I'm not sure how this is going to resolve but it looks like a conflict betwixt the two players is inevitable. They're both cool guys and the former isn't meaning to be a jackass but it has created a bit of a pickle for me.

I didn't mean for this to happen. I tried to avoid the potential for intra-party conflict but this possibility had never occured to me. They were supposed to fear and avoid Tiamat, not swear their loyalty to her. I tried looking this one up already in this sub but I couldn't find anything useful. Any advice would be appreciated!

Edit: thanks for all the great advice! This is a great sub for DMs to give advice and act as sounding boards. Now I’m a lot less worried about letting this situation play out. I’ll keep you all posted about how it goes!

Posted Dec 1, 2020, 6:34 AM UTC · edited

216
Ghurdrich•

...Is your PC a violent fanatic? If not, consider the fact that people with differing beliefs work together all the time and are fine. Ultimately they won't get along, and when the adventure is done these adventurers will probably elect to part ways or settle their differences. But do you really think it's reasonable for this to burn your party up suddenly? Because it shouldn't. Your party is literally in hell slaying devils. It's going to be diffifult for your Tiamat-pledged character to reconcile their new loyalties with their quest, but it shouldn't push your party into pvp or anything.

In other words, conflict will probably be inevitable, but if your players are reasonable, it shouldn't be party-shattering PC-killing conflict. You should encourage your now-evil player to focus on explaining his decisions and motivations, rather than being a wangrod about it. Their character should have a reason for pledging their soul to eternal damnation. If they don't, then maybe they should reconsider their pledge.

8
Many_Bubble•

This is really solid advice, but I'd also recommend speaking to both players independently and maybe together and establish boundaries. Is PvP in the table? Is PvP to the death on the table? If any one of the players isn't okay with it then it shouldn't be an option. Ensuring everyone is on the same page with kinds and levels of conflict is important, but I agree this specific change shouldn't be much of an issue

3
i-dont-like-mages•

Inter party conflict doesn’t have to end in a good way. That being said, pvp should probably be avoided. If either the paladin or the other character should choose to leave the party, that would also be a fine option. Maybe the Tiamat pledged player no longer feels attached to their party as they once did.

That being said, working it out and reasoning with the paladin would also be a good option.

2
SpliceVariantOP•

This is all good advice but I feel that, in this particular case, they have immediate, opposing goals and conflict is inevitable. I discussed with one player so far, as you recommended, and pvp is on the table.

We’re all taking this as a game and in a fun spirit. It’s just that the player I discussed with is my eight year-old son, so I admit to being a teensy bit in favor of his character surviving the duel. Thankfully, the other player is his uncle and cool, so after getting all the great advice here, I’m content to let the story line (and dice) play out (although I may slip my son an extra healing potion... I don’t know!).

1
Ghurdrich•

I know you've accepted feedback and have the situation under control, and I fully respect that you know what you're up to, but I do have to pop in and say "My young child made a deal with a devil and now his adult uncle wants to kill his character" is a more compelling question and maybe might affect the feedback you receive :p

Best of luck!

3
SpliceVariantOP•

Ha! That is a good point, thanks. I’ll keep that in mind if I have future questions regarding this group.

Looking at comment, I realize I wasn’t clear. It’s my boy who’s the paladin. I wanted him to play a good character at this formative age and it’s my fickle brother who made a deal with a dark, dragon goddess.

I spoke with my son (‘the player I discussed with’) and he’s ok with having a fight with his uncle and is already planning to use hold person to end the battle before it begins (so proud!).

2
SirJuul•

Im taking my players through descent into Avernus, is that what you are doing? Because then there is almost no problem.

Tiamat and Bahamut are both enemies of the BBEG of Descent. Of course they dont like each other, but I cant help but thinking of siblings that torture each other. As soon as someone else bullies one of the siblings they unite, because "only I get to treat him like that!".

If it was my game I would bring them together out of game to talk about how this turns into the coolest thing possible.

6
SpliceVariantOP•

I am running DiA. I don’t know if the sibling analogy applies because, to me, the toy they’re fighting over is the prime material plane.

Tiamat’s freedom is a source of opposed, immediate goals, so a real potential for pvp. I don’t want them to work it out out-of-game because I feel the story potential is cool. They’re both cool guys who take the game ina fun spirit, so I’m not worried about real world rancor.

After all the great advice here, I feel a lot less worries about letting it happen. I figured out how Tiamat could be freed; now I’m unsure about the ramifications of freeing a dark, dragon goddess.

1
SirJuul•

That sounds cool and like some fun players.

I just read that it was your eight year olds character that made the pledge. Perhaps you could talk to your kid about how they would feel with the character becoming an npc at some point and a future enemy that they had to fight. It of course depends on your kid, but it might be something they thought was cool 😊

2
SpliceVariantOP•

This misinterpretation seems to be my fault. It’s my boy whose the loyal and steadfast paladin and I’m proud of him for refusing enticing deals with devils I’ve offered him.

That is a cool idea for the other character, though! It could be a good way out of this situation.

1
SirJuul•

Haha oh okay, my bad.

Please make an update when you have adventured your way through this, it sounds like anything you/and they chose will be a cool adventure.

2
agenhym•

Intraparty conflict can be one of the absolute best aspects of tabletop roleplaying. Two player characters debating, arguing, even competing against eachother is so much more tense and engaging than the party arguing against an NPC. But you've got to manage it very carefully - if your players are sensitive then their IC emotions can bleed into OC and cause all kinds of problems.

If you're confident that your players are cool and will both take the conflict in good faith, then you might not need to do anything. But if you're worried that they might get upset OC if the conflict escalates, then I'd suggest having a quick chat with both of them to set expectations and boundaries (like a mini session 0).

2
SpliceVariantOP•

This is great advice and I am taking it 100%. I’ll keep you posted how it goes!

2
FlyswatterActual•

Just let the dice decide who lives. A little pvp never hurt anyone, worst thing you can do imo is get in the way of some good RP.

-2†
SpliceVariantOP•

I don’t know why this comment got down-voted; I’d be curious to read why. I think this is good advice. Set up the world and let the players and dice tell the story.

In this case, though, the Tiamat-sworn is a 30-year old man (my brother) and the paladin is an 8-year old (my son). My son says he doesn’t mind fighting it out but he would be crushed if he lost his character (they’re 8th level already). I might slip an extra healing potion into his backpack... or maybe it’s a lesson on loss? I don’t know!

3